The Lensing Counter Narrative: An Effective Description of Small-Scale Clustering in Weak Lensing Power Spectra
Joseph DeRose, Shi-Fan Chen · 2025
Read The Lensing Counter Narrative: An Effective Description of Small-Scale Clustering in Weak Lensing Power Spectra by Joseph DeRose, Shi-Fan Chen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-18981.txt.
Introduction
Joseph DeRose and Shi-Fan Chen introduce lensing counterterms, a formal way to split large and small scale signals in weak gravitational lensing. Cosmic shear mixes clean cosmology on large scales with messy effects on small scales, such as gas feedback or possible new physics like axion dark matter.
By averaging over the new counterterms, analysts can keep the large-scale signal without cutting away small-scale data by hand. In a test modeled on a future survey, the gain in precision is large. The method also lets the small-scale part speak about feedback instead of being thrown away.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Joseph DeRose, Shi-Fan Chen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 99 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-18981
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Lensing Counter Narrative: An Effective Description of Small-Scale Clustering in Weak Lensing Power Spectra Preprint: APS/123-QED Joseph DeRose, Shi-Fan Chen Abstract We present a new formalism to separate large- and small-scale contributions to cosmic shear through lensing counterterms (LCT) inspired by effective field theory (EFT). Marginalizing over these LCTs isolates the large-scale cosmological signal in weak lensing power spectra while simultaneously constraining the impact of baryonic feedback or new physics (e.g. axion dark matter) at small scales. Our formalism removes the need for hard scale cuts in standard analyses, even when theoretical predictions are limited to below a physical cutoff Λ \Lambda , resulting in significant improvements in constraining power—up to 5 × 5\times smaller in the case of a LSST-Y10-like analysis without marginalizing over baryons when the analysis cutoff is set to Λ = 1.0 h \Lambda=1.0h Mpc -1 . We conduct a proof-of-principle analysis on the publicly available DES Y3 data, finding S 8 = 0.761 ± 0.045 S_{8}=0.761\pm 0.045 and S 8 = 0.794 ± 0.040 S_{8}=0.794\pm 0.040 for analyses with cutoffs of Λ = 0.5 h \Lambda=0.5h Mpc -1 and 1.0 h 1.0h Mpc -1 , respectively, with no detection of modifications to small-scale clustering at k > Λ k>\Lambda beyond the predictions of collisionless dark matter in a Λ \Lambda CDM universe. We make our JAX -based pipeline, gholax , integrated with intrinsic alignment predictions from the EFT of large-scale structure at 1-loop, publicly available. I Introduction Cosmic shear, the coherent distortion of galaxy shapes by weak gravitational lensing from the cosmological distribution of matter, is a powerful probe of the large-scale structure of the universe Bartelmann and Schneider 2001 ; Mandelbaum 2018 . Already, the current generation of weak lensing surveys Amon et al. 2022 ; Secco et al. 2022 ; Dalal et al. 2023 ; Li et al. 2023 ; Wright et al. 2025 ; Anbajagane et al. 2025 are able to place constraints on the clustering of dark matter—frequently summarized in terms of the parameter S_{8}=\sigma_{8}\sqrt{\Omega_{m}/0.3} —at the few-percent level, and imminent results from new surveys promise further, significant gains in constraining power LSST Science Collaboration et al. 2009 ; Euclid Collaboration et al. 2025 . Since the large-scale gravitational formation of structure can be precisely predicted from the initial conditions and particle content of the universe, these measurements enable us to put tight constraints on cosmological parameters and fundamental physics. The precision of coming weak lensing measurements presents formidable challenges to models of the cosmic shear signal. One particular challenge is that, while structure formation can be robustly predicted on large scales where gravity dominates, the clustering of matter on small scales is significantly influenced by collisional dynamics of hot gas, often referred to as baryonic feedback, driven by galaxy formation processes such as winds from supernovae and outflows driven by active galactic nuclei. This separation of scales is critical to analyses of galaxy clustering or cross-correlations between galaxy densities and weak lensing, where well-localized samples of galaxies can be analytically modeled using perturbation theory and effective field theory (EFT) techniques on large scales without having to account for the specifics of small-scale galaxy formation Ivanov et al. 2020 ; d’Amico et al. 2020 ; Chen et al. 2022 ; White et al. 2022 . On the other hand, weak lensing auto-correlations such as the cosmic shear signal are due to the total gravitational deflection of photons along the line-of-sight between source and observer, making the clean separation of large and small physical scales at a given angular scale difficult. Naively, the sensitivity of the cosmic shear signal to small-scale structure implies that contaminating astrophysical effects must be modeled with great care, and indeed many authors have noted the potential for their mis-modeling to bias cosmological inference Semboloni et al. 2011 ; Eifler et al. 2015 ; Chisari et al. 2019 ; Amon and Efstathiou 2022 ; Aricò et al. 2023 ; García-García et al. 2024 . Beyond purely astrophysical phenomena, many extensions to the dark sector (e.g. axion or interacting dark matter Rogers et al. 2023 ; He et al. 2023 ; Preston et al. 2025 ) also induce modifications to small-scale structure that can complicate parameter inference predicated on collisionless, cold dark matter. While the importance of properly accounting for contributions from small-scale structure to cosmic shear is well known, its optimal solution remains a matter of significant research. The most common, and perhaps most conservative approach is to cut out the signal at affected angular scales in practical analyses; this approach is relatively intuitive but (a) requires that the amplitude and scale-dependence of small-scale astrophysics be relatively well understood despite significant unknowns remaining in the literature Schaan et al. 2021 ; Hadzhiyska et al. 2025 ; McCarthy et al. 2025 , and (b) requires relatively stringent cuts since the line-of-sight projection in cosmic shear makes the translation between angular and physical scales rather inexact Truttero et al. 2025 . A different approach, which has seen significant progress in recent years, is to construct forward models that parameterize the impact of baryonic feedback, though this approach again relies on a reliable understanding of galaxy formation and/or sufficiently flexible parametric models Schneider and Teyssier 2015 ; Mead et al. 2015 ; Mead et al. 2020 ; Aricò et al. 2020 ; Wayland et al. 2025 . An alternative approach is to directly remove the contributions from small-scale structure at the level of the observable. Typically known as “nulling”, these methods utilize linear combinations of the observed signal, canceling out contributions from small scales, thereby removing the need to model them explicitly Huterer and White 2005 ; Bernardeau et al. 2014 ; Taylor et al. 2018 . Recently, ref. Piccirilli et al. 2025 proposed a nulling scheme in which small-scale modes are projected out based on their expected contamination, directly linking their nulling schemes to the expected small-scale contribution rather than relying on other metrics such as the compactness of the transformed lensing projection kernel. In this paper, we propose yet a different track inspired by EFT techniques, constructing an effective description of small-scale matter clustering that universally describes its impact on large angular scales for all weak lensing observables via a counterterm expansion. Similar methods have recently been proposed in the context of the 1D Lyman- \alpha forest power spectrum, which similarly involves an integral to small scales Garny et al. 2021 ; Ivanov 2024 . For fixed assumptions about the sizes of these corrections, our method is nearly equivalent to adding a theoretical covariance to the data, i.e. constitutes a formal way to down-weight cosmic shear data more impacted by small-scale nonlinearities equivalent to an optimal nulling scheme given those assumptions. Alternatively, we show that small-scale matter clustering enters into cosmic shear observables as an extra “noise,” and fitting the counterterms in this effective description allows us to constrain the clumpiness of matter below the cutoff scale. This new counterterm expansion, which introduces a compact way of marginalizing over small scale uncertainties weak lensing auto spectra, disentangles contributions to these spectra from large and small scales. This allows for a more complete extraction of information from the large scale data that can be modeled with