Binding energy of compact stars and their non-radial oscillations

P. Laskos-Patkos 1, S. Papadopoulos 2, Ch.C. Moustakidis 1 · 2025

Read Binding energy of compact stars and their non-radial oscillations by P. Laskos-Patkos 1, S. Papadopoulos 2, Ch.C. Moustakidis 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-18706.txt.

Introduction

P. Laskos-Patkos, with S. Papadopoulos and Ch. C. Moustakidis, hunts for a universal rule linking two properties of compact stars, the dense remnants of massive stars. Researchers prize such rules because they let one property be inferred from another without knowing the exact behavior of matter inside the star. Both binding energy and the frequency of the star's non-radial wobbling might one day be measured from the same supernova event.

Assuming ordinary hadronic matter, the authors found an empirical relation connecting oscillation frequency to binding energy, holding for both the fundamental mode and the first pressure mode of the star's ringing. Adding hybrid recipes for the interior, where matter changes phase sharply, broke the pattern and caused deviations. The result adds a candidate to the family of near-universal relations and shows exactly where that family stops applying.

Catalog record

CREATORP. Laskos-Patkos 1, S. Papadopoulos 2, Ch.C. Moustakidis 1
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-18706

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Binding energy of compact stars and their non-radial oscillations P. Laskos-Patkos 1, S. Papadopoulos 2, Ch.C. Moustakidis 1 Abstract In the past years, a significant effort has been made with the scope of determining correlations, involving compact star properties, that are independent of the nuclear equation of state. Such universal relations are of utmost importance as they allow for the imposition of constraints on stellar properties without directly measuring them and they may also serve as a probe of General Relativity. In the present study, we investigated the possible existence of a universal relation between the binding energy of compact stars and the frequency of their non-radial oscillations. The main motivation was related to the fact that both of the aforementioned quantities might be measured in the occurrence of a supernova explosion. Interestingly, we found that there is a empirical relation between the oscillation frequency and the binding energy for both f f and p 1 p_{1} modes, assuming hadronic stellar matter. The inclusion of hybrid equations of state, incorporating sharp phase transitions, was shown to result into deviations from the aforementioned quasi-universal relation. I Introduction Neutron stars are considered to be unique laboratories for the study of dense nuclear matter and strong gravitational fields. In the past decades, a continuous research endeavor has allowed physicists to probe the nuclear equation of state and some of its properties via neutron star observations Abbott-2018 ; Antoniadis-2013 ; Cromatie-2020 ; Romani-2022 ; Miller-2019 ; Riley-2019 , and also to examine the impact of considering modified theories of gravity on neutron star structure Pani-2011 ; Orellana-2013 ; Abbas-2015 ; Das-2016 . However, current limitations in the accuracy of astronomical measurements, and the uncertainty regarding the equation of state (EOS) and the form of the theory of gravity for strong fields have created a degeneracy, where an appropriate selection of a nuclear model and a modified gravitational theory could account easily for observational data. In principle, more unknown parameters allow for an easier fit to the data. In the past years, there has been extensive work on tackling issues resulting from the (currently) unknown nature of the nuclear EOS. A major step has been achieved by the proposition of universal or quasi-universal relations, which describe the dependence between the structural properties of a compact object in a way that is independent from the underlying nuclear model Yagi-2013 ; Maselli-2013 ; Yagi-2015 ; Yagi-2017 ; Alexander-2019 ; Martinon-2014 ; Marques-2017 ; Raduta-2020 ; Khadkikar-2021 ; Largani-2022 ; Anderson-1998 ; Lau-2010 ; Chen-2014 ; Chirenti ; Lioutas-2021 ; Zhao-2022 ; Rodriguez-2025 ; Lattimer-2001 ; Reed-2020 ; Laskos-2022 ; Brew-2016 ; Chatterjee-2025 ; Jyothilakshmi-2025 . The most widely known universal relations are the so-called I-Love-Q relations which connect, in a remarkable EOS independent way, rescaled quantities involving the moment of inertia, the tidal deformability and the quadrupole moment Yagi-2013 . In addition, the well-studied Love-C Maselli-2013 relation is known to connect the tidal deformation to the compactness of a star and can be utilized to translate information from binary neutron star mergers to mass and radius constraints Abbott-2018 . Interestingly, and maybe more importantly, apart from the indirect measurement of different stellar properties, universal relations set the ground for probing the theory of gravity Yagi-2013 . Since their discovery Abbott-2016 , gravitational radiation or gravitational waves (GWs) are considered to be a crucial probe of astrophysical and cosmological phenomena. Being the propagating perturbation of the metric tensor Misner-1973 , GWs are sourced by several phenomena of dynamical perturbations occurring in astrophysical and cosmological structure. The spectrum of their emitted frequencies can be attributed to different physical sources, ranging from compact object dynamics to perturbations in stellar matter or in the early universe. Current detectors, (LIGO,Virgo, KARGA, GEO600) are sensitive in the band of 10Hz up to a few kHz Schnabel-2025 . At the upper range of this band, measurements are expected to find GWs coupled with the f and p modes of non-radial oscillations of compact stars, providing direct information on the properties of ultra-dense matter. Interestingly, such modes may appear when violent cosmic phenomena, such as neutron star mergers Pietri-2020 or supernovae occur Abdikamalov-2021 ; Radice-2019 . Interestingly, several research studies have been focused on the proposition of quasi-universal relations involving the frequency of non radial pulsations Anderson-1998 ; Lau-2010 ; Chen-2014 ; Chirenti ; Lioutas-2021 ; Zhao-2022 ; Rodriguez-2025 . Since the frequencies of these modes may be observationally attainable, they could provide important insight regarding other structural neutron star properties to which they are connected. Anderson and Kokkotas Anderson-1998 were the first to show that the f mode frequency f_{0}=\omega_{0}/2\pi follows a quasi-universal relation with the mean density of a star \sim\sqrt{M/R^{3}} ( M denotes the stellar mass and R the radius). Later, it was found that the rescaled quantity M\omega_{0} follows a series of more precise relations with the rescaled moment of inertia \bar{I} , the dimensionless tidal deformability \Lambda and the compactness C Lau-2010 ; Chen-2014 ; Chirenti ; Lioutas-2021 . In Ref. Zhao-2022 , Zhao and Lattimer refined previously established universal relations involving the frequency of f , p and g modes by using modern EOSs that fulfill state-of-the-art multimessenger constraints. Another important quantity that may be measurable in the event of a supernova explosion is the binding energy E_{b} of a compact object Lattimer-2007 . Being the difference between the baryonic and the gravitational mass the binding energy of a neutron star can thought as an analogue of the nuclear binding energy. Interestingly, as suggested by Lattimer Lattimer-2007 , the neutrinos emitted during supernovae carry information that may allow us to determine the neutron star binding energy. Once again, there have been investigations regarding the involvement of E_{b} in universal correlations Lattimer-2001 ; Reed-2020 ; Laskos-2022 ; Brew-2016 . Lattimer and Prakash indicated an empirical connection between the binding energy and the stellar compactness Lattimer-2001 , while Reed and Horrowitz Reed-2020 discussed a quasi-universal connection with the dimensionless tidal deformability. In Ref. Laskos-2022 the authors proposed a very precise universal relation between the binding energy, the stellar redshift and the dimensionless tidal deformability that has an error of less than 0.5\% and also holds for finite temperature (isentropic) EOSs. Given that both the binding energy and the frequency of a non radial oscillation are involved in quasi-universal relations and that they may also be measured in the occasion of a core-collapse supernova explosion Abdikamalov-2021 ; Lattimer-2007 , in the present study we aim to investigate if there is a possible empirical relation that connects them in a EOS independent way. In order to extend our study, we do not only consider hadronic EOSs, but we also employ hybrid models featuring a first-order phase transition. The importance of this study is threefold: Firstly, the existence of an empirical relation between the binding energy and the non radial mode frequencies could allow us to probe the theory of gravity in a single event by utilizing multimessenger detection. Secondly, possible theoretical deviations from such an empirical relation based on the nature of the EOS could potentially highlight the existence of exotic forms of matter in compact stars. Last, any future insight on the binding energy could narrow down the range of possible frequencies

Read the complete text