Lorentz, Poincaré, Einstein, and the Genesis of the Theory of Special Relativity

Hector Giacomini · 2025

Read Lorentz, Poincaré, Einstein, and the Genesis of the Theory of Special Relativity by Hector Giacomini (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-17838.txt.

Introduction

Hector Giacomini reexamines how special relativity was born between 1895 and 1913. He places Lorentz, Poincaré, and Einstein inside their shared scientific context. German review journals spread Lorentz's 1904 results quickly across Europe. One concise 1905 review by Richard Gans gave many readers easy access.

Poincaré named the relativity principle and interpreted local time clearly. He also proved the group property of the Lorentz transformations. Against that background, Einstein's 1905 paper looks like a powerful reformulation. It answered problems already posed by Maxwell's electrodynamics and failed ether tests. Later histories then sidelined Poincaré from the standard canon.

Catalog record

CREATORHector Giacomini
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE95 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-17838

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Lorentz, Poincaré, Einstein, and the Genesis of the Theory of Special Relativity Hector Giacomini Abstract This work offers a historical reading of the genesis of special relativity by placing the contributions of Lorentz, Poincaré, and Einstein within their scientific and editorial context. It highlights the importance of the German periodical Beiblätter zu den Annalen der Physik as a key channel for the dissemination of international scientific research. The perspective advanced here is that the true revolution did not lie in special relativity itself, but in Maxwell’s electrodynamics. Special relativity thus appears as the necessary expression of a framework already transformed by the universality of the speed of light. 1 The University of Bern and its Library in 1905 Since the theory of special relativity is associated with Albert Einstein, who settled in Bern in 1902 and remained there until 1909, it is useful to recall the history of the University and its library. The University of Bern, officially founded in 1834 [ 1 ] , belongs to a long tradition of higher education in the city dating back to the sixteenth century. In 1528, Bern established a High School intended for the training of Protestant pastors. Transformed into an Academy in 1805, it comprised four faculties: theology, law, medicine, and philosophy. Under the impulse of the liberal Bernese government, the Academy became a university in 1834, conceived in a spirit of social and political openness. The institution experienced rapid growth, especially after the creation of the Swiss federal state in 1848. By around 1885, it had already become the largest university in the country. Foreign students, particularly from Germany and Russia, made up more than half of the enrollment. Among them, Russian women students paved the way for the admission of women in the 1870s. At the turn of the century, Bern also distinguished itself through several remarkable figures: in 1903, the philosopher Anna Tumarkin became the first woman in Europe authorized to supervise doctoral theses and to serve on a university council. In the same year, the university inaugurated its main building on Grosse Schanze Street, designed by the Bernese architects Alfred Hodel and Eduard Joos. A few years later, in 1909, the surgeon Theodor Kocher, a professor at the institution, was awarded the Nobel Prize in Medicine, further strengthening the university’s international reputation. The University Library [ 2 ] , located since 1887 on Herrengasse Street after the merger of the municipal and university collections, occupied the premises of a former Franciscan monastery. These vaulted halls, refurbished in the nineteenth century, held about 175,000 volumes in 1905. The space, sober but already too narrow for the expanding collections, constituted the scientific heart of the city. The library, open to all readers including non-residents, offered free access to students and professors. Other users paid a modest entrance fee and an annual subscription. The services included direct lending, on-site consultation in the reading room, and, exceptionally for the time, the postal delivery of books to researchers living outside Bern. In addition, a well-established interlibrary exchange network allowed readers to request books or journals not available locally from Zurich, Geneva, Basel, or Lausanne, to be sent by post. This system, supported by both cantonal and federal authorities, provided Bern’s readers with rapid access to a scientific collection far broader than that of their own library. Opening hours were generous: the reading room was open every day except Sundays and public holidays, from 10 a.m. to 12 p.m. and from 2 p.m. to 7 p.m. (until 8 p.m. in winter). The lending desk closed at 4 p.m. Saturday was a regular working day. Newly received journal issues were immediately placed in the reading room on special shelves and remained available throughout the year until they were bound. Earlier volumes, kept in storage, could only be obtained by request at the desk before closing time. The library closed only twice a year, for one week at Easter and one week in September. In 1904–1905, a new building was erected on Münstergasse Street to accommodate the growing collections. The transfer took place gradually, and by 1905 the library was already beginning to operate in its new premises. This modernization marked an important step for the institution and for the scientific life of the city. 2 The Role of the Journal Beiblätter zu den Annalen der Physik In 1905, the Beiblätter zu den Annalen der Physik occupied an essential position within the German-speaking scientific system. Conceived as a bibliographical supplement to the Annalen der Physik , the journal did not publish original research but compiled analytical summaries, critical reviews, and systematic listings of international literature in physics, chemistry, and related disciplines. Its primary mission was to provide an information service offering a continuous overview of scientific production worldwide. Edited in Leipzig, the Beiblätter were directed by Eilhard Wiedemann until 1900, and subsequently by Walter König between 1901 and 1907. A cumulative index covering volumes 24 to 30 (1900–1906) still allows researchers to identify reviewers and cited authors, and remains a valuable research tool for reconstructing reading and dissemination networks. Within the German-speaking world, the Beiblätter fulfilled a very important function. For German researchers, they served as a rapid information tool enabling them to follow an expanding international literature. Students used them as an entry point to specialized journals, which were often difficult to access directly. University libraries relied on these notices to guide their acquisitions, particularly for costly foreign journals. Their monthly publication ensured a regular and up-to-date flow of information. In Switzerland, the Beiblätter were systematically available in the main university libraries of Zurich, Geneva, Basel, and Bern. For institutions with more modest means than German universities, they represented a major resource: instead of multiplying expensive subscriptions to foreign journals that were often difficult to obtain, these libraries could rely on this centralized repertory to quickly identify relevant articles and, when necessary, request them through interlibrary exchange. Their transnational diffusion even extended beyond the German-speaking area—they were consulted as far as Scandinavia and Eastern Europe. In 1905, the Beiblätter zu den Annalen der Physik were indeed part of the collections of the University Library of Bern, where they were accessible to readers on the same basis as the Annalen der Physik themselves. 3 Maxwell’s Equations: A Scientific and Technological Revolution 3.1 The Unification of Electricity, Magnetism, and Light Between 1861 and 1873, James Clerk Maxwell accomplished an unprecedented intellectual synthesis. This synthesis, however, was part of a longer historical lineage. André-Marie Ampère had already formulated in the 1820s the quantitative laws of the forces between electric currents, laying the foundations of electrodynamics. From 1831 onward, Michael Faraday discovered the phenomenon of induction and introduced the notion of lines of force, which directly inspired Maxwell. He himself acknowledged that his theory was, for the most part, a mathematical translation of Faraday’s ideas. By formulating a coherent system of differential equations, Maxwell showed that electricity and magnetism are but two aspects of a single physical reality. More than that, he revealed that light itself is an electromagnetic wave propagating in vacuum at a speed determined solely by two universal constants, the electric permittivity \varepsilon_{0} and the magnetic permeability \mu_{0} . Maxwell thus introduced a new and

Read the complete text