Teacher transfers: equalizing deficits across schools
Debasis Mishra Soumendu Sarkar Arunava Sen · 2025
Read Teacher transfers: equalizing deficits across schools by Debasis Mishra Soumendu Sarkar Arunava Sen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-18708.txt.
Introduction
Debasis Mishra and his four co-authors design a fair way to move teachers between government schools in India. A 2009 law sets required student-teacher ratios, and one approved remedy is redeploying teachers from schools with a surplus to schools with a deficit. Teachers may stay put or move to an acceptable school that needs them, and a planner must judge outcomes by the pattern of deficits left behind.
The authors prove that one achievable outcome beats every other in a strong fairness sense called Lorenz dominance, meaning it equalizes deficits as much as possible. They give a two-stage algorithm that computes that outcome, and they show the algorithm is strategy-proof: no teacher can gain by misreporting which schools are acceptable. The work turns a legal mandate into a concrete, manipulation-resistant assignment procedure.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Debasis Mishra Soumendu Sarkar Arunava Sen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 83 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-18708
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Teacher transfers: equalizing deficits across schools Thanks: For comments and suggestions, we are grateful to Tommy Andersson, Anna Bogomolnaia, Julien Combe, Bhaskar Dutta, Albin Erlanson, Manshu Khanna, Vijay Krishna, Herve Moulin, Abhiroop Mukhopadhyay, Sanket Patil, Antonio Penta, Debraj Ray, Olivier Tercieux, Utku Unver and Mike Woodford, and seminar participants at conferences and workshops where the paper was presented. Thanks: Mishra: Indian Statistical Institute, Delhi, [email protected] . Sarkar: Delhi School of Economics, [email protected] . Sen: Indian Statistical Institute, [email protected] . Sethuraman: Columbia University, [email protected] . Yadav: University of Liverpool, [email protected] Debasis Mishra Soumendu Sarkar Arunava Sen Abstract The Right to Free and Compulsory Education Act (2009) (RTE) of the Government of India prescribes student-teacher ratios for state-run schools. One method advocated by the Act to achieve its goals is the redeployment of teachers from surplus to deficit (in teacher strength) schools. We consider a model where teachers can either remain in their initially assigned schools or be transferred to a deficit school in their acceptable set. The planner’s objective is specified in terms of the post-transfer deficit vector that can be achieved. We show that there exists a transfer whose post-transfer deficit vector Lorenz dominates all achievable post-transfer deficit vectors. We provide a two-stage algorithm to derive the Lorenz-dominant post-transfer deficit vector, and show that this algorithm is strategy-proof for teachers. Keywords: matching, teacher transfer, Lorenz dominance, network flows. JEL Classification: C78; D47; D71 1 Introduction The equitable allocation of resources is a fundamental concern in economics. It is well-known that various equity criteria can be satisfied in models where resources are perfectly divisible. However, several problems are discrete in nature and only allow for integral solutions. Our objective in this paper is to show that an existing equitable solution for perfectly divisible resources can be extended to a discrete problem of practical interest. The Right to Education Act in India, 2009 (henceforth, RTE) was enacted by the Union Government to improve the quality of school education in India. 1 1 1 For an overview of the act, see https://dsel.education.gov.in/rte . The Act identified student-teacher ratios in schools as a key determinant of the quality of education and clearly mandated the minimum number of teachers to be deployed relative to student strength. For historical reasons, some schools had teachers in excess of the desired student-teacher ratio while other schools had a deficit of teachers. In addition to fresh hiring, the Act mandated the transfer of teachers from surplus to deficit schools. According to Section 22 of the RTE: “…The sanctioned strength of teachers in a school shall be notified by the Central Government, appropriate Government or the local authority…The Central Government, appropriate Government or the local authority, as the case may be, shall …. redeploy teachers of schools having strength in excess of the sanctioned strength….” The implementation of the RTE Act was largely left to the various states in the Union of India. The government of the state of Haryana was especially proactive in the matter of teacher transfers and its policies are enunciated in two documents ( Government of Haryana 2016 and Government of Haryana 2023 ). According to the vision statements of both documents, the aim of its policies are “ … to ensure equitable, demand based distribution of teachers/heads to protect academic interest of students and optimise job satisfaction amongst its employees in a fair and transparent manner” . Our paper is an attempt to design a theoretical framework to achieve the goals articulated in the vision statement. 2 2 2 Sharan et al. 2022 and Agarwal et al. 2018 contain empirical analyses of teacher transfers in Haryana: see also Section 6 . We formulate the teacher transfer problem as a network flow problem where teachers have trichotomous preferences. We show that fairness and efficiency of outcomes can be defined in a natural and unambiguous way. Finally, we show that these “fair outcomes” can be achieved by a strategy-proof mechanism. Though we consider teacher transfer as our application, we note that our model and results apply more broadly to environments involving transfer of resources. For instance, civil servants assigned to states are transferred periodically; (multi-tasking) workers are transferred across departments in firms; doctors are transferred within states to meet shortages in hospitals. We consider a set of teachers and a set of schools. Each school is either a surplus school or a deficit school, depending on the number of teachers currently assigned to it and its target number of teachers. Prior to transfers, every surplus school is associated with a strictly positive integer that is its surplus. Similarly, every deficit school is associated with a strictly positive integer that is its deficit. A transfer is a reassignment of teachers from surplus to deficit schools satisfying several requirements. Therefore, only the teachers assigned to surplus schools can be transferred; each such teacher has a set of acceptable deficit schools to which she can be transferred. Each teacher must either be transferred to an acceptable deficit school 3 3 3 In Section 5 , we consider the case where a teacher from a surplus school can be transferred to an acceptable surplus school. We do not allow the transfer of teachers from deficit schools in our model. or remain in the surplus school to which she belongs. This is an individual rationality requirement for teachers. No surplus school can become a deficit school nor can a deficit school become a surplus school post-transfer. The former is an individual rationality requirement for surplus schools and the latter, a natural fairness assumption. Finally, we do not permit fractional transfers of teachers. This is a natural assumption in our context since teachers are always assigned to a single school in practice. Every transfer leads to a post-transfer deficit vector of deficit schools. We assume (in broad consonance with the Haryana policy documents) that the planner’s objectives are expressed solely in terms of the post-transfer deficit vector. One can conceive of the planner having one of several objectives. A utilitarian planner may wish to minimize the aggregate sum of deficits or transfer as many teachers as possible. An egalitarian planner may wish to “minimize the worst deficits”. A welfare maximizing planner may wish to minimize total loss for a continuous and convex loss function of the deficits. These solutions will not coincide in an arbitrary problem. Our main result, Theorem 1 shows that there exists an achievable post-transfer deficit vector that Lorenz dominates all other achievable post-transfer deficits. Such a transfer simultaneously reconciles the objectives of utilitarian, egalitarian and welfare maximizing planners. A novel feature of our result is that we demonstrate the existence of a Lorenz dominant solution under integrality constraints. We provide a two-stage algorithm to find a Lorenz dominant vector. We formulate our problem as one of finding an integer flow in a network. In the first stage of the algorithm, we consider a relaxed version of the network flow problem where flows are allowed to be non-negative real numbers. We then use an existing algorithm by Megiddo 1974 and Dutta and Ray 1989 (henceforth, MDR), to find Lorenz dominant flows in this network. These flows are not integral. 4 4 4 Consider a problem in which there is one