A search for black holes with metal-poor stellar companions: I. Survey sample selection and single epoch radial velocity follow-up Facilities: Magellan:Clay (MIKE), APF, Gaia, Sloan, LAMOST, UKST

Casey Y. Lam, Joshua D. Simon, Kareem El-Badry, Howard Isaacson, Daniel D. Kelson, Jessica Lu · 2025

Read A search for black holes with metal-poor stellar companions: I. Survey sample selection and single epoch radial velocity follow-up Facilities: Magellan:Clay (MIKE), APF, Gaia, Sloan, LAMOST, UKST by Casey Y. Lam, Joshua D. Simon, Kareem El-Badry, Howard Isaacson, Daniel D. Kelson, Jessica Lu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-17746.txt.

Introduction

Casey Y. Lam and five co-authors hunt for heavy black holes with old, metal-poor companion stars. Theory says the heaviest stellar black holes form from stars low in metals. A recent find, Gaia BH3, pairs such a hole with a metal-poor giant. The team searched for more systems like it.

They picked about nine hundred candidates from Gaia spacecraft data. The candidates showed odd motion, shifting speeds, and low metal content. The team then took sharp spectra for over six hundred sources. After removing false leads, about fifteen strong candidates remained. Later Gaia data should let astronomers pin down their orbits.

Catalog record

CREATORCasey Y. Lam, Joshua D. Simon, Kareem El-Badry, Howard Isaacson, Daniel D. Kelson, Jessica Lu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE90 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-17746

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A search for black holes with metal-poor stellar companions: I. Survey sample selection and single epoch radial velocity follow-up Facilities: Magellan:Clay (MIKE), APF, Gaia, Sloan, LAMOST, UKST Casey Y. Lam, Joshua D. Simon, Kareem El-Badry, Howard Isaacson, Daniel D. Kelson, Jessica Lu Abstract Stellar-mass black holes (BHs) above 30 ​ M ⊙ 30M_{\odot} are predicted to form from low-metallicity progenitors, but direct detections of such systems in the Milky Way remain scarce. Motivated by the recent discovery of Gaia BH3, a 33 ​ M ⊙ 33M_{\odot} BH with a very metal-poor giant companion, we conduct a systematic search for additional systems. Approximately 900 candidates are identified with Gaia as having significant deviations from single-star astrometric motion, evidence of RV variability, and low metallicities inferred from Gaia XP spectra. We obtain single epoch high-resolution spectra for over 600 of these sources with Magellan/MIKE and Lick/APF and measure independent RVs with ≈ 1 \approx 1 km s -1 precision. After removing contaminants such as hot stars, pulsators, eclipsing binaries, and hierarchical triples, we identify about 15 promising candidates with large RV amplitudes or offsets from the Gaia reported values. This program establishes a well-characterized sample of BH candidates for detailed orbital modeling once Gaia DR4 epoch astrometry and RVs are released in late 2026; multi-epoch RV follow-up is ongoing. Together, the Gaia and ground-based data will place new constraints on the demographics of BHs with metal-poor companions and test theoretical predictions linking low metallicity to the formation of the most massive stellar remnants. show][email protected] hide][email protected] hide][email protected] hide][email protected] hide][email protected] hide][email protected] I Introduction I.1 Observational evidence connecting massive black holes with metal-poor progenitors Astrophysical stellar-mass black holes (BHs) are born from the collapse of massive stars. The masses of these BHs range from \approx 2M_{\sun} to \gtrsim 100M_{\odot} . BHs spanning this full mass range have only been discovered in compact object mergers outside our local universe via gravitational waves ( R. Abbott et al. 2020a ; R. Abbott et al. 2020b ) . In contrast, nearly all BHs in our Milky Way with mass measurements span a much narrower range of 5-20M_{\odot} , whether those BHs are in X-ray binaries ( F. Özel et al. 2010 ; W. M. Farr et al. 2011 ) , detached binaries ( K. El-Badry et al. 2023a ; S. Chakrabarti et al. 2023 ; K. El-Badry et al. 2023b ) , or isolated systems ( C. Y. Lam & J. R. Lu 2023 ; K. C. Sahu et al. 2025 ) . It is hypothesized that the \gtrsim 30M_{\odot} BHs discovered via gravitational waves form at low metallicity ( K. Belczynski et al. 2010 ) . Because wind driven mass loss decreases with decreasing metallicity, BHs that form from low metallicity stars will be more massive ( A. Heger et al. 2003 ) . Recently, Gaia Collaboration et al. 2024 reported the discovery of Gaia BH3, a 33M_{\odot} BH with a 0.76M_{\odot} very metal poor [Fe/H] =-2.56 giant star in an 11.6 year orbit. Gaia BH3 is the most massive Galactic BH known to date, and is similar in mass to BHs discovered via gravitational waves. In addition, the very metal poor giant companion appears to be associated with the very metal poor ED-2 stellar stream ( E. Balbinot et al. 2024 ) . Gaia BH3 thus provides direct evidence of the connection between low-metallicity stellar progenitors and massive stellar-mass BHs. I.2 Searching for additional massive BH binaries in the Milky Way The discovery of Gaia BH3 itself was also notable. Unlike the first two BHs discovered with Gaia ( K. El-Badry et al. 2023a ; S. Chakrabarti et al. 2023 ; K. El-Badry et al. 2023b , Gaia BH1 and BH2,) , Gaia BH3 was not listed in any of the Gaia Data Release 3 (DR3) non-single-star (NSS) catalogs and did not have an orbital solution. Instead, Gaia BH3 was discovered by Gaia Collaboration et al. 2024 during the process of preparing and validating the upcoming Gaia DR4. Figure 1 illustrates why Gaia BH3 was discovered in Gaia DR4 but not Gaia DR3: because of its long orbital period, RV quadrature was only observable in DR4. Gaia DR3’s temporal baseline is 34 months (2014–2017). Gaia DR4, scheduled to be released 2026 December, has a temporal baseline of 66 months (2014–2020). Even from the Gaia DR3 single-star catalog information, there were hints that Gaia BH3 was interesting: it showed astrometric motion inconsistent with a single-star motion model, as well as substantial radial velocity (RV) variation of \approx 40 km s -1 . Without an orbital solution, epoch astrometry, or RVs to validate the signal, it was not an obvious target of interest for follow-up (although see J. Müller-Horn et al. 2025 , which presents a method for identifying compact objects using Gaia summary statistics in the absence of orbital solutions). The discovery of Gaia BH3 suggests there are more massive BHs in the Galaxy waiting to be found, if we know where to look. The sample of neutron stars and BHs discovered so far with Gaia tentatively suggests that low-metallicity stars have a higher occurrence rate of massive compact object companions than solar-metallicity stars ( K. El-Badry 2024a ; K. El-Badry et al. 2024b ) . In this work, we present ground-based RV measurements of Gaia BH3-like sources observed in 2024–2025. A single RV epoch taken in 2024 or 2025, compared to median RVs from 2014–2017 reported in Gaia DR3, will immediately enable detection of large RV variations potentially indicative of massive BH companions. Once the Gaia DR4 epoch data are released, the ground-based RV epoch can be simultaneously modeled with the Gaia data to provide independent validation of orbital solutions of BH candidates. If the orbital periods of BH candidates are long ( \gtrsim 10 years), having observations now will reduce the amount of time required in the future to follow them up and validate their orbital solutions. A similar search with an independently constructed sample was conducted by P. Nagarajan et al. 2025a ; a discussion and comparison are presented in Section VI . The rest of this paper is organized as follows. Section II defines the sample selection of our BH candidates. Sections III and IV describe the acquisition and analysis of ground-based RVs, respectively. Section V presents the results of the follow-up, as well as an analysis of the systems that already have orbits mapped in Gaia DR3. Section VI describes the contaminants in our sample, compares our sample to other searches for compact objects in the Gaia catalogs, and discusses the constraints this sample places on detached BH binaries. We conclude in Section VII and briefly describe the plan for continued follow-up of the most interesting candidates. Figure 1: Left panel: RV measurements of Gaia BH3 taken with Gaia’s Radial Velocity Spectrometer (black points) along with the orbital model determined by Gaia Collaboration et al. 2024 (dashed line). Gaia BH3’s RVs in the Gaia DR3 window showed a roughly monotonic increase of \approx 40 km s -1 ; RV quadrature occurred during the Gaia DR4 window, revealing the full RV amplitude of \approx 110 km s -1 . Data in Gaia DR5 will nearly close the orbit. Right panel: In general, Gaia

Read the complete text