Mapping the AI Divide in Undergraduate Education: Community Detection in Disciplinary Networks and Survey Evidence Journal: Computers & Education

Liwen Zhang, Wei Si, Ke-ke Shang, Jiangli Zhu, Xiaomin Ji · 2025

Read Mapping the AI Divide in Undergraduate Education: Community Detection in Disciplinary Networks and Survey Evidence Journal: Computers & Education by Liwen Zhang, Wei Si, Ke-ke Shang, Jiangli Zhu, Xiaomin Ji (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-19288.txt.

Introduction

Liwen Zhang and four co-authors map the divide in artificial intelligence skills across undergraduate fields at a leading Chinese university. As generated content reshapes how students learn, gaps between disciplines may harden into lasting inequities unless they are measured and addressed directly.

Course enrollment patterns form a network that splits students into four communities, from science-dominant to humanities and social sciences. A survey of about three hundred students shows science-dominant students score higher on generated-content literacy and motivation, while humanities peers lag. Regression analysis ties those gaps to disciplinary setting, pointing to where support should go first.

Catalog record

CREATORLiwen Zhang, Wei Si, Ke-ke Shang, Jiangli Zhu, Xiaomin Ji
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-19288

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Mapping the AI Divide in Undergraduate Education: Community Detection in Disciplinary Networks and Survey Evidence Journal: Computers & Education Liwen Zhang, Wei Si, Ke-ke Shang, Jiangli Zhu, Xiaomin Ji Abstract As artificial intelligence-generated content (AIGC) reshapes knowledge acquisition, higher education faces growing inequities that demand systematic mapping and intervention. We map the AI divide in undergraduate education by combining network science with survey evidence from 301 students at Nanjing University, one of China’s leading institutions in AI education. Drawing on course enrolment patterns to construct a disciplinary network, we identify four distinct student communities: science dominant, science peripheral, social sciences & science, and humanities and social sciences. Survey results reveal significant disparities in AIGC literacy and motivational efficacy, with science dominant students outperforming humanities and social sciences peers. Ordinary least squares (OLS) regression shows that motivational efficacy—particularly skill efficacy—partially mediates this gap, whereas usage efficacy does not mediate at the evaluation level, indicating a dissociation between perceived utility and critical engagement. Our findings demonstrate that curriculum structure and cross-disciplinary integration are key determinants of technological fluency. This work provides a scalable framework for diagnosing and addressing the AI divide through institutional design. 1 Introduction In an era where artificial intelligence is reshaping knowledge production, education is transitioning from knowledge transmission to intelligent collaboration ( Han et al., 2025 ) . Artificial Intelligence Generated Content (AIGC) is a technology that automatically generates multimodal content and is driving this transformation at an unprecedented pace. From the rise of ChatGPT to breakthroughs in models like Deepseek, AIGC has redefined the boundaries of AI applications in education and opened new pathways for personalised learning and higher-order cognitive development. Against this backdrop, information literacy ( Valeri, 2025 ) has evolved in the AIGC era to encompass not only traditional information acquisition and management capabilities, but also the ability to evaluate the value and risks of AI-generated content. In the context of the AI divide, disparities manifest in three dimensions: access, usage and evaluation. As a user-driven technology, AIGC emphasises the importance of usage and evaluation capabilities ( Lythreatis et al., 2022 ) . However, existing research has two notable gaps. Firstly, it has not clarified the link between motivational efficacy and AIGC literacy. Secondly, it has not systematically examined the transmission pathway of the education environment - motivation - literacy. Social constructivist theory suggests that learning communities formed through curriculum associations may shape individual motivation via group norms, thereby influencing AIGC literacy. However, the manner in which communities defined by curriculum similarity structure this relationship remains an unexplored area of theory. As one of China’s leading research universities, Nanjing University is a member of the C9 League and plays a pivotal role in the national "Double First-Class" initiative. The university has long been renowned for its commitment to educational innovation and academic excellence. Nanjing University won the Special Award in the selection of the 7th National Teaching Achievement Award for Higher Education with its project "Exploring the Path of Cultivating Top Innovative Talents in Comprehensive Universities" in September 2014. In September 2023, relying on its profound educational accumulation, Nanjing University launched the undergraduate AI curriculum reform and became the first university in China to build a full-chain curriculum system - from basic AI general courses for undergraduates, to AI interdisciplinary integration courses, and then to core courses focusing on cutting-edge AI technologies. As a representative university in undergraduate education in China, Nanjing University has a complete range of disciplines and aims to run the best undergraduate education in China. This initiative is a valuable case study for researching curriculum restructuring and content development in higher education. Its systematic approach has also created an ideal environment for analysing the relationship between curriculum and AIGC literacy. To address these gaps, this study employs community detection and questionnaire surveys to connect meso-level curriculum design with micro-level student literacy at Nanjing University. The research centers on two core questions: How are motivational efficacy and AIGC literacy manifested within communities identified through curriculum similarity? And how do such communities influence AIGC literacy, with what mediating role does motivational efficacy play? In theory, this research focuses on mapping the environment-motivation-literacy mechanism, offering a new perspective on the formation of the AI divide. In practice, it enables universities to establish dynamic monitoring systems to track students’ AIGC literacy development across different curricula, providing data to inform teaching adjustments. By doing so, it promotes the digital transformation of education, advancing it from empirical exploration to data-driven, precise practice. 2 Literature Review 2.1 AIGC and information literacy The rise of AIGC challenges the very foundations of learning ( Buchanan, 2005 ) . Education is undergoing a pivotal shift from knowledge transmission to intelligent collaboration – a transformation significantly driven by the rise of AIGC (Artificial Intelligence Generated Content). Artificial intelligence generative adversarial (AIGC) is defined as a production method that leverages AI technology to automatically generate digital content across a variety of media types, including text, images, audio, and video . It has evolved at an unprecedented pace, from the widespread attention initially sparked by ChatGPT 3.5 to the continuous breakthroughs of models like ChatGPT 4.0 and Deepseek ( Alqahtani et al., 2023 ) . In contradistinction to conventional AI applications in the field of education, its adaptable and intelligent interactive capabilities in teaching and learning scenarios offer novel pathways for the advancement of personalised education and the cultivation of higher-order cognitive skills ( Černý, 2024 ) ( Bazargani et al., 2025 ) ( Dibek et al., 2024 ) . Information literacy is the ability to use digital media to access, create, manage and critically evaluate information and to use it effectively for one’s own purposes ( Lau and Yuen, 2015 ) . Concurrently, the concept of information literacy has undergone a significant expansion in its scope and complexity ( Brata et al., 2022 ) . This evolution is particularly pronounced in the context of the AIGC era, which has introduced novel challenges and expectations, underscoring the need for a multifaceted approach to the development of information literacy ( Valeri, 2025 ) . Education now faces the imperative of equipping students not only with practical skills to operate AIGC tools (e.g., using AI for text creation or data analysis) but also with the capacity to evaluate the value and identify risks in AI-generated content (e.g., assessing credibility and ethical compliance). This will empower them to become "active masters" rather than passive users of intelligent technology. This urgency is further emphasised by scholars ( Zafari et al., 2022 ) , whose review of AI integration in K-12 education highlights the growing adoption of AIGC across grades and disciplines. From an educational equity perspective, AIGC literacy emerges as a critical lever to bridge generational gaps in technology adoption and promote balanced access to educational resources. The fundamental objective of this initiative is to empower individuals to master and ethically utilise intelligent tools and content value, thereby ensuring that technology serves as an engine for inclusive education rather than a catalyst for disparity. This, in turn, establishes the fundamental logic for education to respond to AIGC-driven transformations and cultivate innovative talent. 2.2 AI divide The connotation of the digital divide has evolved from an early binary classification

Read the complete text