Non-CMC solutions to a Lichnerowicz equation in the Einstein-scalar field theory on closed manifolds

Bartosz Bieganowski, Pietro d’Avenia, Jacopo Schino, Daniel Strzelecki · 2025

Read Non-CMC solutions to a Lichnerowicz equation in the Einstein-scalar field theory on closed manifolds by Bartosz Bieganowski, Pietro d’Avenia, Jacopo Schino, Daniel Strzelecki (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-17669.txt.

Introduction

Bartosz Bieganowski, with Pietro d'Avenia and two co-authors, proves a solution exists for a gravity equation in a 2025 arXiv paper. The equation is the Lichnerowicz equation, used when building starting data for Einstein's field equations. Their setting couples gravity with a scalar field on a closed manifold, meaning a finite space with no edge. The mean curvature of the space is not constant, which is the non-CMC case.

Non constant mean curvature adds terms that grow faster than standard ones. Singular terms, which blow up at some points, appear as well. The team uses a recent fixed point argument built on sub and super solutions. They prove a positive, essentially bounded solution exists. They also give conditions on the coefficients under which no positive classical solution can exist.

Catalog record

CREATORBartosz Bieganowski, Pietro d’Avenia, Jacopo Schino, Daniel Strzelecki
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-17669

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Non-CMC solutions to a Lichnerowicz equation in the Einstein-scalar field theory on closed manifolds Bartosz Bieganowski, Pietro d’Avenia, Jacopo Schino, Daniel Strzelecki Abstract . In the paper, we prove the existence of a positive and essentially bounded solution to a Lichnerowicz equation in the Einstein-scalar field theory on a closed manifold with non-constant mean curvature. In particular, the non-constant mean curvature gives rise to supercritical terms in the equation, on top of singular ones. We employ a recent fixed-point argument, which involves sub- and supersolutions. Additionally, we provide several conditions on the coefficients in the equation that prevent the existence of positive classical solutions. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 58J05, 58J90, 35J75, 35J61, 35Q75, 35Q76 1. Introduction To study the Einstein equation in general relativity in a four-dimensional spacetime \displaystyle\mathcal{V} as a Cauchy problem, it is necessary to find appropriate initial data. The Gauss and Codazzi equations, when applied to the Einstein equation, provide the conditions for a metric \displaystyle g , a symmetric \displaystyle(0,2) -tensor \displaystyle K , and a mean curvature \displaystyle\tau in a three-dimensional space manifold \displaystyle M that must be satisfied to ensure that \displaystyle M is the initial state for the study of evolution. These conditions are known as constraint equations (for a detailed derivation, see [ 2 ] ). One of the most fruitful techniques in studying constraint equations is a conformal method (also called “Method B”) introduced by Lichnerowicz [ 10 ] . This method allows for the classification of the constant mean curvature (CMC) solutions of such equations on compact manifolds (see [ 9 ] ) or other types of initial manifolds (see [ 11 ] and references therein). The situation becomes more complicated when studying non-constant mean curvature (non-CMC) solutions. This was not a case of interest for many years, since it was thought that each solution of the Einstein equation had a slice with constant mean curvature. In 1988, Bartnik provided an example of a spacetime satisfying the Einstein equation that does not admit any CMC surface, see [ 1 ] . A general method to create such examples was given in [ 6 ] . Therefore, the study of non-CMC solutions proved to be an important topic. In the study of the Einstein field equation, the coupling of gravity with other fields provides the form of the energy-momentum tensor. For instance, this approach leads to the Einstein–Maxwell equations for electromagnetism in curved spacetime. In this paper, we are focused on the so called Einstein-scalar field theory: the coupling of gravity with a scalar field. Let \displaystyle\Psi be a real-valued scalar field on an \displaystyle(N+1) -dimensional spacetime manifold \displaystyle\mathcal{V} ( \displaystyle N\geq 3 ) and let \displaystyle\gamma be a spacetime metric. Consider the action \mathcal{S}(\Psi,\gamma):=\int_{\mathcal{V}}\Big[R(\gamma)-\frac{1}{2}|\nabla\Psi|_{\gamma}^{2}-V(\Psi)\Big]d\eta_{\gamma}, where \displaystyle R(\gamma) is the scalar curvature of \displaystyle\gamma , \displaystyle d\eta_{\gamma} is the volume element, \displaystyle|\nabla\Psi|_{\gamma}^{2} is the squared pseudo-norm of the spacetime gradient of the field \displaystyle\Psi with respect to the metric \displaystyle\gamma , and \displaystyle V\colon\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R} is a given smooth function. 1 1 1 For the Klein–Gordon field theory, \displaystyle V(\Psi)=\frac{1}{2}m^{2}\Psi^{2} . Making the variations of \displaystyle\mathcal{S} with respect to \displaystyle\gamma and \displaystyle\Psi , we get the Einstein-scalar field equations \begin{cases}G_{\alpha\beta}=\nabla_{\alpha}\Psi\nabla_{\beta}\Psi-\frac{1}{2}\gamma_{\alpha\beta}\nabla_{\mu}\Psi\nabla^{\mu}\Psi-\gamma_{\alpha\beta}V,\\ \nabla_{\mu}\Psi\nabla^{\mu}\Psi=\frac{dV}{d\Psi}\end{cases} where \displaystyle G_{\alpha\beta} is the Einstein curvature tensor. The same system was obtained by Rendall [ 12 ] to describe the expansion of the universe (see also [ 13 ] ). Moreover, in particle physics, scalar fields are used to describe spin-zero particles. Now, let us consider the constraint equations for this problem, which are conditions for an \displaystyle N -dimensional spacelike hypersurface \displaystyle M with a spatial metric \displaystyle g , a symmetric tensor \displaystyle K , and a mean curvature \displaystyle\tau . As noted in [ 5 ] , the coupling of a scalar field to the Einstein gravitational field theory does not add any new constraint equations to the theory. In the same paper, Choquet-Bruhat, Isenberg, and Pollack applied the Lichnerowicz conformal method to reformulate the constraint equations for the Einstein-scalar system into a system of partial differential equations. In this method, \displaystyle\Psi is split into \displaystyle\psi (its restriction to \displaystyle M ) and \displaystyle\pi (the normalized time derivative of \displaystyle\Psi restricted to \displaystyle M ). Introducing the new variables \displaystyle u for a positive scalar function and \displaystyle W for a vector field defined on \displaystyle M , one can rescale and transform \displaystyle\pi , \displaystyle K , and \displaystyle g (we keep these symbols for the transformed variables) to rewrite the constraint equations as the system (1.1) \left\{\begin{array}[]{l}\begin{aligned} -\Delta_{g}u&+\frac{N-2}{4(N-1)}\left(R(g)-|\nabla_{g}\psi|_{g}^{2}\right)u-\frac{N-2}{4(N-1)}\left(|\sigma+{\mathcal{D}}W|_{g}^{2}+\pi^{2}\right)u^{-(2^{*}+1)}\\ \quad&+\frac{N-2}{4(N-1)}\left(\frac{N-1}{N}\tau^{2}-4V(\psi)\right)u^{2^{*}-1}=0,\end{aligned}\\[4.30554pt] \mathrm{div}_{g}({\mathcal{D}}W)=\frac{N-1}{N}u^{2^{*}}\nabla_{g}\tau-\pi\nabla_{g}\psi,\end{array}\text{in }M.\right. In this system, \displaystyle R(g) is the scalar curvature (also called the Ricci scalar), \displaystyle\sigma is the so-called TT-tensor (symmetric, divergence free and trace free), \displaystyle{\mathcal{D}} is the conformal Killing operator, \displaystyle\tau represents the mean curvature of \displaystyle M , and \displaystyle V is the smooth potential of the Einstein-scalar field theory. The standard task in this approach is to verify which choices of the data \displaystyle(g,\sigma,\tau,\psi,\pi) allow solving the constraint equations for \displaystyle u and \displaystyle W . Then, from the full set of data \displaystyle(g,\sigma,\tau,\psi,\pi,W,u) , by the reverse rescaling, one can obtain the solution of the constraint equations. In [ 5 ] and [ 8 ] , the authors consider the system ( 1.1 ) in the case where \displaystyle\tau is constant (see also [ 3 ] , where the authors admit more general nonlinearities). In that scenario, the second equation becomes independent of \displaystyle u . By solving it for \displaystyle W , the problem reduces to studying the first equation for the function \displaystyle u , whose nonlinear part consists of Sobolev-critical and negative powers. In this paper, we deal with non-constant \displaystyle\tau , so that the system ( 1.1 ) is fully coupled, taking, in this way, a different point of view on the variables in the constraint equation. We fix the vector field \displaystyle W and we solve the equation for the functions \displaystyle u and \displaystyle\psi . This approach, as will be shown, leads then to a single equation for \displaystyle u , independent of \displaystyle\psi , with Sobolev-supercritical terms. From now on, we assume that \displaystyle(M,g) is a closed (i.e., compact and without boundary) Riemannian manifold of dimension \displaystyle N\geq 3 . To transform the system ( 1.1 ) into a single equation, we assume \displaystyle V\equiv\nu\in\mathbb{R} . The case of a constant potential can be understood as the situation when the scalar field does not produce a force (the force is the gradient of a potential). Especially, assuming \displaystyle V\equiv 0 , we study the scalar field of massless particles, for example, the massless Klein–Gordon equation. Consider \displaystyle V\equiv\nu and non-constant \displaystyle\tau . Then, from the second equation, |\nabla_{g}\psi|_{g}^{2}=\left|\pi^{-1}\left(\frac{N-1}{N}u^{2^{*}}\nabla_{g}\tau-\mathrm{div}_{g}({\mathcal{D}}W)\right)\right|_{g}^{2}. Hence, the system ( 1.1 ) reduces to a single equation, which we call the Lichnerowicz equation, \displaystyle\displaystyle-\Delta_{g}u+\frac{N-2}{4(N-1)}\left(R(g)-\left|\pi^{-1}\left(\frac{N-1}{N}u^{2^{*}}\nabla_{g}\tau-\mathrm{div}_{g}({\mathcal{D}}W)\right)\right|_{g}^{2}\right)u \displaystyle\displaystyle\qquad-\frac{N-2}{4(N-1)}(|\sigma+{\mathcal{D}}W|_{g}^{2}+\pi^{2})u^{-(2^{*}+1)}+\frac{N-2}{4(N-1)}\left(\frac{N-1}{N}\tau^{2}-4\nu\right)u^{2^{*}-1}=0. We set \displaystyle\displaystyle h \displaystyle\displaystyle:=\frac{N-2}{4(N-1)}R(g),\quad A:=\frac{N-2}{4(N-1)}(|\sigma+{\mathcal{D}}W|_{g}^{2}+\pi^{2}),\quad B:=\frac{N-2}{4(N-1)}\left(\frac{N-1}{N}\tau^{2}-4\nu\right), \displaystyle\displaystyle C \displaystyle\displaystyle:=-\sqrt{\frac{N-2}{4(N-1)}}\pi^{-1}\mathrm{div}_{g}({\mathcal{D}}W),\quad D:=\sqrt{\frac{N-2}{4(N-1)}}\pi^{-1}\frac{N-1}{N}\nabla_{g}\tau. Then we rewrite the Lichnerowicz equation as -\Delta_{g}u+(h-|Du^{2^{*}}+C|_{g}^{2})u-Au^{-(2^{*}+1)}+Bu^{2^{*}-1}=0 or equivalently (1.2) -\Delta_{g}u+(h-|C|_{g}^{2})u=|D|_{g}^{2}u^{2\cdot 2^{*}+1}+2\langle C,D\rangle_{g}u^{2^{*}+1}-Bu^{2^{*}-1}+\frac{A}{u^{2^{*}+1}}\quad\text{in }M, which is the equation that we study in this paper. Note that \displaystyle A , \displaystyle B , \displaystyle C , \displaystyle D , \displaystyle h are not necessarily constant. In fact, \displaystyle A,B,h\colon M\to\mathbb{R} and \displaystyle C,D\colon M\to TM

Read the complete text