Semiclassical cosmic string evaporation

Robert Penna · 2025

Read Semiclassical cosmic string evaporation by Robert Penna (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-18948.txt.

Introduction

Robert Penna describes a semiclassical route by which a cosmic string can decay into a burst of gravitational waves. Cosmic strings are thin, dense lines that some early universe theories predict, and how they can vanish is a basic question for those theories.

Penna finds the tunneling solution, called an instanton, and computes the decay rate. Locally the solution matches an analytic extension of the Kerr metric, though no black hole is present. A striking point is that a cone-like flaw in the starting state is gone in the final state, showing flaws can vanish in quantum gravity.

Catalog record

CREATORRobert Penna
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE16 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-18948

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Semiclassical cosmic string evaporation Robert Penna Abstract We describe a new tunneling solution for the decay of a cosmic string into a burst of gravitational waves. We find the relevant instanton and compute the tunneling rate. Locally, our solution is just an analytic continuation of the Kerr metric (but there is no black hole in our solution). An interesting feature of our result is that there is a conical singularity in the initial state but there is no singularity in the final state. This demonstrates that singularities can disappear in quantum gravity in ways that are impossible in classical gravity. Nonperturbative results about quantum gravity are hard to come by. When they do appear, they are usually worth investigating. One class of examples we have in mind are the “bubble of nothing” solutions [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] , which show that simple Kaluza-Klein vacuums are unstable. Another class of examples are the black hole pair production solutions [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] , which shed light on the role of topology change in quantum gravity and give insight into the nature of black hole entropy. These are all examples of instanton-mediated tunneling processes. An instanton is a classical solution of the Euclidean signature equations of motion. It interpolates between two different field configurations (an initial state in the far Euclidean past and a final state on a surface of fixed Euclidean time). The action of the instanton gives the semiclassical approximation to the tunneling rate. In this note, we describe a new example of an instanton-mediated tunneling process in semiclassical gravity. In our solution, a cosmic string spontaneously decays into a burst of gravitational radiation. The cosmic string in the initial state is an infinitely thin thread. The metric has a conical singularity at the location of the string. The gravitational radiation in the final state, on the other hand, has no singularity. So our solution gives a clean demonstration that singularities can disappear in quantum gravity in ways that are impossible in classical gravity. An interesting feature of our solution is that, locally, it is just an analytic continuation of the Kerr metric 1 1 1 Different analytic continuations of the Kerr metric give different instantons. For example, there is an analytic continuation which is different from the one considered here which gives a bubble of nothing [ 2 , 3 ] . . Despite this, the physical interpretation is very different (there is no black hole). Although analytic continuation is used to get the solution, the metric is real valued. Our metric differs from Kerr globally because our angular coordinates have different periodicities. The Lorentzian endpoint of our solution was discovered long ago by Piran, Safier and Katz [ 11 ] . The gravitational wave burst in the final state has a pulse-shaped profile with a characteristic width, \tilde{a} . The tunneling rate we compute scales as e^{-(\cdots)\tilde{a}}\,. (1) In other words: the most narrow, sharply peaked bursts are favored all the way down to \tilde{a}=0 . In reality, we suspect this an artifact of the thin string approximation. If we give the string a finite thickness, the tunneling rate will probably turn over and have a maximum at a scale set by the string thickness. It would be interesting to try to check this. To get a nonzero tunneling rate, we need to make the spatial direction along the string periodic. Let 2\pi R be the length of the string. Our result for the tunneling rate is e^{-\pi\tilde{a}R(\alpha-1)}\,, (2) where \alpha=1/(4\mu) and \mu is the energy per unit length of the string. The fact that the rate vanishes in the R\rightarrow\infty limit harmonizes well with bubble of nothing calculations. There too, the rate of decay vanishes in the limit in which the size of the Kaluza-Klein circle becomes infinite. To make closer contact with Kaluza-Klein bubbles of nothing, it would be interesting to look for a generalization of our solution in five spacetime dimensions 2 2 2 There is a five dimensional analogue of the Kerr metric called the Myers-Perry metric [ 12 ] . It would be interesting to look for a five dimensional generalization of our solution based on the Myers-Perry metric. Actually, there already is a well-known instanton based on Myers-Perry but the physical interpretation is very different [ 10 ] . In the known construction, the time direction of the instanton comes from analytically continuing the Myers-Perry \psi coordinate. In our solution, on the other hand, the time direction of the instanton comes from analytically continuing the Weyl z coordinate of the Kerr metric in Weyl coordinates. So a good starting point for finding a five dimensional analogue of our solution would be to consider the Myers-Perry metric in Weyl coordinates [ 13 ] . . Then the spatial direction along the string could be identified with the fifth dimension of the Kaluza-Klein model. The string in the initial state of our solution is static but astrophysical cosmic strings (if they exist at all, or once existed) are not be expected to be static. Nonstatic strings can radiate through classical channels [ 14 ] . We expect these conventional modes of radiation to swamp any contribution from our semiclassical mechanism. We do not anticipate our tunneling solution to be relevant for astrophysical strings. We have already mentioned that our solution comes from an analytic continuation of the Kerr metric. It is interesting to match parameters. Our width parameter, \tilde{a} , is related to the spin parameter of the Kerr black hole by a=i\tilde{a} . In other words, we are studying the Kerr metric at pure imaginary values of the spin parameter. The string’s line energy density, \mu , is related to the mass and spin parameters of Kerr by \mu=\frac{\tilde{a}}{4\sqrt{M^{2}+\tilde{a}^{2}}}\,. (3) It is amusing to note that M=0 corresponds to \mu=1/4 (in units with c=G=1 ). It has been conjectured that this value of \mu is a fundamental upper limit on the energy density of strings set by general relativity [ 15 ] . Eqn. ( 3 ) shows that the “maximum tension principle” of the string is mapped to the zero mass limit of the black hole by analytic continuation. It is unclear if this fact has deeper significance or if it is just a curiosity. Our string has a third parameter, R , which is absent in the Kerr black hole solution. The reason for this is the following. 2\pi R is the length of the direction along the string. Under the analytic continuation we have referred to, this spatial circle is mapped to the imaginary time direction of the Kerr black hole. The latter has a well known periodicity related to the temperature of the black hole and it is completely fixed in terms of M and a . The reason it is fixed is that there is a regularity condition at the event horizon. Our solution has no horizon and thus no regularity condition to enforce. So the period of the circle enters as a third, independent parameter. We are now ready to discuss the calculation. Our starting point is the metric of the eternal cosmic

Read the complete text