Testing Risk Difference of Two Proportions for Combined Unilateral and Bilateral Data

Jia Zhou, Chang-Xing Ma · 2025

Read Testing Risk Difference of Two Proportions for Combined Unilateral and Bilateral Data by Jia Zhou, Chang-Xing Ma (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-18834.txt.

Introduction

Jia Zhou and Chang-Xing Ma develop statistical tests for clinical studies of paired organs, such as eyes or ears, where outcomes from the two sides of one patient are correlated. Some patients contribute both organs and others only one, mixing unilateral and bilateral data, and the question is whether two proportions, say success rates under two treatments, truly differ.

Working under a model with constant within-patient correlation, the authors build three likelihood-based tests: a likelihood ratio test, a Wald-type test, and a score test. Simulations showed all three kept false-positive rates under control with comparable power, the score test being slightly more stable. The methods are illustrated on ear and eye study data, and an online calculator supports power analysis and testing. The authors recommend the score test for practical work with such mixed paired data.

Catalog record

CREATORJia Zhou, Chang-Xing Ma
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-18834

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Testing Risk Difference of Two Proportions for Combined Unilateral and Bilateral Data Jia Zhou, Chang-Xing Ma Abstract In clinical studies with paired organs, binary outcomes often exhibit intra-subject correlation and may include a mixture of unilateral and bilateral observations. Under Donner’s constant correlation model, we develop three likelihood-based test statistics (the likelihood ratio, Wald-type, and score tests) for assessing the risk difference between two proportions. Simulation studies demonstrate good control of type I error and comparable power among the three tests, with the score test showing slightly better stability. Applications to otolaryngologic and ophthalmologic data illustrate the methods. An online calculator is also provided for power analysis and risk difference testing. The score test is recommended for practical use and future studies with combined unilateral and bilateral binary data. Keywords: Combined unilateral and bilateral data; Donner’s ρ \rho model; Risk difference; Likelihood ratio test; Wald-type test; Score test 1 Introduction In comparative clinical studies, binary outcomes are commonly used to assess treatment efficacy or disease occurrence, where each observation represents a dichotomous event such as success/failure or cured/uncured. In many medical applications, particularly those involving paired organs, such as eyes and ears, responses are measured bilaterally. In practice, however, datasets often contain a mixture of unilateral and bilateral observations, as some subjects contribute paired organ data while others provide only a single measurement. Such imbalance may arise due to prior surgical removal, congenital absence, or missing measurements in one organ. Analyzing these combined unilateral and bilateral data jointly, rather than excluding unilateral cases, is essential to avoid loss of information and to reduce potential bias in statistical inference. A key challenge in analyzing bilateral outcomes lies in appropriately accounting for the intra-subject correlation between paired organs. Several statistical models have been proposed to handle this correlation. Rosner [ 1 ] introduced the “constant R ” model, which assumes equal dependence between paired organs within an individual and tests for equality of proportions across treatment groups. Dallal [ 2 ] identified limitations of Rosner’s model when the marginal prevalences differ substantially between groups and proposed an alternative model assuming a constant conditional probability of response in one organ given the other. Donner [ 3 ] later developed a constant correlation model that parameterizes the intra-subject dependence through a single correlation coefficient \rho , which Thompson [ 4 ] demonstrated to be robust through simulation studies. Moreover, Clayton [ 5 ] proposed a general model for association in bivariate data using the Clayton copula, which expresses the joint distribution of two variables in terms of their marginal cumulative distribution functions and a dependence parameter. Although originally developed for bivariate survival or event-time data, the Clayton copula model can be extended to correlated binary outcomes and has been applied in paired organ studies to capture intra-subject dependence [ 6 , 7 ] . Building on these correlation structures, numerous likelihood-based methods have been developed for inference with correlated binary data. For instance, Tang et al. [ 8 ] and Pei et al. [ 9 ] proposed asymptotic methods for testing equality of proportions between two groups. Ma and others [ 10 , 11 ] investigated three asymptotic tests (likelihood ratio, Wald-type and score) for testing homogeneity of proportions among g\geq 2 groups. Other studies have considered relative measures, such as relative risk and odds ratio, and their interval estimations have been studied under different correlation models, with or without stratification (e.g., see [ 12 , 13 ] ). While tests for equality of proportions have been extensively studied, practical research questions often concern the difference in risk (or proportion) between two treatment groups, referred to as the risk difference . Compared with relative measures such as odds ratio or relative risk, the risk difference provides a more direct and interpretable measure of treatment effect, especially in clinical and public health contexts where absolute risk reduction is of primary interest [ 14 ] . It also forms the basis for important inferential quantities such as the number needed to treat (NNT) [ 15 , 16 ] . Several studies have examined inference procedures for the risk difference in correlated binary data. Pei et al. [ 17 ] compared three methods (profile likelihood, asymptotic score and Wald-type with three estimated variances) for constructing confidence intervals for differences in proportions in a two-arm randomized trial. More recently, Sun et al. [ 18 ] studied various confidence intervals of common risk difference in stratified unilateral and bilateral data based on the Dallal’s model. In this paper, we focus on testing the risk difference between two proportions under Donner’s constant \rho model. We derive three likelihood-based test statistics: the likelihood ratio, Wald-type, and score tests, respectively, to evaluate their performance through extensive simulation studies. To facilitate practical implementation, we also develop an online calculator for power analysis and hyptohesis testing using user-supplied data. The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 presents the construction of the three likelihood-based test statistics under Donner’s model. Section 3 reports numerical results, including simulation studies (Section 3.1 ) evaluating empirical type I error rates and powers, and two real-world applications in otolaryngologic and ophthalmologic studies (Section 3.2 ). Section 4 concludes the paper. 2 Methods Let Z_{ijk} denote the response of the k -th ( k=1,2 ) paired organ of the j -th subjet in the i -th ( i=1,2 ) group, where Z_{ijk}=1 indicates the occurence of a particular condition (e.g., the organ is cured or affected) and Z_{ijk}=0 otherwise. For the unilateral portion of the date, each Z_{ijk} ( k=1 or k=2 ) follows a Bernoulli distribution. For the bilateral portion of the data, the vector \boldsymbol{Z}_{ij}=\left(Z_{ij1},Z_{ij2}\right)^{T} follows a paired Bernoulli distribution. Let m_{ri} denote the number of bilateral subjects in the i -th group who have r~\left(r=0,1,2\right) organs cured (or affected), and let n_{ri} denote the number of unilateral subjects in the i -th group who have r~\left(r=0,1\right) organs cured (or affected). Then, \displaystyle m_{ri}=\sum_{j=1}^{m_{+i}}I\left(Z_{ij1}+Z_{ij2}=r\right),\quad r=0,1,2, \displaystyle n_{ri}=\sum_{j=1}^{n_{+i}}I\left(Z_{ijk}=r\right),\quad r=0,1;~k=1\text{ or }2, where m_{+i}=m_{0i}+m_{1i}+m_{2i} and n_{+i}=n_{0i}+n_{1i} are the numbers of the subjects contributing bilateral and unilateral observations in the i -th group, respectively. The data structure can be summarized as a combination of a 3\times 2 contingency table for the bilateral portion and a 2\times 2 contingency table for the unilateral portion, as shown in Table 1 . Table 1: Frequency table for number of cured (or affected) organs for subjects in g groups. # of cured or affected organs group 1 group 2 total 0 m_{01} m_{02} m_{0+} 1 m_{11} m_{12} m_{1+} 2 m_{21} m_{22} m_{2+} total m_{+1} m_{+2} m_{++} 0 n_{01} n_{02} n_{0+} 1 n_{11} n_{12} n_{1+} total n_{+1} n_{+2} n_{++} The proportion of organs that are cured (or affected) in the i -th group is assumed to be Pr\left(Z_{ijk}=1\right)=\pi_{i} . Under Donner’s constant \rho model [ 3 ] , the intra-subject correlation satisfies {\mathrm{Corr}}\left(Z_{ijk},Z_{ij,3-k}\right)=\rho . Therefore, given m_{+i} and n_{+i} in the i -th group, the counts \left(m_{0i},m_{1i},m_{2i}\right) follow a trinomial distribution, and \left(n_{0i},n_{1i}\right) follow a binomial distribution, \left(m_{0i},m_{1i},m_{2i}\right)\sim Trinomial\left(m_{+i},p_{0i},p_{1i},p_{2i}\right),\quad n_{1i}\sim Binomial\left(n_{+i},\pi_{i}\right), (1) where the joint probabilities p_{ri} ’s ( r=0,1,2 ) are given by \displaystyle p_{2i}=Pr\left(Z_{ij1}=1,Z_{ij2}=1\right)=E\left(Z_{ij1}Z_{ij2}\right)=\pi_{i}\left(\pi_{i}+\left(1-\pi_{i}\right)\rho\right), (2) \displaystyle p_{1i}=\sum_{k=1}^{2}Pr\left(Z_{ijk}=1,Z_{ij,3-k}=0\right)=2\left(\pi_{i}-p_{2i}\right)=2\pi_{i}\left(1-\pi_{i}\right)\left(1-\rho\right), \displaystyle p_{0i}=Pr\left(Z_{ij1}=0,Z_{ij2}=0\right)=1-p_{1i}-p_{2i}=\left(1-\pi_{i}\right)\left(1-\pi_{i}+\pi_{i}~\rho\right). Consequently, the log-likelihood as a function of \boldsymbol{\beta}=\left(\pi_{1},\pi_{2},\rho\right)^{T} can be written as

Read the complete text