Numerical Error Analysis of the Poisson Equation under RHS Inaccuracies in Particle-in-Cell Simulations Journal: Communications in Computational Physics for peer review

Kai Zhang, Xiao Tao, Weizong Wang, Bijiao He · 2025

Read Numerical Error Analysis of the Poisson Equation under RHS Inaccuracies in Particle-in-Cell Simulations Journal: Communications in Computational Physics for peer review by Kai Zhang, Xiao Tao, Weizong Wang, Bijiao He (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-17580.txt.

Introduction

Kai Zhang, with Tao Xiao and two co-authors, studies error sources in plasma simulations in a 2025 arXiv paper. Their simulations track charged particles and must solve an electric potential equation on a grid. Accuracy often drops near odd shaped walls. Most past work blamed the equation's left side, which holds the unknown values. Zhang's team instead studies the right side, which holds charge data gathered near those walls.

Charge data gathered near walls often comes out too low. The authors show this error helps a simple solution scheme but harms a more refined one. Tests in one, two, and three dimensions confirmed the pattern. A simple fix to the charge data restored the refined scheme's accuracy. The findings guide how simulation codes should treat wall regions.

Catalog record

CREATORKai Zhang, Xiao Tao, Weizong Wang, Bijiao He
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE79 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-17580

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Numerical Error Analysis of the Poisson Equation under RHS Inaccuracies in Particle-in-Cell Simulations Journal: Communications in Computational Physics for peer review Kai Zhang, Xiao Tao, Weizong Wang, Bijiao He Abstract Particle-in-Cell (PIC) simulations rely on accurate solutions of the electrostatic Poisson equation, yet accuracy often deteriorates near irregular Dirichlet boundaries on Cartesian meshes. While much research has addressed discretization errors on the left-hand side (LHS) of the Poisson equation, the impact of right-hand-side (RHS) inaccuracies—arising from charge density sampling near boundaries in PIC methods—remains largely unexplored. This study analyzes the numerical errors induced by underestimated RHS values at near-boundary nodes when solving the Poisson equation using embedded boundary finite difference schemes with linear and quadratic treatments. Analytical derivations in one dimension and truncation error analyses in two dimensions reveal that such RHS inaccuracies modify local truncation behavior differently: they reduce the dominant truncation error in the linear scheme but introduce a zeroth-order term in the quadratic scheme, leading to larger global errors. Numerical experiments in one-, two-, and three-dimensional domains confirm these findings. Contrary to expectations, the linear scheme yields superior overall accuracy under typical PIC-induced RHS inaccuracies. A simple RHS calibration strategy is further proposed to restore the accuracy of the quadratic scheme. These results offer new insight into the interplay between boundary-induced RHS errors and discretization accuracy in Poisson-type problems. 1 Introduction Particle-in-Cell [ 1 ] (PIC) simulation has become an indispensable tool in studying plasma physics, where a core computational task is solving the electrostatic Poisson equation on a mesh. Most modern PIC codes [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] for simulating plasma flows adopt Cartesian meshes, owing to advantages such as straightforward implementation, efficient parallelization, and favorable computational performance. While Cartesian PIC codes can, in principle, accommodate arbitrarily shaped boundaries, solution accuracy often degrades in the presence of irregular Dirichlet boundaries. This degradation arises because mesh nodes rarely align perfectly with the boundary surfaces. For geometries with high symmetry—such as spherical or cylindrical shapes—these challenges can be alleviated by developing customized PIC codes using spherical [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] or cylindrical meshes [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] . However, such specialized codes are only applicable to a limited class of problems and typically require substantial development effort. Other approaches, such as finite-volume-based methods [ 13 ] or finite-element methods [ 14 , 15 , 16 ] , fundamentally alter the structure of standard PIC codes, introducing additional complexity and reduced computational efficiency. There were many existing techniques as to improving the solution accuracy of the Poisson equation with irregular domain on Cartesian meshes, each providing unique way of reducing the truncation errors for the near-boundary nodes—defined as nodes less than one grid spacing away from boundary interfaces along any coordinate direction. For example, Mayo’s method [ 17 , 18 , 19 ] that employ the integral formations for the near-boundary nodes. While this method allows the use of fast Poisson solvers [ 20 ] , the procedures require using numerical quadrature to evaluate the integrals followed by spline interpolations. In solving more general elliptic equations, the immersed interface method (IIM) proposed by LeVeque and Li [ 21 , 22 ] introduces an innovative six-point stencil for the near-boundary nodes, which necessitates determining appropriate coefficients for the stencil points by solving local linear systems. Both approaches have been proved to produce second-order accuracy [ 23 ] . The embedded boundary finite volume methods [ 24 , 25 ] are viable alternatives, with the scheme of Devendran et al. [ 25 ] achieving fourth-order accuracy. Among second-order accurate methods, the embedded boundary finite difference method offers an attractive alternative [ 26 , 27 ] . This method embeds irregular Dirichlet boundaries within a rectangular (or cuboidal in 3D) computational domain and modifies the Poisson equation’s discretization near the boundary using either the linear [ 28 , 29 ] or the quadratic interpolation schemes [ 30 , 31 ] . For interior grid nodes located at least one grid spacing away from the Dirichlet boundaries along any axial direction, the standard five-point stencil, known to yield second-order truncation error, is retained. The resulting discretization leads to a linear system to be solved numerically. Extensive prior work has investigated the error behavior of the embedded boundary finite difference method. It is widely recognized that both the linear and quadratic schemes improve the solution accuracy. In particular, the linear scheme was proved to give second-order accuracy [ 28 , 29 ] , while the quadratic attains third-order accuracy at the boundaries and maintain second-order accuracy in the interior [ 31 , 32 , 33 ] . These two schemes have been successfully applied in various computational applications, including crystal growth [ 34 ] , fluid dynamics [ 35 ] , tumor modeling [ 36 ] , etc. Recently, the use of such schemes has also seen increases in plasma simulations [ 37 , 38 ] . The linear scheme, in particular, had been considered favorable [ 29 ] for its simplicity and the symmetric linear systems it produces, which enables using efficient sparse matrix storage and matrix-vector algorithms, as well as iterative solvers such as the Preconditioned Conjugate Gradient (PCG) method. However, Jomaa and Macaskill’s error analysis [ 26 ] challenged the preference for the linear scheme. In one-dimensional problems they provided explicit numerical error expressions. Upon evaluation of these expressions, they showed that the linear scheme, although exhibiting second-order accuracy, has much larger error coefficients than the quadratic counterpart. For two-dimensional problems, they verified numerically that their 1-D error analysis holds for non-corner grid points. While the majority of existing studies focus on discretization errors arising from the numerical treatment of the left-hand side (LHS) of the Poisson equation, comparatively little attention has been paid to inaccuracies originating from the right-hand side (RHS). Such inaccuracies may stem from measurement errors, data processing procedures, or physical modeling assumptions, and can significantly affect the accuracy of the computed potential field. Several studies in the literature have examined the Poisson equation with varied RHS values. Pan et al. [ 39 , 40 ] investigated the pressure Poisson equation in the context of particle image velocimetry (PIV) for fluid dynamics. In their formulation, the RHS depends on experimentally measured velocity field data, which inevitably contains systematic errors across the domain. They derived error bounds for the reconstructed pressure field and numerically validated these bounds under the assumption of constant perturbations in the RHS at both interior and boundary points. However, their analysis did not account for irregular Dirichlet boundary effects, nor did it consider numerical errors arising from the solving the Poisson equation. Marques et al. [ 41 ] developed the Correction Function Method (CFM) to handle interface jump conditions for constant-coefficient Poisson equations. As a finite difference approach, this method estimates ghost-node values that can be incorporated into the RHS, thereby enabling the use of standard solvers. Although the method modifies the RHS, its primary purpose is to improve the discretization of the LHS; hence, it does not address inaccuracies in the RHS itself. A critical gap in the literature concerns the effect of RHS inaccuracies in the electrostatic Poisson equation, particularly in

Read the complete text