Clearing up the Strong C ​ P CP problem

Joshua N. Benabou, Anson Hook, Claudio Andrea Manzari, Hitoshi Murayama, Benjamin R. Safdi · 2025

Read Clearing up the Strong C ​ P CP problem by Joshua N. Benabou, Anson Hook, Claudio Andrea Manzari, Hitoshi Murayama, Benjamin R. Safdi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-18951.txt.

Introduction

Joshua N Benabou and four co-authors revisit the strong CP problem. A key angle in the theory must be tiny. If it were not, neutrons would show an electric dipole moment. Tests do not see one. That gap is the puzzle. The bound comes from neutron tests.

One set of answers uses parity as a gauged discrete symmetry. The authors argue the vacuum then keeps that symmetry. This holds despite recent claims to the contrary. They also answer claims that the problem is fake. A nonzero dipole, they show, follows from known dynamics.

Catalog record

CREATORJoshua N. Benabou, Anson Hook, Claudio Andrea Manzari, Hitoshi Murayama, Benjamin R. Safdi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE107 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-18951

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Clearing up the Strong C ​ P CP problem Joshua N. Benabou, Anson Hook, Claudio Andrea Manzari, Hitoshi Murayama, Benjamin R. Safdi Abstract The absence of a neutron electric dipole moment (EDM) constrains the quantum chromodynamics (QCD) theta angle to be less than one part in ten billion, posing the Strong C P problem. We revisit two classes of proposed solutions. First, we show that when P P or C ​ P CP is realized as a gauged discrete symmetry—as can arise in quantum gravity—the vacuum necessarily preserves C ​ P CP , contrary to recent claims that discrete-symmetry solutions fail. Gauged discrete models face model-building challenges, such as avoiding contributions to the neutron EDM after spontaneous P P or C ​ P CP breaking, but in principle have no fundamental obstructions. Second, we critically examine recent arguments that the Strong C ​ P CP problem is illusory, demonstrating that a nonzero neutron EDM at finite θ ¯ \bar{\theta} follows directly from well-understood QCD dynamics. Taken together, our results reinforce the reality of the Strong C ​ P CP problem and highlight gauged discrete-symmetry realizations of P P or C ​ P CP as plausible solutions. I Introduction The Strong CP problem provides one of the most promising avenues at present for learning about physics beyond the Standard Model (SM). The problem is experimentally manifest by the absence of a neutron electric dipole moment (EDM), which constrains the \bar{\theta} parameter of quantum chromodynamics (QCD), which we describe in detail below, to be |\bar{\theta}|\lesssim 10^{-10} Abel et al. 2020 (see Kim and Carosi 2010 ; Hook 2019 ; Safdi 2024 ; Bonanno et al. 2025 for reviews). Given that a priori \bar{\theta} could take values between -\pi and \pi and no additional symmetry of the SM is restored at the point \bar{\theta}=0 , this represents a fine-tuning problem. Moreover, this fine-tuning problem does not appear to have an anthropic explanation Ubaldi 2010 ; Dine et al. 2018 , which strongly motivates mechanisms that set the neutron EDM to zero. Broadly speaking, there are two classes of solutions to the Strong CP problem that evade fine tuning: (i) the axion, which is a new light degree of freedom that dynamically sets the neutron EDM to zero Peccei and Quinn 1977a ; Peccei and Quinn 1977b ; Weinberg 1978 ; Wilczek 1978 ; and (ii), symmetry-based solutions that use spontaneously-broken P or CP symmetry in the ultraviolet (UV) to keep \bar{\theta}\sim 0 in the infrared (IR) while also generating the CP violation observed in the Cabibbo–Kobayashi–Maskawa (CKM) matrix Nelson 1984 ; Barr 1984 ; Babu and Mohapatra 1989 ; Babu and Mohapatra 1990 ; Barr et al. 1991 ; Lavoura 1997 ; Vecchi 2017 ; Dine and Draper 2015 ; Hall and Harigaya 2018 ; Dunsky et al. 2019 ; Craig et al. 2021 ; Bonnefoy et al. 2023 ; Hall et al. 2025 ; Feruglio et al. 2024 ; Bonnefoy et al. 2025 . The second class of solutions benefit from the fact that \bar{\theta} evolves very mildly in the SM under the renormalization group (RG) Ellis and Gaillard 1979 . In both scenarios the Strong CP problem is associated with new physics, though only in case (i) does the new physics need to be light enough to be observable. A number of works have recently cast doubts on the Strong CP problem and its possible solutions. Refs. Ai et al. 2021 ; Nakamura and Schierholz 2023 ; Ai et al. 2022 ; Ai et al. 2024a ; Ai et al. 2024b ; Schierholz 2025a ; Schierholz 2025b , for example, argue that the neutron EDM is zero even for \bar{\theta}\neq 0 , such that there is no Strong CP problem whatsoever. These authors claim that traditional calculations suggesting a \bar{\theta} -dependent neutron EDM are mirages arising from an incorrect order of limits in the process of taking the infinite volume limit. Conversely, Refs. Dvali 2006 ; Dvali and Farrar 2008 ; Dvali 2022 ; Kaplan et al. 2025 argue that the Strong CP problem does exist but can only be solved by axions or related physics, as discrete symmetries can remove CP -violating terms from the Lagrangian or Hamiltonian but are not enough to guarantee that the QCD vacuum preserves CP . In this work we attempt to clear up the above confusion about the Strong CP problem. We argue that the Strong CP problem does exist and that it may be solved by discrete symmetries, though we argue that gauged P / CP are the most motivated ultraviolet (UV) discrete-symmetry-based solutions. This is because, as we show, gauged P or CP in the UV enforces the vacuum to be CP preserving, while also ensuring no P or CP violating operators in the Lagrangian. The gauged discrete symmetry must be spontaneously broken in the infrared (IR), but all contributions to the neutron EDM are calculable from the dynamics responsible for spontaneous P / CP breaking; in particular, there is no dependence of the neutron EDM on an otherwise unknowable superselection parameter for the QCD vacuum. Theories of gauged P or CP emerge naturally in the context of quantum gravity theories that involve compactified extra dimensions. The discrete symmetries arise below the compactification scale as the unbroken subgroups of the continuous, identity-connected Lorentz transformations of the higher-dimensional theory, in some cases in combination with unbroken internal symmetries. We illustrate this idea through a simple 5D toy model of QCD that leads to gauged P in 4D, and we also illustrate how gauged P and CP may arise in string theory. The rest of this work is organized as follows. In Sec. II we review the traditional approaches to describing the Strong CP problem, theta vacua, and computing the neutron EDM. Then, in Sec. III we show that to solve the Strong CP problem, P / CP have to be symmetries of all quantum correlation functions and not simply at the Lagrangian level, highlighting the case of gauged P / CP . We illustrate how gauged P can arise in the context of gauged Lorentz symmetry of a higher-dimensional theory through a simple 5D example in Sec. IV , and we discuss how gauged P / CP arise from the basic principle illustrated in the toy example in the context of more UV complete string theory constructions. In Sec. V we show definitively, for example using the Witten-Veneziano relation, that the Strong CP problem exists, and we point out the flaws in recent works stating that there is no such problem. Lastly, in Sec. VI we speculate that the entire discussion of e.g. Ref. Kaplan et al. 2025 about discrete symmetries not solving the Strong CP problem is in the swampland. We argue that in theories that emerge from quantum gravity the neutron EDM is always dynamically determined and does not depend on an otherwise unknowable superselection sector parameter. This is in part because quantum gravity theories are conjectured to gauge the Chern–Weil global symmetry associated with {\rm tr}F\wedge F Heidenreich et al. 2021 , with F the non-abelian field strength, for example through an axion-like-particle or p -form field, and gauging this current yields the QCD superselection parameter unobservable through gauge redundancy.

Read the complete text