Colour coherence in small collision systems Journal: Physics Letters B

Isobel Kolbé, Chiara Le Roux, Korinna Zapp · 2025

Read Colour coherence in small collision systems Journal: Physics Letters B by Isobel Kolbé, Chiara Le Roux, Korinna Zapp (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-17570.txt.

Introduction

Small collision systems, such as oxygen nuclei striking each other, show signs of collective flow that usually signal a droplet of hot quark matter, yet their jets lose no visible energy. Isobel Kolbé, Chiara Le Roux, and Korinna Zapp investigate whether colour coherence can explain that apparent contradiction. Colour coherence changes how a jet interacts with the medium it crosses, depending on whether the medium can resolve the jet inner parts.

Using the Jewel simulation model with coherence effects switched on and off, Kolbé and her co-authors compare jet and hadron suppression and the sideways flow pattern in both settings. Coherence raised the survival rate of jets but barely changed the flow signal. At equal particle counts, oxygen and lead collisions gave the same suppression despite their different shapes, a result that sharpens the small system puzzle.

Catalog record

CREATORIsobel Kolbé, Chiara Le Roux, Korinna Zapp
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE21 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-17570

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Colour coherence in small collision systems Journal: Physics Letters B Isobel Kolbé, Chiara Le Roux, Korinna Zapp Abstract The observation of collectivity in collisions of small systems has constituted a challenge for the heavy-ion community for over a decade now. The absence of jet quenching in those systems presents an apparent contradiction to the presence of an azimuthal anisotropy of high- p ⟂ p_{\perp} particles. In the present work, we investigate the role of colour coherence in this puzzle. For that, we use the Jewel Monte Carlo model in its latest version, which includes effects of colour coherence in the jet-medium interactions. We then compare the two scenarios, with and without colour coherence, and quantify the effect on hadron and jet R A ​ A R_{AA} as well as on high- p ⟂ p_{\perp} v 2 v_{2} . The results indicate that, although coherence effects do account for an increase in R A ​ A R_{AA} , they do not affect v 2 v_{2} to the same extent. Using hydrodynamic profiles generated with Trajectum we compare O+O and Pb+Pb collisions at the same charged particle multiplicity and find that the nuclear modification factors are the same in both systems despite their different shapes. 1 Introduction The formation of a medium of quarks and gluons in heavy-ion collisions was proposed Wiedemann 2010 , Majumder and Van Leeuwen 2011 , Mehtar-Tani et al. 2013 , Qin and Wang 2015 , Apolinário et al. 2022 and observed Connors et al. 2018 , Cunqueiro and Sickles 2022 , Acharya et al. 2024a , Hayrapetyan et al. 2025 for a long time now. In this process, high transverse momentum hadrons and jets have played an important role since they are modified by losing energy and momentum via successive interactions with the medium particles Apolinário et al. 2022 . The same process of path-length dependent energy loss also leads to an azimuthal anisotropy of high- p_{\perp} hadrons and jets in the final state. Both of these signatures of a medium have been observed in the collision of heavy ions. Nonetheless, when it comes to small systems, no energy loss has been observed whereas the anisotropy of high- p_{\perp} particles is present Khachatryan and et al. CMS Collaboration , Oh 2023 , Aad et al. 2020 , Acharya et al. 2024b , CMS 2024 . To reconcile these contradictory observations, it is important to understand the dynamics of partonic energy loss. One important aspect in this process is that hard partons carry colour charge and, therefore, are subject to the effects of colour coherence. For example, a parton forming a color dipole may not be resolved by the medium as an independent particle depending on the size of the dipole. Therefore, the re-scattering of this parton is suppressed relative to the incoherent case. Since this effect relies on the size of the dipole, it is expected that it is more important at early times when the dipoles are typically smaller than later on. As a result, this effect could be more important in collisions of small systems compared to large ones. The question thus arises to what extent colour coherence could be responsible for the apparent absence of jet quenching in small collision systems, and whether it affects nuclear modification factors quantifying the overall suppression and anisotropic flow coefficients in the same way. The present work takes a first step in addressing theses questions and explores the size of colour coherence effects in O+O collisions, their sensitivity to re-scattering at early times, and the relation between nuclear modification factors and elliptic flow coefficients for high transverse momentum hadrons and jets within the Jewel framework for jet evolution in a dense background medium. 2 Model For the work presented in this paper, we have generated events using the Jewel Monte Carlo model Zapp et al. 2013 , Zapp 2014 . Jewel is based on Pythia 6.4 Sjostrand et al. 2006 , which is used for the hard matrix elements, initial state parton showers, and the hadronisation. Jewel has its own virtuality ordered final state parton shower, which is constructed with off-shell kinematics such that there is no need to correct the kinematics of an earlier splitting a posteriori . In the presence of a medium of coloured particles, the partons can re-scatter off medium particles according to t -channel pQCD matrix elements for elastic scattering regularised by the Debye mass. Medium induced emissions are taken care of by resetting the parton shower at a higher scale whenever a scattering occurs at a scale above that of the parton shower and the formation time of the first emission from the new parton shower has a shorter formation time than that from the old parton shower. The Landau-Pomeranchuk-Migdal effect Landau and Pomeranchuk 1953 , Migdal 1956 is also included by treating scatterings falling within the formation time of a given splitting coherently Zapp et al. 2009 . Jewel can also keep the medium particles that scattered off the hard partons in order to account for medium response. All these particles are then hadronised using the Pythia string model. For the present work, the latest version 2.6.0 1 1 1 The code will soon be available at jewel.hepforge.org . Zapp was used. This way, angular ordering can be imposed dynamically only for those splittings that take place sequentially with no medium interactions in between. Moreover, the code includes a new mechanism to take care of colour coherence. This follows qualitatively the findings of Mehtar-Tani et al. 2011 , Mehtar-Tani et al. 2012 , Casalderrey-Solana and Iancu 2011 and involves rejecting medium scatterings off single partons that happen at scales 1/q_{\perp} smaller than the size of the colour dipole which that parton is a part of. On the other hand, the two partons in a dipole may scatter coherently with the medium. This is done by performing the scattering of the summed four-momentum of the two partons and then splitting the resulting vector again. The model was run with default settings without any tuning. The simulations presented here were carried out with the EPPS21 Eskola et al. 2022 nuclear PDF sets on top of the CT18ANLO Hou et al. 2021 proton PDF set, which was also used for the p+p baseline calculations. Medium response is included with the subtraction of thermal momenta performed using the Constituent subtraction procedure Milhano and Zapp 2022 . The parton shower evolution and re-scattering is fairly agnostic to the medium model. Therefore, Jewel can be interface with several different media. For the present work, we have used two different models for the medium: the default simplified model that is deployed with Jewel supplemented by a Glauber model Mariano 2022 , Barreiro 2022 , Barreiro et al. to obtain the initial temperature profile. It uses the TGlauberMC Loizides et al. 2018 implementation of the Phobos MC Glauber model Alver et al. 2008 to obtain the positions of wounded nucleons and binary nucleon–nucleon scatterings on an event-by-event basis. A Gaussian energy density profile is placed at the position of each wounded nucleon in the transverse plane at the initialisation time \tau_{i} , which then gets translated into a temperature profile. The medium is assumed to be boost invariant along

Read the complete text