A spin on Hagedorn temperatures and string stars

Josef Seitz, and Erez Y. Urbach · 2025

Read A spin on Hagedorn temperatures and string stars by Josef Seitz, and Erez Y. Urbach (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-17951.txt.

Introduction

Josef Seitz and Erez Y Urbach link two extreme objects: highly excited strings and black holes, now with spin added. At a fixed spin rate, free strings hit a Hagedorn instability when a thermal winding mode turns unstable. That point lets the authors compute the exact limiting temperature for three kinds of string theory.

Around that background they find a new rotating string star, a bound ball of excited strings held by its own gravity. It appears to bridge the plain string phase and a rotating black hole. The work extends a classic string and black hole match into turning settings.

Catalog record

CREATORJosef Seitz, and Erez Y. Urbach
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE125 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-17951

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A spin on Hagedorn temperatures and string stars Josef Seitz, and Erez Y. Urbach Abstract We discuss the correspondence between highly excited strings and black holes in the presence of angular momentum. At fixed imaginary angular velocity ν \nu , we show that free strings exhibit a Hagedorn instability, explained—as in Atick-Witten—by a thermal-winding mode turning tachyonic. This allows us to determine the exact Hagedorn temperature β H ​ ( ν ) \beta_{H}(\nu) for bosonic, type II, and heterotic strings. Using the effective field theory for the thermal-winding mode around the ν \nu -dependent background, we find a novel ‘rotating string star’ saddle (perturbatively in the angular velocity) and study its properties. This configuration describes a self-gravitating bound state of highly excited rotating strings. As in the non-rotating case, the saddle is qualitatively shown to interpolate between the rotating strings phase and a rotating black hole. We also comment on the implications of these results for anti-de Sitter space. 1 Introduction Over time, black holes tend to shrink as they radiate. The fate of small (highly-curved) black holes in a UV-complete theory of gravity is therefore an interesting self-consistency check Bedroya:2022twb ; Basile:2023blg ; Bedroya:2024ubj ; Bedroya:2024uva ; Herraez:2024kux ; Herraez:2025gcf ; Herraez:2025clp , which could teach us a lesson on black hole microscopy. In string theory, the nature of black holes as their horizon size reaches the string scale remains an open question Susskind:1993ws ; Maldacena:1996ky ; Horowitz:1996nw ; Peet:2000hn . One version of this question is phrased in terms of Euclidean gravity Chen:2021dsw . The Euclidean black hole saddle in asymptotically \mathbb{R}^{d}\times S^{1}_{\beta} string theory 1 1 1 At finite g_{s} , it is impossible to fix the asymptotic length \beta Atick:1988si . We work at arbitrarily small g_{s}\ll 1 throughout the paper, in which the problem disappears. Another option is to embed the discussion inside thermal AdS (see Urbach:2022xzw and section 5 ). is well described by Einstein gravity for \beta\gg l_{s} , but what is its description for \beta\sim l_{s} ? Horowitz and Polchinski Horowitz:1997jc suggested that at high temperatures and for 3\leq d\leq 5 , the saddle is a normalizable condensate of strings winding on the thermal cycle of \mathbb{R}^{d}\times S^{1}_{\beta} . The saddle, interpreted as a self-gravitating stringy condensate Damour:1999aw ; Khuri:1999ez , is termed ‘the Horowitz-Polchinski solution’ or a ‘string star’. Surprisingly, this saddle carries an O(G_{N}^{-1}) thermal entropy, and qualitatively agrees with black hole thermodynamics at lower temperatures. 2 2 2 In Chen:2021dsw a worldsheet index argument was given against a smooth transition between the two descriptions in type II string theory. To the best of our understanding, the argument carries over to our setting ( \nu\neq 0 ) as well. Recently, there has been a renewed interest in string stars, extending the original setting Chen:2021dsw ; Mazel:2024alu to higher dimensions d>5 Balthazar:2022szl ; Balthazar:2022hno ; Bedroya:2024igb ; Chu:2025boe ; Chu:2025kzl , and other background geometries Urbach:2022xzw ; Urbach:2023npi ; Halder:2023nlp ; Agia:2023skp ; Ishibashi:2025qwn ; Chu:2024ggi ; Emparan:2024mbp ; Chu:2025fko . Figure 1 : A schematic summary of the suggested black hole/string star correspondence. The Schwarzschild black hole (left) shrinks as the temperature (vertical axis) increases, and turns into a string star close to the string theory Hagedorn temperature T\lesssim T_{H} . Turning on angular momentum (horizontal axis), we find a ‘rotated’ version of the correspondence (right): the rotated black hole turns into a rotating string star at higher temperatures. To gather more evidence for this proposal, it is natural to consider extra parameters to turn on, both at the string star and the black hole sides of the correspondence. In this work, we study the correspondence in the presence of angular momenta. 3 3 3 Rotating black holes at low temperatures (near-extremal limit) have enjoyed renewed interest recently Sen:2012cj ; Moitra:2019bub ; Kapec:2023ruw ; Rakic:2023vhv ; Maulik:2024dwq due to their strong quantum effects at the near-horizon Bardeen:1999px region. Let J be a rotation generator in a two-dimensional plane of \mathbb{R}^{d} . To add angular momenta, we consider an ensemble of fixed temperature \beta , and fixed imaginary ‘angular velocity’ potential \nu , conjugate to J , with the partition function Z(\beta,\nu)=\sum_{E,J}\exp\left(-\beta E+2\pi i\nu J\right). (1) In terms of Euclidean string theory, this ensemble is defined by an \mathbb{R}^{d}\times S^{1} asymptotic boundary condition with a twist \nu between the thermal and the angular directions. The twisted \mathbb{R}^{d}\times S^{1} is one possible saddle that contributes to Z(\beta,\nu) , describing, at g_{s}=0 , freely rotating strings. The Euclidean rotating black hole is another saddle with the same asymptotics that contributes to ( 1 ). This work suggests a description of the rotating black hole saddle when it reaches a string size \beta\sim l_{s} . Following the non-rotating case, we find a normalizable winding condensate solution on top of the twisted \mathbb{R}^{d}\times S^{1} background. The result is a ‘rotating string star’ saddle, interpreted as a bound state of self-gravitating rotating strings. By studying the saddle thermodynamic properties, we find a qualitative agreement with the rotating black hole (see figure 1 ). We begin in section 2 by reviewing the thermodynamic properties of highly-excited rotating strings. 4 4 4 For previous literature on this subject, see Russo:1994ev ; Matsuo:2009sx . Recently Ceplak:2023afb ; Ceplak:2024dxm studied aspects of the correspondence between free strings and black holes with angular momenta. While some of our work overlaps with theirs, there are important differences. Most importantly, they compared black holes with free strings, whereas we compare them to the string star. Secondly, all the objects we consider in this work (strings, string stars, or black holes) will possess a ‘small’ amount of angular momentum, and will remain away from extremality. More abstractly, the process that interpolates between strings and black holes in Ceplak:2023afb ; Ceplak:2024dxm was an adiabatic (fixed entropy) process of varying the string coupling. We follow Chen:2021dsw , and change the temperature (and possibly the angular velocity) at fixed string coupling (fixed theory). We believe this difference is not consequential. By studying free strings in the \beta,\nu ensemble ( 1 ), we find it shares an important property with the canonical (non-rotating \nu=0 ) ensemble: it has a Hagedorn instability! Explicitly, we find that due to the high energy spectrum of free rotating strings, Z(\beta,\nu) diverges at temperatures above a \nu -dependent Hagedorn temperature \beta<\beta_{H} . 5 5 5 While we were not aware of this work until the final stages of writing, Mertens:2014nca is the only previous work we found that presents \beta_{H}(\nu) , in the context of the pure NS-NS bosonic AdS 3 background. Defining R_{H}=\beta_{H}/(2\pi) , we find (for |\nu|<1 ) \begin{split}R_{H}/l_{s}&=\begin{cases}\sqrt{4-2|\nu|+2\nu^{2}},&\text{Bosonic}\\ \sqrt{2-2|\nu|},&\text{Type II}\\ \frac{1}{2}\left(\sqrt{4-2|\nu|+2\nu^{2}}+\sqrt{2-2|\nu|}\right),&\text{Heterotic}\end{cases}.\end{split} (2) We give two alternative ways to find ( 2 ). One is to directly check the Hagedorn growth of the partition function due to high-energy excitations. A second, more instructive way for our purposes is to follow Atick and Witten Atick:1988si and interpret the Hagedorn instability as a tachyonic instability of a thermal winding mode in \mathbb{R}^{d}\times S^{1} . Studying the winding sector of the twisted \mathbb{R}^{d}\times S^{1} worldsheet theory, we were able to derive ( 2 ). As we explain, it is also possible to derive ( 2 ) perturbatively in \nu from a target space analysis.

Read the complete text