Demonstrators for Industrial Cyber-Physical System Research: A Requirements Hierarchy Driven by Software-Intensive Design

Uraz Odyurt, Richard Loendersloot, Tiedo Tinga · 2025

Read Demonstrators for Industrial Cyber-Physical System Research: A Requirements Hierarchy Driven by Software-Intensive Design by Uraz Odyurt, Richard Loendersloot, Tiedo Tinga (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-18534.txt.

Introduction

Uraz Odyurt works with Richard Loendersloot and Tiedo Tinga. They tackle a planning flaw in research projects. Teams rarely define what a demonstrator must prove, and they define it far too late. Vague plans breed confusion, and loose readiness labels make things worse. Projects then promise demos they cannot deliver. The authors offer a framework to fix this. It spells out demo requirements before work starts. Feasibility can then be judged early, and targets adjusted in time.

The framework sets five levels of demonstration. Each level ties to clear expectations, to how work packages interact, and to the project's use cases. The scope is software-heavy systems and industrial cyber-physical systems, where software and machines act as one. A full test would take years. Still, use on two real projects showed its worth. It exposed gaps between targeted and feasible demos.

Catalog record

CREATORUraz Odyurt, Richard Loendersloot, Tiedo Tinga
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-18534

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Demonstrators for Industrial Cyber-Physical System Research: A Requirements Hierarchy Driven by Software-Intensive Design Uraz Odyurt, Richard Loendersloot, Tiedo Tinga Abstract . One of the challenges apparent in the organisation of research projects is the uncertainties around the subject of demonstrators. A precise and detailed elicitation of the coverage for project demonstrators is often an afterthought and not sufficiently detailed during proposal writing. This practice leads to continuous confusion and a mismatch between targeted and achievable demonstration of results, hindering progress. The reliance on the TRL scale as a loose descriptor does not help either. We propose a demonstrator requirements elaboration framework aiming to evaluate the feasibility of targeted demonstrations, making realistic adjustments, and assist in describing requirements. In doing so, we define 5 hierarchical levels of demonstration, clearly connected to expectations, e.g., work package interaction, and also connected to the project’s industrial use-cases. The considered application scope in this paper is the domain of software-intensive systems and industrial cyber-physical systems. A complete validation is not accessible, as it would require application of our framework at the start of a project and observing the results at the end, taking 4–5 years. Nonetheless, we have applied it to two research projects from our portfolio, one at the early and another at the final stages, revealing its effectiveness. *[itemize]labelindent=10pt, itemindent=0pt, leftmargin=* 1. Introduction Research projects often include “demonstrators” as deliverables. It is often assumed that a demonstrator is inherently known to project members, with no structure or definitive description provided as part of the project proposal. Another valid reason for the absence of such a description is the initial level of uncertainty specific to research projects. After all, a research project is supposed to be high-level by definition. Questions such as: “What is there to be demonstrated?” , “How much of it can be demonstrated?” , “Given the a priori knowledge limitations resulting from unknowns in a research project, which level of demonstration is feasible?” , are familiar to most researchers. Most projects try to solve this by relying on the Technology Readiness Levels (TRL), which proves to be inadequate as it does not account for a demonstrator’s coverage. We discuss this in Section 3.4 . The vague and undefined nature of a “demonstrator” leads to misaligned expectations, excessive delays, or simply failing to provide a viable demonstrator. This is especially a more apparent shortcoming with research projects in collaboration with the industry. Research projects in natural science domains with an experimental focus, e.g., experimental high-energy physics, and more obviously, projects for various engineering domains, e.g., computer science, can be mentioned. Contribution We propose a systematic approach for a clear definition of requirements, clarifying a research project’s demonstrator(s) ambitions. We take inspiration from the common research project structures, as well as TRL. In this particular paper, we also consider a software-intensive system as the deliverable, which would clarify additional unknowns. We provide: • A structured and practical typology of demonstration levels, suitable for research projects. • A systematic and reusable framework designed to reveal misalignments and/or missing detail crucial to the composition of demonstrators. • Application of our method (framework) to two research projects in our portfolio. Scope The role of software is ever-increasing in industrial Cyber-Physical Systems (CPS), to an extent that we can consider modern instances as Software-Intensive Systems (SIS) Hölzl et al. 2008 . This designation is backed by the fact that analytic solutions intended for industrial CPS, especially the likes of solutions providing capabilities such as Fault Detection and Identification, anomaly detection/identification Ibidunmoye et al. 2015 , and predictive maintenance, are fully based on software algorithms and data. In this paper, we focus on research project in the context of SIS. Further evaluations with more diverse projects could lead to adjustments, making our method suitable for a broader scope. Following this introduction, Section 2 covers fundamental topics and Section 3 presents our proposed demonstrator typology. Our designed framework as the method is covered in Section 4 , with example cases analysed in Section 5 . Related works and concluding remarks are given in Section 6 and Section 7 , respectively. 2. Background A few fundamental topics are to be elaborated. 2.1. TRL levels The Technology Readiness Level (TRL) scale in its original form, was first formalised by NASA Mankins 2004 . The scale is intended as a framework for systematic assessment of technology maturity during its development. Consisting of 9 levels from basic research (TRL 1) to fully operational (TRL 9), it was primarily focused on hardware for aerospace technologies. These levels are defined as (taken from Mankins 2004 ): • TRL 1: Basic principles observed and reported • TRL 2: Technology concept and/or application formulated • TRL 3: Analytical and experimental critical function and/or characteristic proof-of-concept • TRL 4: Component and/or breadboard validation in laboratory environment • TRL 5: Component and/or breadboard validation in relevant environment • TRL 6: System/subsystem model or prototype demonstration in a relevant environment (ground or space) • TRL 7: System prototype demonstration in a space environment • TRL 8: Actual system completed and “flight qualified” through test and demonstration (ground or space) • TRL 9: Actual system “flight proven” through successful mission operations The TRL scale can act as a common language to track, assess and communicate technology maturity across involved organisations or even different projects. 2.2. Adapted TRLs for SIS Modern systems portray an increasing reliance on software components to achieve the core functionality. Considering the differences between hardware development and software development, reinterpretation of TRLs to better reflect the unique characteristics of software development and deployment is necessary. An adapted version of the TRL scale, focusing on software-intensive systems is a sensible update to have. The key motivating differences are: • Software development lacks physical instantiation stages, making traditional TRL interpretations less applicable. • Software is typically developed using agile or incremental methods, requiring readiness to reflect iterative validation. • The maturity of software is often more dependent on its interaction with other systems than on standalone functionality, i.e., there is a clear distinction between individual functionality and integrated functionality. • Software must be tested under realistic conditions, especially in safety-critical or real-time environments, to achieve robustness. Given the above differences and considering the original TRL scale, Table 1 provides the adapted TRL scale definitions for software-intensive systems. Software-specific keywords and concepts are introduced in blue text for legibility and ease of comparison. Table 1 . Adapted TRL scale definitions to accommodate key differences present in software development and software-intensive systems. Adapted text is highlighted in blue font. Level Original definition Adapted definition TRL 1 Basic principles observed and reported Basic principles or algorithms identified and described TRL 2 Technology concept and/or application formulated Software concept and intended application formulated TRL 3 Analytical and experimental critical function and/or characteristic proof-of-concept Proof-of-concept algorithms developed and demonstrated in analytical or simulation environments TRL 4 Component and/or breadboard validation in laboratory environment Individual software components prototyped and tested in controlled lab conditions TRL 5 Component and/or breadboard validation in relevant environment Software modules integrated and tested with representative data and interfaces in a simulated or partially relevant environment TRL 6 System/subsystem model or prototype demonstration in a relevant environment (ground or space) Prototype software

Read the complete text