The thesan project: Lyman- α \alpha emitters as probes of ionized bubble sizes

Meredith Neyer 1 ⋆ {}^{1\,\star}, Aaron Smith 2, Mark Vogelsberger 1,3, Luz Ángela García 4, Rahul Kannan 5, Enrico Garaldi 6, Laura Keating 7 · 2025

Read The thesan project: Lyman- α \alpha emitters as probes of ionized bubble sizes by Meredith Neyer 1 ⋆ {}^{1\,\star}, Aaron Smith 2, Mark Vogelsberger 1,3, Luz Ángela García 4, Rahul Kannan 5, Enrico Garaldi 6, Laura Keating 7 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-18946.txt.

Introduction

Meredith Neyer and six co-authors use the THESAN simulations to test whether Lyman-alpha emitters can reveal the size of ionized bubbles during reionization. Early galaxies lit up hydrogen gas around them, and the bright line they emit is easier to see when the bubble nearby is large.

The team builds realistic emitter catalogs with dust and gas outflow effects, matched to observed counts. Before the midpoint of reionization, galaxies in larger bubbles along the line of sight shine brighter in that line. The link fades as bubbles merge, but early on the emitter share works as a size tracer.

Catalog record

CREATORMeredith Neyer 1 ⋆ {}^{1\,\star}, Aaron Smith 2, Mark Vogelsberger 1,3, Luz Ángela García 4, Rahul Kannan 5, Enrico Garaldi 6, Laura Keating 7
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE76 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-18946

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The thesan project: Lyman- α \alpha emitters as probes of ionized bubble sizes Meredith Neyer 1 ⋆ {}^{1\,\star}, Aaron Smith 2, Mark Vogelsberger 1,3, Luz Ángela García 4, Rahul Kannan 5, Enrico Garaldi 6, Laura Keating 7 Abstract We use the thesan radiation-hydrodynamics simulations to investigate how Lyman- α \alpha emitters (LAEs) trace ionized bubble sizes during the Epoch of Reionization. We generate realistic LAE catalogs by combining accurate intrinsic Ly α \alpha production and intergalactic transmission with an empirical model for dust absorption and gas outflows. By calibrating to observationally-constrained Ly α \alpha luminosity functions, we reproduce the rapid decline in Ly α \alpha visibility toward higher redshifts while revealing mild tensions in LAE fractions near the end of reionization. Before the midpoint of reionization, galaxies within larger line-of-sight bubbles ( ≳ 10 \gtrsim 10 cMpc) have higher observed Ly α \alpha luminosity and equivalent width (EW), demonstrating that the evolving LAE fraction provides a practical statistical tracer for bubble size. These correlations weaken as percolation progresses and the IGM becomes increasingly ionized. In LAE selected samples with L Ly ​ α > 10 41.5 ​ erg s − 1 L_{\text{Ly}\alpha}>10^{41.5}\,\text{erg\,s}^{-1} , Ly α \alpha properties correlate with bubble size more strongly than UV magnitude, especially at z ≳ 7 z\gtrsim 7 . This simulation-based framework maps LAE selections to bubble-size statistics, clarifies biases in more idealized models, and will supply public catalogs to interpret current and forthcoming JWST and narrow-band LAE surveys in terms of the evolving topology of reionization. ⋆ E-mail: ][email protected] 1 Introduction Within the first billion years after the Big Bang, the Universe underwent a pivotal transformation known as the Epoch of Reionization (EoR). During this period, high-energy photons emitted by the first generations of galaxies ionized the surrounding neutral hydrogen gas in the intergalactic medium (IGM), gradually ending the cosmic dark ages ( Shapiro & Giroux 1987 ; Barkana & Loeb 2001 ; Furlanetto et al. 2006 ; Wise 2019 ) . The EoR occurred at redshifts of approximately z\approx 5-20 , which can be characterized by the formation and growth of ionized hydrogen bubbles around early luminous sources. These H ii regions expanded and eventually merged and percolated, leading to a fully ionized IGM as observed today ( Furlanetto & Oh 2016 ) . The evolving bubble size distribution as a function of redshift reflects how reionization progressed ( McQuinn et al. 2007 ; Neyer et al. 2024 ) . Higher-order spatial statistics reveal further details about the topology, e.g., imprinting whether reionization was driven by clustered sources in overdense regions or numerous faint galaxies. However, until tomographic maps are available it is crucial to constrain the properties of ionized bubbles with indirect measurements. One of the most promising observational probes of ionized bubbles at high redshift is the Lyman-alpha (Ly \alpha ) emission line, which originates from the transition of electrons in hydrogen atoms from the first excited state to the ground state. Ly \alpha photons are produced efficiently within star-forming galaxies due to the recombination of ionized hydrogen. These photons undergo a complex resonant scattering process that enhances dust absorption and alters their emergent spectral profiles ( Dijkstra 2019 ) , and at z\gtrsim 5 must traverse the surrounding IGM, which leads to further scattering out of the line of sight if they encounter partially neutral gas. A given galaxy embedded in a sufficiently large ionized bubble can transmit most of its Ly \alpha emission, whereas in a small bubble the line is strongly attenuated ( Miralda-Escudé 1998 ; Santos 2004 ) . As a result, the detectability of high- z LAEs is sensitive to the dust content affecting escape fractions, shape of pre-IGM spectral line profiles to determine the frequency-dependent transmission, and the ionization state of the surrounding IGM including the bubble size distribution and peculiar velocities setting resonant cutoff features ( Laursen et al. 2011 ; Dijkstra 2014 ; Gronke et al. 2021 ; Park et al. 2021 ; Smith et al. 2022a ) . Ly \alpha transmission is the basis for many recent studies that use LAEs as signposts of reionization. For example, the drop in the fraction of Lyman-break galaxies with detectable Ly \alpha between z\sim 6 and z\sim 7 has been interpreted as evidence for increasing IGM neutrality and smaller host bubbles ( Mesinger et al. 2015 ; Sadoun et al. 2017 ; Mason et al. 2018 ) . More direct inferences have come from analyses of Ly \alpha damping-wing absorption in spectra of galaxies and quasars. If a red damping feature is present, it signals a significant neutral column along the line of sight, whereas a sharp, unattenuated Ly \alpha profile suggests a large ionized region around the source. Especially in light of recent observations from the James Webb Space Telescope ( JWST ), this dichotomy of features can be interpreted within idealized models or simulations ( Huberty et al. 2025 ; Park et al. 2025 , e.g.) to place constraints on the reionization history of the Universe ( Asada et al. 2025 ; Mason et al. 2025 ; Umeda et al. 2025 ) . Furthermore, specific cases of very high-redshift observed galaxies have shown unexpectedly strong Ly \alpha emission indicative of very large ionized bubbles ( Hayes & Scarlata 2023 ; Endsley & Stark 2022 ; Endsley et al. 2024 ; Witstok et al. 2025 ) , and already test models even with a few objects. While it is clear that evolving bubble sizes influence the potential for LAE visibility, interpreting Ly \alpha observations in terms of bubble sizes is non-trivial and highlights the need for further theoretical calibration of Ly \alpha -based probes. The simple picture of a galaxy surrounded by a spherical bubble of ionized gas can be complicated by several factors, including the intrinsic luminosity and galaxy scale radiative transfer, scattering in the circumgalactic medium and infall regions, the presence of residual neutral hydrogen within the bubble, and the 3D inhomogeneous density and velocity structure of the IGM. Many studies still employ the idealized spherical models to estimate the minimum bubble size required for a given Ly \alpha transmission fraction or to infer the IGM neutral fraction from damping wing absorption profiles. While these analytic approaches yield order-of-magnitude estimates, they can suffer from degeneracies and oversimplifications ( Huberty et al. 2025 ; Lu et al. 2025 ) . In reality, the IGM during reionization is clumpy and the ionized regions have irregular, evolving shapes that can be used with a more robust synthetic observation approach to correct for model shortcomings ( Keating et al. 2023 , e.g.) . Comparisons of increasingly self-consistent radiative transfer modeling with real data enables us to learn potential biases that are important to account for when using LAEs to trace ionized bubbles in the EoR and the large-scale cosmology. In this paper, we pursue such an approach using the thesan suite of state-of-the-art radiation-hydrodynamical (RHD) simulations that of the EoR ( Kannan et al. 2022a ; Garaldi et al. 2022 ; Smith et al. 2022a ; Garaldi et al. 2024 ) . thesan combines the galaxy formation physics of the IllustrisTNG model with on-the-fly ionizing radiation transport using the arepo-rt code ( Kannan et al. 2019

Read the complete text