Can we ignore the time dependence in matter neutrino resonance?
Owais Ullah Faiz, Mushahid Hussain, Shashank Shalgar · 2025
Read Can we ignore the time dependence in matter neutrino resonance? by Owais Ullah Faiz, Mushahid Hussain, Shashank Shalgar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-19485.txt.
Introduction
Owais Ullah Faiz, Mushahid Hussain, and Shashank Shalgar ask whether the time dependence of matter neutrino resonance can safely be ignored. The resonance happens near neutron star mergers, where the neutrino self-interaction cancels against the matter potential and flavors can change. Earlier studies usually assumed the system settles into a steady state.
The authors run reproducible calculations both with and without time dependence and compare the flavor survival probabilities. The two approaches give qualitatively different answers, and the steady states from the simpler method prove unstable. Their result warns that physical readings of dense neutrino systems built on time-independent calculations need to be re-examined.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Owais Ullah Faiz, Mushahid Hussain, Shashank Shalgar |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-19485
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Can we ignore the time dependence in matter neutrino resonance? Owais Ullah Faiz, Mushahid Hussain, Shashank Shalgar Abstract In the vicinity of neutron star mergers (NSMs), it is possible for the neutrino self-interaction potential to cancel with the matter potential leading to matter neutrino resonance (MNR). MNR is one of the most interesting mechanisms by which neutrino flavor evolution can occur in dense astrophysical environments. Previous studies have typically assumed that the neutrino flavor field evolves to a steady state—a simplification also used in other self-interaction models such as the neutrino-bulb model. Here, we perform reproducible calculations of MNR using both time-independent and time-dependent formalisms and show that they yield qualitatively different flavor survival probabilities. The time-independent approach produces unstable steady-state solutions that differ fundamentally from the dynamical behavior captured in time-dependent simulations. These results demonstrate that the steady-state assumption is generally invalid, and physical interpretations based on time-independent calculations of dense neutrino systems require re-evaluation. keywords Neutrino Oscillations; Collective Neutrino Oscillations; Neutron Star Mergers. † † catchline: Vol. , No. () – 1 Introduction In dense astrophysical environments, neutrino flavor evolution acquires a new degree of phenomenological richness due to neutrino self-interactions – a potential experienced by neutrinos due to other neutrinos in the medium [ 1 ] . The evolution of neutrino flavor in such environments exhibits a collective evolution of neutrino flavor, that is, the evolution of the various momentum modes is correlated. The phenomenon of collective neutrino oscillations is non-linear in nature, and most of the progress in the field and our understanding is based on numerical simulations of the phenomenon that are extremely challenging [ 2 , 3 , 4 ] . In certain cases, known as fast flavor conversions, the time scale of flavor evolution can be extremely short, posing even more challenges from a numerical point of view [ 5 , 6 ] . Early investigations of collective neutrino oscillations primarily focused on the neutrino-bulb model – a spherically symmetric toy model designed to capture the essential physics of flavor evolution in the interior of core-collapse supernovae (CCSNe). Although this model provided valuable insights, it incorporated several idealized assumptions [ 2 , 3 , 7 , 4 ] . In particular, it assumes that all neutrinos decouple at a single radius and that their emission is perfectly spherically symmetric. More importantly, the formalism presupposes that the flavor field reaches a steady state after a sufficiently long evolution time. This assumption, though not initially recognized as problematic, was effectively built into the theoretical framework of the bulb model. Apart from supernovae, another environment where neutrino self-interactions become important is in the regions surrounding neutron star mergers (NSMs) [ 8 , 9 ] . A crucial difference between neutrinos emitted from supernovae and neutron star mergers is that in neutron star mergers, there is an excess of electron antineutrinos over electron neutrinos, unlike supernovae, where the situation is opposite. This leads to an interesting phenomenon of matter neutrino resonance (MNR), which results from the matter potential canceling the self-interaction potential, giving rise to resonant neutrino flavor conversion. [ 10 ] . The phenomenon was originally described in the single-angle approximations. In the single-angle approximation the dependence of the Hamiltonian on the angle is ignored. The effects of relaxing the single-angle approximation have also been studied [ 11 , 12 , 13 ] . To date, however, all multi-angle simulations of MNR have employed a formalism that assumes the flavor field evolves toward a steady state. In contrast, recent work on collective oscillations in supernovae indicates that the flavor field does not generally reach such a steady configuration [ 14 ] . This raises an important question: does the MNR phenomenon—described by similar equations of motion but under different initial conditions—also exhibit non-steady behavior? In this study, we find that although the MNR system appears to evolve toward a steady state, the steady-state solutions obtained from the time-independent formalism are intrinsically unstable. Even small perturbations drive the system away from these solutions, leading to dynamics that are fundamentally different from those captured by the full time-dependent treatment. In this paper, we use a simple multi-angle model of MNR to test the validity of the assumption of time-independent formalism in the context of multi-angle calculations of MNR [ 11 , 12 , 13 ] . We perform multi-angle simulations of MNR both with and without the time-independent assumption, and find that the two formalisms yield qualitatively different results. This implies that the widely used time-independent formalism is generally not valid. Moreover, the implications of this study extend beyond the MNR phenomenon: the same formalism has been widely applied to neutrino flavor evolution in supernovae through the neutrino-bulb model. Consequently, physical insights derived from such steady-state analyses warrant re-examination. Revisiting these foundational assumptions is essential for developing a more accurate understanding of neutrino flavor dynamics in realistic astrophysical environments. This paper is organized as follows: In Sec. 2 , we discuss the phenomenon of matter neutrino resonance with an emphasis on the distinction between time-dependent and time-independent formalism. In Sec. 3 we explain the numerical setup used in this paper, and in Sec. 4 we present the numerical results. In Sec. 5 , we discuss the implications of the numerical results and conclude. In addition, we present convergence tests for our results in A 1 1 1 The code used for the results in this paper can be found at https://github.com/shashankshalgar/MNRpaper2025 . 2 Formalism: Time-Dependent and Time-Independent Equations for MNR The numerical evolution of neutrinos experiencing MNR is difficult to model numerically due to the complex geometry associated with the problem. Attempts to investigate MNR using realistic potentials are limited to the single-angle approximation, due to the complicated geometry [ 15 ] . If the single-angle approximation is relaxed, then unrealistic symmetries have to be imposed to understand the phenomenon of MNR. One such attempt invoked an infinite disk that emits neutrinos along a particular opening angle [ 11 ] , and another attempt has assumed spherical symmetry for the MNR system [ 12 ] . Although neither approach is clearly justified, we use the former on account of its simplicity. The goal of this paper is not to model the neutrino transport in a system of neutron star mergers but to investigate the assumption of time-independence of the solution. In particular, we investigate the justification used in previous papers that calculates neutrino flavor evolution in the presence of MNR. In what follows, we first present the time-dependent formalism and then derive the time-independent equations from it. 2.1 Time-Dependent Formalism Throughout this paper, we restrict our analysis to the two-flavor approximation, in which the flavor states of neutrinos and antineutrinos are represented in terms of 2\times 2 density matrices. The diagonal components of the density matrix denote the occupation numbers, whereas the off-diagonal components contain information about coherence between the flavor eigenstates. Following the approach used in [ 11 ] , we perform the simulation in a narrow range of angles, \displaystyle\cos\theta\in[\cos\theta_{\mathrm{min}},\cos\theta_{\mathrm{max}}]\ . (1) Throughout this paper, we use a range for \theta that is centered at 45^{\circ} but various values for the range, \Delta\theta defined as |\theta_{\mathrm{max}}-\theta_{\mathrm{min}}| . This allows us to clearly see the effect of