Lieb-Robinson causality and non-Fermi liquids
Subham Dutta Chowdhury ♯ , Sean A. Hartnoll ♭ and Aditya Hebbar ♯ · 2025
Read Lieb-Robinson causality and non-Fermi liquids by Subham Dutta Chowdhury ♯ , Sean A. Hartnoll ♭ and Aditya Hebbar ♯ (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-18950.txt.
Introduction
Subham Dutta Chowdhury, Sean A Hartnoll, and Aditya Hebbar connect Lieb-Robinson causality with the physics of non-Fermi liquids. Lattice models with local, bounded interactions cannot spread influence faster than a set limit, and the authors show this limit forces a region where a key response function stays analytic.
Low-energy theories of strange metals must respect that microscopic limit. Checking two standard forms, the marginal Fermi liquid and the Hertz liquid, they find the constraint caps the strength of the non-Fermi liquid coupling in some cases. The result ties everyday causality limits to exotic metal behavior.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Subham Dutta Chowdhury ♯ , Sean A. Hartnoll ♭ and Aditya Hebbar ♯ |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-18950
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Lieb-Robinson causality and non-Fermi liquids Subham Dutta Chowdhury ♯ , Sean A. Hartnoll ♭ and Aditya Hebbar ♯ Abstract Quantum mechanical lattice models with local, bounded interactions obey Lieb-Robinson causality. We show that this implies a domain of analyticity of the retarded Green’s function G R ( ω , 𝐤 ) G^{R}(\omega,{\bf k}) of local lattice operators as a function of complex frequency ω \omega and momentum 𝐤 {\bf k} , similar to the lightcone analyticity property of relativistic field theories. Low-energy effective descriptions of the dynamics must be consistent with this microscopic analyticity constraint. We consider two canonical low-energy fermionic Green’s functions describing non-Fermi liquids, the marginal Fermi liquid and the ‘Hertz liquid’. The pole in these Green’s functions must be outside of the Lieb-Robinson domain of analyticity for all complex momenta captured by the low-energy theory. We show that this constraint upper bounds the magnitude of the dimensionless non-Fermi liquid coupling in certain Hertz liquids. We furthermore obtain, from causality, an upper bound on the magnitude | G R ( ω , 𝐤 ) | |G^{R}(\omega,{\bf k})| within the analytic domain. We use this bound to constrain the quasiparticle residue of the non-Fermi liquids. 1 Introduction Lightcone causality is, of course, a foundational principle in relativistic physics. The fact that local operators commute at spacelike separation implies analyticity properties of the S-matrix in relativistic quantum field theory [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 ] . See [ 6 ] for a summary of known results. Analyticity is a core ingredient in bootstrap approaches to quantum fields, as it connects high energy and low energy dynamics [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] . Retarded Green’s functions in relativistic theories enjoy similar analyticity properties through the Källén-Lehmann representation, and these have been used to bound dynamics in states where Lorentz invariance is broken by, for example, a temperature, charge density or magnetic field [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 ] . The Lieb-Robinson bound is a beautiful result that extends the notion of a lightcone to local lattice models with bounded interactions [ 20 ] . The starting point for this bound is that a localised operator evolves in time through repeated commutation with the lattice Hamiltonian. If the Hamiltonian is also local, then each commutation can only cause the operator to spread in space by a finite amount. The spatial growth of the operator is thereby bounded by the amount of time that has passed. A rigorous treatment of this effect — we will be using the formulation in [ 21 , 22 ] — shows that the time-evolved operator has exponentially small norm outside of a lightcone defined by the Lieb-Robinson velocity. The Lieb-Robinson velocity v is, up to numerical factors, the lattice spacing multiplied by the norm of the local terms in the Hamiltonian — see e.g. ( 5 ) below. It was argued in [ 23 ] that Lieb-Robinson causality could be used, in an analogous way to relativistic causality, to bound low-energy observables. In this paper we will obtain sharp causality bounds on low-energy observables arising from lattice models. Our first result provides the tools that we need. In ( 11 ) and in Fig. 1 below we establish a domain of analyticity of retarded Green’s functions, as a function of frequency \omega and momentum {\bf k} , in lattice models that are subject to a Lieb-Robinson bound. The domain restricts the imaginary parts of the frequency and momentum — see ( 6 ) below. At low frequencies and momenta the domain of analyticity is the same as that obtained for relativistic theories, with v the effective speed of light. However, at large imaginary momenta, greater than the inverse lattice spacing, the ‘lightcone’ becomes exponentially weaker. It is still present, however. Non-Fermi liquids are ubiquitous in strongly correlated materials, but continue to present a major theoretical challenge because they involve strong interactions between the electrons [ 24 , 25 , 26 ] . Non-Fermi liquids are often defined as exhibiting unconventional transport or thermodynamic properties [ 27 , 28 ] , but the most direct probe of the underlying electronic dynamics is angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) [ 29 , 30 ] . ARPES measurements reveal the electronic retarded Green’s function G^{R}(\omega,{\bf k}) , defined precisely in ( 1 ) below. In this paper we will show that the analyticity properties of G^{R}(\omega,{\bf k}) , following from Lieb-Robinson causality, constrain the space of possible non-Fermi liquid theories that can emerge at low frequencies. This paper will follow the ‘quantum lattice bootstrap’ methodology introduced in [ 31 ] . The logic is to start with an effective low-energy description as given, and ask whether there are microscopic lattice constraints on the parameters in the low-energy description. In [ 31 ] we obtained constraints from microscopic bounds on the spectral weight \text{Im}\,G^{R}(\omega,{\bf k}) . Here we will obtain constraints from microscopic causality. The most basic requirement is that any pole in the electronic Green’s function G^{R}(\omega,{\bf k}) must remain outside of the Lieb-Robinson domain of analyticity. In § 3 we review some canonical non-Fermi liquid Green’s functions, including the marginal Fermi liquid and a phenomenological generalisation of Hertz theory that we call a ‘Hertz liquid’. These models are assumed to pertain below some cutoff energy \Lambda . The parameters in the models are then the ‘quasiparticle residue’ {\mathcal{A}} , a dimensionless coupling \lambda and a renormalised Fermi velocity v_{F}^{\star} . Clearly one expects v_{F}^{\star}<v , although as we note in § 4 there is room for exceptions. Our second main result, in ( 25 ), is an upper bound on the coupling |\lambda| in cases where the fermionic excitation remains well-defined at the lowest energy scales but has a non-Fermi liquid decay rate (i.e. \omega<|\Sigma^{\prime\prime}(\omega)|<\omega^{2} as \omega\to 0 ). Our bound is consistent with ARPES data in overdoped cuprates, as fit in [ 32 , 33 ] . In cases with stronger departures from Fermi liquid theory at low energies all velocities are driven to zero at the lowest energies and there is no bound on \lambda from causality. In § 5 we obtain, using Lieb-Robinson causality, the bound ( 32 ) on the magnitude |G^{R}(\omega,{\bf k})| of the Green’s function within the domain of analyticity. This bound then implies our third main result, the upper bound ( 33 ) on the quasiparticle residue {\mathcal{A}} . The bound is, again, strongest for cases where the quasiparticle peak remains well-defined at the lowest energy scales. Roughly, if the pole in the Green’s function can come close to the domain of Lieb-Robinson analyticity, then the magnitude of the Green’s function within the analytic domain becomes too large unless the residue is small. In the discussion § 6 we extend our framework to the retarded Green’s function for the current operator. Within the Drude model of transport, we show that our upper bound on |G^{R}(\omega,0)| now leads to an upper bound on the dc conductivity. 2 Analyticity from Lieb-Robinson causality Let the operator \psi^{\dagger}_{\alpha} create a fermion at the site \alpha of a lattice, which is at position {\bf x}_{\alpha}