LawChain: Modeling Legal Reasoning Chains for Chinese Tort Case Analysis
Huiyuan Xie, Chenyang Li, Huining Zhu, Chubin Zhang, Yuxiao Ye, Zhenghao Liu, Zhiyuan Liu · 2025
Read LawChain: Modeling Legal Reasoning Chains for Chinese Tort Case Analysis by Huiyuan Xie, Chenyang Li, Huining Zhu, Chubin Zhang, Yuxiao Ye, Zhenghao Liu, Zhiyuan Liu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-17602.txt.
Introduction
Chinese tort cases, where one party seeks compensation for harm, require a careful chain of legal reasoning that generic logic templates capture poorly. Huiyuan Xie and six co-authors build LexChain, a framework that spells out that chain in three modules, each broken into finer steps drawn from how tort analysis is actually done. Most earlier computational work on legal reasoning aimed at criminal cases, leaving civil reasoning of this kind largely unmodelled.
The team turns the framework into a benchmark task and tests current large language models on it. Xie and her co-authors find that the models still mishandle crucial elements of tort reasoning. Adding LexChain style steps, through prompting or extra training, lifted performance clearly and transferred to related legal tasks, which supports explicit reasoning chains as a design principle.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Huiyuan Xie, Chenyang Li, Huining Zhu, Chubin Zhang, Yuxiao Ye, Zhenghao Liu, Zhiyuan Liu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-17602
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
LawChain: Modeling Legal Reasoning Chains for Chinese Tort Case Analysis Huiyuan Xie, Chenyang Li, Huining Zhu, Chubin Zhang, Yuxiao Ye, Zhenghao Liu, Zhiyuan Liu Abstract Legal reasoning is a fundamental component of legal analysis and decision-making. Existing computational approaches to legal reasoning predominantly rely on generic reasoning frameworks such as syllogism and IRAC, which do not comprehensively examine the nuanced processes that underpin legal reasoning. Moreover, current research has largely focused on criminal cases, with insufficient modeling for civil cases. In this work, we present a novel framework for explicitly modeling legal reasoning in the analysis of Chinese tort-related civil cases. We first operationalize the legal reasoning processes used in tort analysis into the LawChain framework. LawChain is a three-module reasoning framework, with each module consisting of multiple finer-grained sub-steps. Informed by the LawChain framework, we introduce the task of tort legal reasoning and construct an evaluation benchmark, LawChain eval , to systematically assess the critical steps within analytical reasoning chains for tort analysis. Leveraging this benchmark, we evaluate state-of-the-art large language models for their legal reasoning ability in civil tort contexts. Our results indicate that current models still fall short in accurately handling crucial elements of tort legal reasoning. Furthermore, we introduce several baseline approaches that explicitly incorporate LawChain-style reasoning through prompting or post-training. We conduct further experiments on additional legal analysis tasks, such as Legal Named-Entity Recognition and Criminal Damages Calculation, to verify the generalizability of these baselines. The proposed baseline approaches achieve significant improvements in tort-related legal reasoning and generalize well to related legal analysis tasks, thus demonstrating the value of explicitly modeling legal reasoning chains to enhance the reasoning capabilities of language models. Introduction The rapid development of large language models (LLMs) has led to widespread adoption of these tools across diverse domains. Recent models, such as Gemini-2.5-Pro ( Comanici et al. 2025 ) and Qwen-3 ( Yang et al. 2025 ) , now position reasoning as a default and essential component of their architecture. While notable progress has been made in advancing the reasoning abilities of LLMs in areas such as mathematics and coding ( Wei et al. 2022 ; Huang et al. 2023 ; El-Kishky et al. 2025 ) , LLMs’ reasoning capabilities in the legal domain, where nuanced outputs are dependent on structured and domain-specific legal reasoning, remain underexplored. Legal reasoning is a foundational element of legal analysis and decision-making. Legal scholars argue that there is, descriptively, something unique that can be characterized as “thinking like a lawyer” ( Samuelson 1997 ; Schauer 2009 ) . This encompasses distinctive forms of reasoning, such as the systematic application of codified legal rules, the decomposition of legal questions into granular elements for structured judgment, and ensuring that similar cases are treated uniformly. Better modeling of legal reasoning processes not only improves the accuracy and efficiency of legal analysis, but also enhances the interpretability of results by providing explicit reasoning chains. Figure 1: Illustration of the case information (English translation) in a civil tort case and the three-module LawChain reasoning framework. However, existing work on computational legal reasoning has primarily focused on generic legal reasoning frameworks, such as syllogism ( Deng et al. 2023 ; Jiang and Yang 2023 ) and IRAC ( Yu, Quartey, and Schilder 2023 ; Kuppa, Rasumov-Rahe, and Voses 2023 ; Servantez et al. 2024 ) , often simulating reasoning through simple prompting strategies. In addition, research has concentrated predominantly on criminal law, with insufficient attention paid to civil cases, especially tort cases, which are highly relevant to everyday life. Tort law plays a fundamental role in modern legal systems, in both protecting individual rights and compensating plaintiffs for harms suffered. In this work, we explicitly model legal reasoning chains for tort-related civil cases within the context of Chinese civil law. Drawing on established legal theory ( Smith 1911 ; Moore 1999 ) , we operationalize the analytical process of tort adjudication into the LawChain reasoning framework - a multi-module reasoning chain in which each module comprises a set of key steps or elements essential to tort legal reasoning (see Figure 1 for an illustration). We introduce a novel task of tort legal reasoning and construct a benchmark designed to assess whether existing models can correctly identify the key steps and elements required for robust legal reasoning in tort disputes. We evaluate several leading LLMs on this benchmark, observing that accurately modeling the tort reasoning chain remains a challenging task for current models. Leveraging our LawChain reasoning framework, we further implement reasoning-enhanced baselines using approaches such as legal prompting, supervised fine-tuning (SFT) and direct preference optimization (DPO). Results demonstrate that integrating explicit legal reasoning chains through these techniques consistently improves model performance on identifying key elements for tort case analysis, underscoring the value of explicit legal reasoning modeling in enhancing LLMs’ legal reasoning abilities. Finally, we evaluate our fine-tuned baselines on related legal AI tasks, including Legal Named-Entity Recognition and Criminal Damages Calculation ( Fei et al. 2024 ) . Our reasoning-enhanced models achieve comparable or superior performance to zero-shot counterparts on these tasks, demonstrating the generalizability of reasoning-enhanced approaches to other legal AI tasks. The contributions of this work are summarized as follows: • We operationalize legal reasoning in the domain of civil tort law by proposing a legally-informed, fine-grained reasoning framework that reflects the structured analytical processes employed in real-world tort litigation. • Building on this framework, we introduce the novel task of tort legal reasoning and construct a dedicated benchmark to evaluate models’ performance on this task. To the best of our knowledge, the constructed benchmark is the first evaluation dataset that focuses on the assessment of legal reasoning abilities in the context of Chinese civil tort law. In addition, we curate a reasoning-enhanced training dataset to enable effective learning of legal reasoning patterns. • Our empirical results demonstrate that current LLMs exhibit notable limitations in tort-related legal reasoning, particularly in labor dispute cases. Furthermore, we find that generic syllogistic reasoning frameworks do not yield meaningful improvements in this domain, underscoring the need to move beyond generic approaches and adopt domain-specific reasoning paradigms tailored to the complexity of civil tort law. We further show that incorporating LawChain-style reasoning through prompting, SFT and DPO leads to substantial performance gains on the tort reasoning task. These improvements also generalize effectively to other related tasks, underscoring the value of explicitly modeling structured legal reasoning in enhancing LLM performance on legal analysis tasks. Related Work Legal Reasoning and Tort Cases Legal reasoning refers to the analytical process by which legal practitioners integrate legal norms with case facts to reach a legal conclusion ( Samuelson 1997 ; Schauer 2009 ) . Legal reasoning holds a central role in judicial practice, serving as the foundation for legal analysis and as a mechanism to ensure the consistency of judicial decisions. Distinct from general forms of logical reasoning, legal reasoning is shaped by the constraints of legal systems, precedential rules and various institutional factors ( Scharffs 2004 ) . The diversity and complexity of real-world cases also make the practical application of legal reasoning highly challenging. Tort liability is a form of civil liability that aims to remedy infringed civil rights and safeguard the legitimate interests of