Clouds as the driver of variability and colour changes in brown dwarf atmospheres

Lucas Teinturier, Benjamin Charnay, Aymeric Spiga, Bruno Bézard · 2025

Read Clouds as the driver of variability and colour changes in brown dwarf atmospheres by Lucas Teinturier, Benjamin Charnay, Aymeric Spiga, Bruno Bézard (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-18090.txt.

Introduction

Lucas Teinturier, Benjamin Charnay, Aymeric Spiga, and Bruno Bezard use a full climate model to show that clouds drive the color changes of brown dwarfs. These heavy objects sit between stars and planets, and their shift in color across the L/T boundary has long lacked a settled cause. Air flow and clouds were both candidates.

With cloud forming, moving, and radiating inside the model, the simulated dwarfs varied in light, place, and time much like real ones. Cloud heating stirred convection, and waves ruled low latitudes while eddies ruled higher ones. The work makes clouds the lead suspect in dwarf weather.

Catalog record

CREATORLucas Teinturier, Benjamin Charnay, Aymeric Spiga, Bruno Bézard
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-18090

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Clouds as the driver of variability and colour changes in brown dwarf atmospheres Lucas Teinturier, Benjamin Charnay, Aymeric Spiga, Bruno Bézard Abstract Brown dwarfs are massive, giant exoplanet analogues subject to variability and colour changes, known as the L/T transition, fundamental for their thermal evolution. The drivers of the L/T transition remain elusive, with atmospheric circulations and/or clouds usually suggested as potential mechanisms. Using a three-dimensional Global Climate Model including cloud formation, transport and multi-wavelength radiative effects, we show that clouds play a major role in shaping the atmospheric properties of brown dwarfs. Cloud radiative effect, which triggers atmospheric convection, leads to spectral, spatial, and temporal variability in the modelled brown dwarfs, in agreement with the observed variability and L/T transition. Low latitudes are subject to sustained wave activity, whereas eddies dominate higher latitudes. Our results highlight that the role of clouds as a driver of atmospheric dynamics and climate, well known for giant exoplanets, extends to all sub-stellar bodies. 1 Introduction Brown dwarfs are objects intermediate between exoplanets and stars, with masses ranging from 13 to 80 times the mass of Jupiter. Split into three different spectral types which roughly correlates to effective temperature (L-type (1300 \leq T eff \leq 2200 K), T-type (500 \leq T eff \leq 1300 K) kirkpatrick_new_2005 and Y-type (250 \leq T eff \leq 500 K) cushing_discovery_2011 ), their atmosphere span a wide range of spectral properties. Especially, on a narrow temperature range around 1300 K, the L/T transition marks a sharp change in observed colours and magnitudes as well as composition with the transition from CO to CH 4 as the main C-bearing molecule vos_astro2020_2019 . During this evolutionary phase, L-type dwarfs appear red whereas T-type dwarfs are bluer, with a brightening observed in the J-band (1.1-1.4 µm) for early T-dwarfs. Distinct explanations for this L/T transition have been proposed, all linked to atmospheric changes. L-dwarfs’ thermodynamic conditions favour the presence of silicate and iron condensates high in the atmosphere, which could shape their spectral properties and explain their red colours tsuji_warm_1999 ; allard_limiting_2001 ; ackerman_precipitating_2001 ; helling_atmospheres_2014 ; charnay_self-consistent_2018 . The disappearance of these condensates below the photosphere (i.e., the vertical depth probed by observations) as the brown dwarf transitions into a T-type dwarf could explain the observed change in spectral properties. Some 1D models produce a L/T transition following the temperature evolution of brown dwarfs saumon_evolution_2008 ; allard_models_2012 ; charnay_self-consistent_2018 . However, they fail to produce a sharp transition with increasing flux in the J-band. Additional mechanisms related to cloud feedback have been proposed to reinforce the transition, as changes in the cloud cover or vertical mixing induced by cloud convection marley_patchy_2010 ; charnay_self-consistent_2018 . Still, such hypotheses require 3D models to be tested. A last possible explanation for the L/T transition is linked to atmospheric convection triggered by chemical instabilities tremblin_thermo-compositional_2019 ; tremblin_rotational_2020 . Brown dwarfs are rapid rotators (P \sim 2-20 hours metchev_weather_2015 ), whose atmospheric inhomogeneities, such as patchy cloud cover, are expected to lead to rotational variability in their lightcurves crossfield_global_2014 ; metchev_weather_2015 . This variability has been widely observed in multiple brown dwarfs artigau_photometric_2009 ; radigan_strong_2014 ; apai_hst_2013 ; buenzli_vertical_2012 ; buenzli_cloud_2015 ; metchev_weather_2015 , and is probably related to planetary-scale waves apai_zones_2017 . Specifically, increased variability in the J-band has been observed for L/T transitioning objects radigan_strong_2014 . Several modelling studies have tackled the variability and L/T transition, mostly focusing on 1-dimensional models robinson_temperature_2014 ; morley_water_2014 ; tan_atmospheric_2019 ; luna_empirically_2021 . However, as atmospheric circulation is a three-dimensional process, understanding the L/T transition and the observed variability requires using 3D Global Climate Models (GCM). Few GCM studies paved the way to such an endeavour. Still, they didn’t include clouds, which are thought to play a strong role showman_atmospheric_2013 ; zhang_atmospheric_2014 ; showman_atmospheric_2019 ; tan_jet_2022 ; lee_dynamically_2023 . Idealised simulations of early L-dwarfs taking into account cloud formation and their radiative feedback revealed vigorous equatorial dynamics with large-scale zonally propagating waves (Kelvin and Rossby waves), whereas mid-to-high latitudes are dominated by horizontally isotropic vortices tan_atmospheric_2021-1 . Assuming a given rotation period, the vertical thickness of the cloud layer was found to be greater in the equatorial region than at the poles. However, this modelling ignored the spectral aspect of radiative transfer and could not thus address the change of colour at the L/T transition. Moreover, their models were tuned to impede convection within the cloud-forming region whereas convective overshoot and mixing by gravity waves can be invoked to maintain dust clouds in the upper levels of hot atmospheres, which disappear when decreasing effective temperature freytag_role_2010 . Additionally, cloud-convection feedback can drive spontaneous atmospheric variability, as was shown using a Cloud Resolving Model lefevre_cloud-convection_2022 . To date, an investigation of the drivers of the L/T transition and variability using a GCM with spectral radiative transfer and self-consistent cloud modelling is lacking. 2 Setup To tackle the issue of variability and L/T transition on brown dwarf atmospheres, we use a state-of-the-art 3D multi-wavelength Global Climate Model, the generic Planetary Climate Model ( generic PCM ) wordsworth_gliese_2011 coupled with a cloud model which includes condensation, evaporation, transport and radiative effect. This model has recently been adapted for Hot Jupiters teinturier_radiative_2024 and its adaption to field brown dwarfs is described in Section 5 . Assuming a rotational period of 5 hours, a gravity of 1000 m.s -2 , a radius equal to one Jovian radius and silicate clouds made of Mg 2 SiO 4 (dominant type of clouds for a solar metallicity visscher_atmospheric_2010 ), we vary the effective temperature (1500-700 K) and the radius of cloud particles (10-30 µm) to swipe through the L/T transition, and test the effect of the radius of cloud particles on the transition, as particles sizes strongly affect the spectral properties charnay_self-consistent_2018 . Our simulations are run at a high horizontal resolution (1.4 ∘ \times 0.94 ∘ in longitude-latitude), with 80 vertical levels, equally log-spaced in pressure between 1 mbar and 80 bars. This setting is designed to resolve the dynamics, as the characteristic horizontal length scale of dynamical features is close to the deformation radius, which is of the order of 500-5000 km for brown dwarfs showman_atmospheric_2020 . On the vertical scale, the typical atmospheric scale height is \sim 4 km and needs to be resolved by the model. The runtime is 400 periods, long enough to reach a statistical equilibrium state in the atmosphere. 3 Results 3.1 Atmospheric Structures Regardless of the effective temperature of the simulation, two distinct regions emerge in the modelled thermal emission maps (Fig. 1 .A). An equatorial region of strong dynamical activity is present with a latitudinal extent that varies with effective temperature, similarly to tan_atmospheric_2021 ; lee_dynamically_2024 . Zonal winds in these regions can reach hundreds of meters per second (see Fig. Extended Data 1 ) corresponding to the wind speed measured by allers_measurement_2020 . In this region, the thermal emission is lower than at higher latitudes, due to an increased abundance of clouds. This correlation is seen in Fig. 1 .B which displays the maps of the cloud columns. These maps and the latitude-pressure maps reveal a patchy cover, with more abundant clouds close to the equatorial region than at higher latitudes. Indeed, a greater Coriolis parameter

Read the complete text