Broadband Thermal Noise Correlations Induced by Measurement Back-Action
Jiaxing Ma, Thomas J. Clark, Vincent Dumont, Jack C. Sankey · 2025
Read Broadband Thermal Noise Correlations Induced by Measurement Back-Action by Jiaxing Ma, Thomas J. Clark, Vincent Dumont, Jack C. Sankey (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-19043.txt.
Introduction
Jiaxing Ma and three co-authors show that measurement back-action creates linked thermal noise across many vibration modes in modern mechanical sensors. Sensors now resolve the basic thermal noise floor over a wide band, not just near resonance, which speeds data taking and reveals brief signals once hidden.
Stronger measurement, though, pushes back on the device. The authors find that this back-action correlates noise from modes far apart in frequency, so measured spectra depart from standard single-mode and independent multimode predictions. Sensor designers must account for that coupling to read broadband data correctly.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jiaxing Ma, Thomas J. Clark, Vincent Dumont, Jack C. Sankey |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 25 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-19043
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Broadband Thermal Noise Correlations Induced by Measurement Back-Action Preprint: APS/123-QED Jiaxing Ma, Thomas J. Clark, Vincent Dumont, Jack C. Sankey Abstract Modern mechanical sensors increasingly measure motion with precision sufficient to resolve the fundamental thermal noise floor over a broad band. Compared to traditional sensors – achieving this limit only near resonance – this capability provides massive gains in acquisition rates along with access to otherwise obscured transient signals. However, these stronger measurements of motion are naturally accompanied by increased back-action. Here we show how resolving the broadband thermal noise spectrum reveals back-action-induced correlations in the noise from many mechanical modes, even those well-separated in frequency. As a result, the observed spectra can deviate significantly from predictions of the usual single-mode and (uncorrelated) multimode models over the broad band, notably even at the mechanical resonance peaks. This highlights that these effects must be considered in all systems exhibiting measurement back-action, regardless of whether the resonances are spectrally isolated or the readout noise is high enough that the noise peaks appear consistent with simpler models. Additionally, these correlations advantageously allow the thermal noise spectrum to reach a minimum – equivalent to that of a single mode – in a band far from the resonance peak, where the mechanical susceptibility is comparatively stable against frequency noise. The most sensitive mechanical measurements have traditionally relied on resonance to enhance signals above readout noise, in order to achieve thermally limited operation Saulson 1990 ; Bachtold et al. 2022 in a narrow band near the mechanical frequency. As readout techniques continue to improve, it is now increasingly common to achieve this fundamental noise limit far from resonance Numata et al. 2003 ; Kajima et al. 1999 , even with modern low-noise mechanical elements Fedorov et al. 2018 ; Cripe et al. 2019 ; Zhou et al. 2021 ; Cripe et al. 2019 . This broadband regime promises massive gains in the rate at which information is gathered, while also unlocking sensitivity to transient (and other broadband) signals that would have otherwise been obscured. Achieving this regime with modern sensors requires stronger measurement, meaning back-action (e.g., radiation pressure) necessarily plays a larger role. Usually this first appears as optical spring and damping effects Cuthbertson et al. 1996 ; Sheard et al. 2004 ; Arcizet et al. 2006 ; Aspelmeyer et al. 2014 , but one can also observe quantum fluctuations in the back-action forces Purdy et al. 2013 ; Teufel et al. 2016 ; Peterson et al. 2016 , even now over a broad band Cripe et al. 2019 . Here we show how this back-action serves to correlate the noise from many mechanical modes in a way that strongly impacts the observed thermal noise spectra over a broad band. Similar narrowband correlations have been observed near two degenerate resonances de Jong et al. 2022 and, by resolving thermal noise over the broad band, we reveal striking features involving a large number of modes – even those that are well-separated in frequency. Equally importantly, we find these effects are large even at the observed resonance peaks, where one might expect the resonantly enhanced response to dominate over the broad and comparatively small background from other modes. Because of this, these effects must be considered in all systems exhibiting such back-action effects, even in the presence of high readout noise, where well-isolated resonance peaks appear to behave consistently with traditional single- or multi-mode models. Finally, as a practical consideration, we find that the lowest force noise – approaching that of a single mode – advantageously always occurs near the bare mechanical frequency, allowing one to exploit the optical spring to shift unstable resonance peaks away from this optimal measurement band. Figure 1: Model for back-action-induced thermal noise correlations. (a) Canonical optomechanical system with a multimode mechanical system for one mirror. (b) Feedback loop describing (a), with one row per mechanical mode, each converting forces (including uncorrelated thermal noise \tilde{F}_{j} ) to displacements x_{j} through mechanical susceptibilities \chi_{\text{m},j} . The optomechanical coupling G converts the total \tilde{x} to detuning \tilde{\Delta} , and the cavity’s detuning susceptibility \mathcal{D} (just a constant in the fast-cavity limit) converts this to photon number \tilde{n}_{\text{cav}} , which finally applies radiation force -\hbar Gn_{\text{cav}} to all modes simultaneously, correlating displacements \tilde{x}_{j} . (c) Plot of expected thermal displacement noise amplitude spectrum \sqrt{S_{x}} including N =1,001 modes (black curve) of an ideal string with a cavity mode positioned at its center (frequencies \omega normalized by \Omega_{1} ). For this example, the cavity is driven by a red-detuned laser, applying anti-spring and shifting all modes to lower frequency. The blue dash curve includes only the fundamental ( j=1 ), which exhibits less shift. The red curve shows the result treating all N modes independently, but increasing G to match the fundamental resonance frequency, highlighting major broadband and (inset) resonant discrepancies. (d) Dividing \sqrt{S_{x}} by the total susceptibility to external forces (at the cavity spot) yields a force noise floor \sqrt{S_{F}} (black). The dashed blue lines represent the (structural) force noise Saulson 1990 for each individual mode. Importantly, the noise at the shifted resonance frequency (red dashed line) is significantly different than expected for a single mode. Moreover, the single-mode limit is approached at the bare mechanical frequency, far from the modified resonance, where the spectrum is comparatively insensitive to frequency noise artifacts. Model.— To see how back-action induced noise correlation (BANC) presents itself, consider the optomechanical system drawn in Fig. 1 (a), comprising a Fabry-Perot optical cavity in which one mirror is a flexible object with many mechanical modes (e.g., a membrane, string, ribbon, or cantilever), the combined motion of which modulates cavity resonance frequency \omega_{c} to create dispersive coupling G=\partial_{x}\omega_{c} Aspelmeyer et al. 2014 . This can be modeled by the feedback loop drawn in Fig. 1 (b), with mechanical modes (indexed by j ) independently driven by uncorrelated environmental (e.g., thermal) force noises of amplitude \tilde{F}_{j} at frequency \omega . With structural damping Saulson 1990 , a mode with inertial mass m_{j} , bare resonance frequency \Omega_{j} , and quality factor Q_{j} has susceptibility \chi_{\text{m},j}=\frac{1/m_{j}}{\Omega_{j}^{2}-\omega^{2}-i\Omega_{j}^{2}/Q_{j}} (1) that nominally converts \tilde{F}_{j} to uncorrelated displacement \tilde{x}_{j}=\chi_{\text{m},j}\tilde{F}_{j} (about equilibrium value \bar{x}_{j} ), but with the cavity driven to mean photon occupancy \bar{n} at mean detuning \bar{\Delta} from resonance, the optomechanical coupling G converts the summed displacement \tilde{x}=\sum_{j}\tilde{x}_{j} to detuning fluctuations \tilde{\Delta}=-G\tilde{x} that modulate the cavity photon number \tilde{n}=-\mathcal{D}\tilde{\Delta} according to the optical cavity’s detuning susceptibility \mathcal{D}(\bar{\Delta},\bar{n})=\partial_{\Delta}n Aspelmeyer et al. 2014 ; Clark et al. 2025 (just a constant in the fast-cavity limit \Omega_{\text{m}}\ll\kappa , where \kappa is the cavity’s energy decay rate). Finally, the optomechanical coupling factor \hbar G converts this fluctuation back to a radiation force applied to all modes in parallel, closing the loop and causing BANC. Combining the aforementioned transfer functions we arrive at a self-consistent linear system of equations, with the displacement of each mode l satisfying \tilde{x}_{l}=\chi_{\text{m,}l}\tilde{F}_{l}-\xi\chi_{\text{m,}l}\sum_{j}\tilde{x}_{j}, (2) where \xi\equiv\hbar G^{2}\mathcal{D} represents the strength of the back-action; in the fast cavity limit, this is just the optical spring constant. Solving this system for \tilde{x}_{l} (using the Sherman-Morrison equation) yields \tilde{x}_{l}=\chi_{\text{m,}l}\left[\tilde{F}_{l}-\eta\xi\sum_{j}\chi_{\text{m,}j}\tilde{F}_{j}\right] (3) with optomechanical “interference factor” \eta\equiv\frac{1}{1+\xi\sum_{k}\chi_{\text{m,}k}}, (4) such that the total displacement \tilde{x}=\eta\sum_{j}\chi_{\text{m,}j}\tilde{F}_{j}. (5) If the driving noises \tilde{F}_{j} are uncorrelated and