A Detailed Chemical Analysis of the Red Giant Orbiting Gaia BH3: From Lithium to Thorium This paper includes data taken with the Harlan J. Smith 2.7m telescope at The McDonald Observatory of The University of Texas at Austin. Facilities: Tull Coudé Spectrograph on the 2.7m HJST at McDonald Observato
Zoe Hackshaw, Keith Hawkins, Catherine Manea · 2025
Read A Detailed Chemical Analysis of the Red Giant Orbiting Gaia BH3: From Lithium to Thorium This paper includes data taken with the Harlan J. Smith 2.7m telescope at The McDonald Observatory of The University of Texas at Austin. Facilities: Tull Coudé Spectrograph on the 2.7m HJST at McDonald Observato by Zoe Hackshaw, Keith Hawkins, Catherine Manea (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-18757.txt.
Introduction
Zoe Hackshaw, Keith Hawkins, and Catherine Manea chemically dissect the red giant star that orbits Gaia BH3, the most massive known black hole of stellar origin. The giant is extremely poor in metals, and its chemistry may reveal whether the pair formed together or was assembled later by a capture. Using a high-resolution spectrograph on a telescope at McDonald Observatory, they measured abundances for twenty-nine elements, from lithium to thorium.
The star proved enriched in alpha elements and carries the signature of rapid neutron-capture processing at a moderate level. Crucially, no element deviated from the pattern expected of an ordinary halo red giant of its type, so chemistry alone does not decide between the capture and isolated-formation stories. An upper limit on thorium also let the team bound the system's age using the thorium-to-europium ratio as a radioactive clock.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zoe Hackshaw, Keith Hawkins, Catherine Manea |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 62 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-18757
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Detailed Chemical Analysis of the Red Giant Orbiting Gaia BH3: From Lithium to Thorium This paper includes data taken with the Harlan J. Smith 2.7m telescope at The McDonald Observatory of The University of Texas at Austin. Facilities: Tull Coudé Spectrograph on the 2.7m HJST at McDonald Observatory ( Tull et al. 1995 ) astropy ( Astropy Collaboration et al. 2022 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2013 ) , BACCHUS ( Masseron et al. 2016 ) , iSpec ( Blanco-Cuaresma et al. 2014 ; Blanco-Cuaresma 2019 ) matplotlib.pyplot ( Hunter 2007 ) , numpy ( van der Walt et al. 2011 ) scipy ( Virtanen et al. 2020 ) , TSDRP , TURBOSPECTRUM ( Plez 2012 ) , https://github.com/grzeimann/TSDRP Zoe Hackshaw, Keith Hawkins, Catherine Manea Abstract Preliminary astrometric data from the fourth data release of the Gaia mission revealed a 33 M ⊙ dark companion to a metal-poor red giant star, deemed Gaia BH3. This system hosts both the most massive known stellar-origin black hole and the lowest-metallicity star yet discovered in orbit around a black hole. The formation pathway for this peculiar stellar-black hole binary system has yet to be determined, with possible production mechanisms that include isolated binary evolution and dynamical capture. The chemical composition of the stellar companion in G a i a Gaia BH3 (hereafter BH3 ⋆ \star ) can help constrain the potential formation mechanisms of this system. Here, we conduct the most comprehensive chemical analysis of BH3 ⋆ \star to date using high resolution spectra obtained by the Tull Coudé Spectrograph on the 2.7m Harlan J. Smith Telescope at McDonald Observatory to constrain potential formation mechanisms. We derived 29 elemental abundances ranging from lithium to thorium and find that BH3 ⋆ \star is an α \alpha -enriched ([ α \alpha /Fe] = 0.41), r-I neutron-capture star ([Eu/Fe] = 0.57). We conclude that BH3 ⋆ \star shows no chemical peculiarities (defined as deviations from the expected chemical pattern of an r-I halo red giant) in any elements, which is in alignment with both the dynamical capture and isolated binary evolution formation scenarios. With an upper limit detection on Th, we use the Th/Eu chronometer to place limits on the cosmochronometric age of this system. These observations lay the groundwork for heavy-element chemical analysis for subsequent black hole and low-metallicity stellar binaries that will likely be found in Gaia DR4. I Introduction Stellar-mass black holes serve as key laboratories for probing both stellar evolution and compact object formation ( Strader et al. 2012 ; Morscher et al. 2015 ; Abbott et al. 2016 ; Bambi 2025 ) . Dormant black holes in binaries are especially valuable, as the luminous companion can help constrain the black hole properties without the observational challenges introduced by accretion-driven emission. If the companion star is metal-poor, its spectrum preserves the chemical imprint of early nucleosynthetic events, offering a window into the chemical conditions of the early universe ( Sneden et al. 2008 ; Roederer et al. 2018 ; Frebel 2018 ) . Studies of such systems can provide critical constraints on the environments in which the first generations of stars formed. Preliminary Gaia DR4 results revealed a 33 M ⊙ dark companion in an 11.6-year, eccentric ( e=0.73 ) orbit with a metal-poor 0.8 M ⊙ red giant star ( Gaia Collaboration et al. 2024 , hereafter BH3 \star ;) identified through Gaia astrometry and confirmed with the Radial Velocity Spectrometer ( Cropper et al. 2018 , RVS;) . This system, deemed Gaia BH3, is located \sim 590 pc away in the Galactic halo and shows no detectable emission from the black hole, with only upper limits observed in the radio ( Sjouwerman & Blanchard 2024 ) , infrared ( Kervella et al. 2025 ) , ultraviolet ( Sbarufatti et al. 2025 ) , and x-ray ( Gilfanov et al. 2024 ; Cappelluti et al. 2024 ) . The lack of electromagnetic radiation across all wavelengths supports the interpretation of the dark companion being a dormant black hole in a binary with a low-metallicity star. While two other dormant black holes in binaries have been previously discovered with Gaia data ( El-Badry et al. 2023a ; El-Badry et al. 2023b ; Chakrabarti et al. 2023 ; Nagarajan et al. 2023 ; Tanikawa et al. 2023 ) , this system is particularly unique. It is the most massive stellar-origin black hole known to date, making it a valuable laboratory for studying hierarchical black hole formation and the possible seeds of intermediate-mass black holes, especially in the low-metallicity regime ( Belczynski et al. 2016 , e.g.,) . This is the lowest metallicity star found in a binary with a black hole, and consequently, this system can provide constraints on stellar evolution in the early universe ( Merritt et al. 2025 , e.g.,) . Another unique aspect of the Gaia BH3 system is its association with the halo stream ED-2, making this the first black hole to be found in a disrupted star cluster ( Balbinot et al. 2024 ) . ED-2 is a cold (low velocity dispersion) stream currently passing through the solar neighborhood on a highly retrograde orbit ( Dodd et al. 2023 ; Balbinot et al. 2023 ) . Balbinot et al. 2024 proposed that the ED-2 progenitor was a star cluster due to the low dispersion of metallicities among ED-2 stars. Dodd et al. 2025 reported 22 chemical abundances of BH3 \star and other ED-2 stars using the Ultraviolet and Visual Echelle Spectrograph ( Dekker et al. 2000 , UVES;) and supported the conclusion that ED-2 originated as an ancient star cluster. We expand on this work by reporting more heavy element abundances with higher signal-to-noise (SNR) spectra of BH3 \star , using these elements to place a cosmocrhonometric age limit on this star, and confirming the lack of chemical peculiarities in BH3 \star . Parameter This Work Gaia+24 Dodd+25 T eff [K] 5416 \pm 84 5212 \pm 80 5445 log g 3.00 \pm 0.14 2.929 \pm 0.003 3.037 [Fe/H] -2.27\pm 0.24 -2.56\pm 0.11 -2.34 [ \alpha /Fe] 0.42 \pm 0.17 0.43 \pm 0.12 0.40 \xi [km/s] 1.54 \pm 0.11 … 1.60 Table 1: Stellar Parameters of BH3 \star This black hole is the first of its kind located in a disrupted star cluster, and as such the formation pathway of this kind of system is still an open question. There are two main hypothesized formation pathways for Gaia BH3: isolated binary evolution or dynamical capture. In the isolated binary evolution scenario, the two stars would have been born together and remain bound even after the event that created the black hole. Iorio et al. 2024 , using models of evolved stellar binaries, concluded that Gaia BH3 could plausibly have formed through isolated binary evolution, only if the natal kick was mild enough to reproduce the orbital parameters found in Gaia Collaboration et al. 2024 . However, El-Badry 2024 argued that the black hole would have formed with a significant natal kick that likely would have ejected the system from ED-2. Given Gaia BH3’s association with a disrupted star cluster, the density of stars could have caused BH3 \star to be dynamically captured in the orbit