Observable spins in gravitational waves from compact binary mergers

Souradeep Pal · 2025

Read Observable spins in gravitational waves from compact binary mergers by Souradeep Pal (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-17449.txt.

Introduction

Gravitational waves from merging black holes and neutron stars carry a fingerprint of how fast the bodies were spinning. Souradeep Pal, writing alone, asks how well that spin can actually be measured for the mergers our detectors can hear. The latest catalogue of events does not rule out spinning systems, yet Pal notices a pattern linking spin estimates to how loud each event was.

Loud events tend to show near zero spin, while faint events return almost arbitrary spin values. Through simulations, Pal shows that a truly non-spinning system can be misread as spinning when the signal is weak. That suggests the real spins in observed mergers are generally small. Future detections, he argues, could sharpen population studies if this bias is kept in mind.

Catalog record

CREATORSouradeep Pal
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-17449

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Observable spins in gravitational waves from compact binary mergers Souradeep Pal Abstract We investigate the measurability of effective inspiral spin in the detectable compact binary mergers using gravitational-wave observations. Measurements from the latest gravitational-wave transient catalog do not rule out the existence of binary systems with non-zero effective spins. However, we observe an apparent correlation between the inferred effective inspiral spin and the loudness of the gravitational-wave events– loud events typically have close-to-zero effective spins whereas fainter events tend to be inferred with relatively arbitrary effective spins. Through simulations, we demonstrate that non-negligible effective spins can be systematically inferred from non-spinning systems at small signal strengths. These two observations support the possibility that the effective spin magnitudes in the observable compact binaries are generally small. Future detections can have potential impact on the understanding of their population and other astrophysical inferences. I Introduction Observation of gravitational-wave (GW) signals from compact binary mergers has become a routine effort. Component spins of the binary systems can play a crucial role in the signal detection, the estimation of the source properties, and can potentially inform us about their origin. The first direct detection of GW signal from a compact binary merger was made in 2015 by the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-wave Observatories (LIGOs) ( Abbott et al. 2016 ) . The fourth observing run (O4) of the Advanced LIGO, Advanced Virgo, and KAGRA began on May 24, 2023. A catalog of gravitational-wave transient (GWTC) events until the first part of the run (O4a) has been released ( Collaboration et al. 2025a ) . It contains more than 200 confident candidates of astrophysical events and their properties. Several exceptional events are also reported ( Abac et al. 2025a ; Abac et al. 2025b ) . A majority of these events are consistent with signals from the merger of astrophysical black holes (BHs) ( Collaboration et al. 2025a ) . Several others are consistent with neutron star (NS) mergers ( Abbott et al. 2017 ; Abbott et al. 2020 ; Abbott et al. 2021a ; Collaboration et al. 2025a ) . Overall, a few very loud events have been reported. For a binary system, with component masses \mathrm{m}\textsubscript{1} and \mathrm{m}\textsubscript{2} , the effective inspiral spin ( \chi\textsubscript{eff} ) is given by \chi\textsubscript{eff}=\frac{\mathrm{m}\textsubscript{1}\chi\textsubscript{1}+\mathrm{m}\textsubscript{2}\chi\textsubscript{2}}{\mathrm{m}\textsubscript{1}+\mathrm{m}\textsubscript{2}}, (1) where \chi\textsubscript{1} and \chi\textsubscript{2} are the dimensionless component spins aligned to the orbital angular momentum of the binary. Its effect is imprinted in the signal emitted during the inspiral-merger-ringdown (IMR) stages of binary evolution. The signal-to-noise ratio (SNR, or equivalently the loudness) of a signal in a detector is computed by maximizing the match between the recorded data ( d ) with a template waveform ( h ) modeling the signal. The SNR ( \rho ) in a detector is given by \rho^{2}=\langle{d|h}\rangle=4\Re{\int_{f\textsubscript{lower}}^{f\textsubscript{upper}}\frac{\tilde{d}(f)\tilde{h}^{*}(f;\boldsymbol{\theta})}{\mathrm{S}\textsubscript{n}(f)}}df\,, (2) where \langle{d|h}\rangle represents the inner product (or the match) between the data and the template, with \boldsymbol{\theta} describing the source of the signal. Here \mathrm{S}\textsubscript{n}(f) represents the (one-sided) noise power spectral density (PSD) of the detector. The frequency interval bounded by f\textsubscript{lower} and f\textsubscript{upper} comes from the sensitive frequency band of the detector. For a detector network, the matched-filter network SNR is calculated as the quadrature sum of the SNRs in the detectors participating in the observation of an event. An empirical correlation between the inferred effective inspiral spin and the network SNR is shown in Fig. 1 . Figure 1: Distribution of the inferred effective inspiral spin ( \chi\textsubscript{eff} ) with the network SNR for simulated non-spinning merger events (in grey). The same is shown for the confidently detected GW events (in black), which contains events reported in GWTC-4.0 , as exceptional and other events ( gwo a ) , collectively referred to as GWTC-4.0+ . A circle indicates the inferred value and the error bars represent the 90% credible interval of the measurement. Essentially, note that non-negligible \chi\textsubscript{eff} values can be inferred from non-spinning sources at generally small SNRs, as discussed later in the text. Figure 2: Visualization of the effects of aligned-spins and that of the Gaussian noise on the GW strain in the time domain from an arbitrary simulated (77.2,57.6) \mathrm{M}_{\odot} source located at \sim 1000 Mpc. The aligned-spins are such that \chi\textsubscript{eff}=0.14 (shown in dark blue). The GW strain for the non-spinning signal with a single realization of Gaussian noise is shown (in light blue). In this work, inferences are mainly made from simulated astrophysical signals injected into Gaussian noise described as follows. The signal parameters are obtained from the injection sets presented with the public data release of GWTC-4.0 ( o4a a ) . A subset of the injections within an arbitrary time-interval is selected. Since the properties of the underlying population do not vary with time, a sufficiently large time-interval to select injections is expected to preserve the population properties to a reasonable extent. A non-spinning injected population (or a corresponding population with aligned-spins only) is obtained by appropriately fixing the values of the spin parameters to zero for each injection in our injection set. Unless specified otherwise, full IMR signals are implemented using the IMRPhenomXAS waveform model ( Pratten et al. 2020 ) . The waveform can model GW signals from aligned-spin sources with an accuracy relevant for the current purpose. To simulate the data d , a signal ( s ) is deposited in Gaussian noise ( n ) obtained with detector PSDs available with the data release, which can be summarized as d(t)=n(t)+s(t)\,. (3) This is illustrated in Fig. 2 . For demonstration, we simulate data for LIGO Hanford (H1) and LIGO Livingston (L1) and for ease of analysis, the injections are grouped into subsets categorized by the signal duration. Here we set the low-frequency cutoff for the analyses at 20 Hz and the high-frequency cutoff is determined by at least the highest possible signal frequencies. For the simulations, \chi\textsubscript{eff} values correspond to that obtained with a reference frequency set at the low-frequency cutoff. II Parameter inference Figure 3: Self-consistency of quoted credible intervals for the (intrinsic) source parameters used to calculate \chi\textsubscript{eff} . The grey shaded regions indicate up to 3\sigma -uncertainty. Figure 4: Simulated effect of detector noise realizations on the inference of effective inspiral spin ( \chi\textsubscript{eff} ). Each column represents a given injected source with varied network SNRs. Each curve represents a unique noise realization for a given injected source. The network SNRs indicate the injected SNRs averaged over the multiple noise realizations. To estimate the source parameters of an observed signal, we utilize Bayesian inference. Several algorithms are extensively described in the literature, see for example ( Lange et al. 2018 ; Biwer et al. 2019 ; Ashton et al. 2019 ; Dax et al. 2021 ; Fairhurst et al. 2023 ; Pathak et al. 2023 ; Nitz 2025 ) . The goal is to assign a probability ( p ) to a range of possible values of any source parameter ( \theta ) given the data. The range of values is assumed to contain the true value. The process involves computation of the likelihood of observing the given data in the presence of a signal with trial/proposed parameter values that can possibly describe the source. For the underlying Gaussian noise, the likelihood of

Read the complete text