Breakdown of hydrodynamics in a one-dimensional cold gas

Taras Holovatch 1,2 , Yuri Kozitsky 3 , Krzysztof Pilorz 3 , Yurij Holovatch 1,2,4,5 · 2025

Read Breakdown of hydrodynamics in a one-dimensional cold gas by Taras Holovatch 1,2 , Yuri Kozitsky 3 , Krzysztof Pilorz 3 , Yurij Holovatch 1,2,4,5 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-17428.txt.

Introduction

A line of cold particles, spaced evenly, can react to a single push in surprisingly orderly ways. Taras Holovatch and three co-authors study that setup, where particles of two alternating masses sit along a half line and the first one is suddenly given a positive speed. All later motion comes from elastic collisions between neighbours, and the mass ratio between the two kinds turns out to decide the whole character of the motion.

For most mass ratios, the system behaves like a fluid, with a blast front that slows as it advances and some particles recoiling backward. Holovatch and his co-authors find a special list of ratios where that picture collapses: no particles splash backward, at most three move at once, and the front travels at steady speed. Random starting positions restore the fluid like behaviour even there.

Catalog record

CREATORTaras Holovatch 1,2 , Yuri Kozitsky 3 , Krzysztof Pilorz 3 , Yurij Holovatch 1,2,4,5
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE18 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-17428

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Breakdown of hydrodynamics in a one-dimensional cold gas Taras Holovatch 1,2 , Yuri Kozitsky 3 , Krzysztof Pilorz 3 , Yurij Holovatch 1,2,4,5 Abstract The following model is studied analytically and numerically: point particles with masses m , μ , m , … m,\mu,m,\dots ( m ≥ μ m\geq\mu ) are distributed over the positive half-axis. Their dynamics is initiated by giving a positive velocity to the particle located at the origin; in its course the particles undergo elastic collisions. We show that, for certain values of m / μ m/\mu , starting from the initial state where the particles are equidistant the system evolves in a hydrodynamic way: (i) the rightmost particle (blast front) moves as t δ t^{\delta} with δ < 1 \delta<1 ; (ii) recoiled particles behind the front enter the negative half-axis; (iii) the splatter – the particles with locations x ≤ 0 x\leq 0 – moves in the ballistic way and eventually takes over the whole energy of the system. These results agree with those obtained in S. Chakraborti et al, SciPost Phys. 2022, 13, 074, for m / μ = 2 m/\mu=2 and random initial particle positions. At the same time, we explicitly found the collection of positive numbers { ℳ i , i ∈ 𝐍 } \{\mathcal{M}_{i},i\in\mathbf{N}\} such that, for m / μ = ℳ i m/\mu=\mathcal{M}_{i} , i ≤ 700 i\leq 700 , the following holds: (a) the splatter is absent; (b) the number of simultaneously moving particles is at most three; (c) the blast front moves in the ballistic way. However, if, similarly as in S. Chakraborti et al, the particle positions are sampled from a uniformly distributed ensemble, for m / μ = ℳ i m/\mu=\mathcal{M}_{i} the system evolves in a hydrodynamic way. I. Introduction. – An important task of contemporary statistical mechanics is to clarify interconnections between the micro- and macroscopic descriptions of a large interacting particle system, see, e.g., Spohn . This relates to the transport of energy in a cold gas following explosion – an instant injection of energy at its certain point. In Antal ; Chakraborti21 ; Chakraborti22 ; kumar , a cold gas with explosion was modeled as a system of resting hard disks undergoing elastic collisions with the excited particles. In the actual formulation, this model and the corresponding terminology were first introduced in Antal , where the two-dimensional case was also considered. While two- and three-dimensional versions of the model are more adequate, their rigorous study at the microscopic level is highly challenging. In the one-dimensional models, the collisions are inevitable even if the disks (rods) are shrunk to points. However, such one-dimensional models have a degenerate version: if all the particles have equal masses, the dynamics gets trivial (domino-like), as the number of moving particles is conserved ( =1 ) and the blast front evolves as {\cal R}(t)=v_{0}t . To get rid of this degeneracy, one studies systems of particles with masses alternating between different values, the number of which is two in the simplest case. Such a model is known as the alternating hard particle (AHP) gas, see also Dhar ; Garrido ; Grass . In the symmetric version of the AHP gas, the blast fronts move in both directions, and their distance to the injection site evolves as {\cal R}(t)\sim t^{2/3} , which was obtained by molecular dynamics (MD) simulations Chakraborti21 in agreement with the corresponding hydrodynamic result obtained by solving Euler’s equation. Another version of the AHP gas was studied in Chakraborti22 . It is the system of resting point particles distributed over the positive part of the real axis, in which the dynamics is initiated by giving positive velocity to the particle located at the origin. Then the blast front moves in the positive direction whereas recoiled particles behind it can move in the opposite direction and enter the negative half-axis forming a ‘splatter’. In the sequel, the models of Chakraborti21 and Chakraborti22 will be called symmetric and asymmetric AHP gas models, respectively. Similarly as in Chakraborti21 , the results of Chakraborti22 were obtained by making analytic predictions based on solving the corresponding hydrodynamic equation confronted with numerical simulation results of solving Newtonian equations of motion. In the simulations, the initial positions of the particles were sampled from the uniformly distributed ensemble. Among the results of Chakraborti22 obtained for the system of particles with masses m,\mu,m,\dots , m/\mu=2 , we mention the following: (i) the blast front evolves as {\cal R}(t)\sim t^{\delta} with \delta\simeq 0.628 ; (ii) the splatter moves in the ballistic way; (iii) the energy \mathcal{E}_{x\geq 0}(t) of the particles with locations x\geq 0 at time t decays to zero as t^{-\beta} with \beta\simeq 0.1161 ; (iv) the number of collisions up to time t increases as \mathcal{C}(t)\sim t^{2(2-\beta)/3} with \beta as just mentioned. It was claimed that essentially the same results were obtained also for m/\mu=3 and m/\mu=10 . In this work, we study the model of Chakraborti22 with various values of m/\mu . We explicitly found the collection of positive numbers \{\mathcal{M}_{i}:i\in\mathbf{N}\} , see ( 9 ) below, such that, for m/\mu=\mathcal{M}_{i} , i\leq 700 , the following holds. If the particles are initially located equidistantly, then: (a) the splatter is absent; (b) the number of simultaneously moving particles is at most three; (c) the blast front moves in the ballistic way – in contrast to the hydrodynamic picture drawn in Chakraborti22 . This conclusion is applicable also to the symmetric AHP gas studied in Chakraborti21 . For m/\mu close to \mathcal{M}_{i} , the front motion remains ballistic-like – at least in the window the span of which depends on i and |\mathcal{M}_{i}-m/\mu| . At the same time, for other values of m/\mu , including m/\mu=2 , as well as for m/\mu=\mathcal{M}_{i} and random initial particle positions, our results are essentially the same as those found in Chakraborti22 . Further discussion of these issues is given below. II. The Results. Posing. – If point particles a and b , with masses m_{a} and m_{b} , undergo an elastic collision, their velocities after, v^{\prime}_{a} and v^{\prime}_{b} , and before, v_{a} and v_{b} , the collision satisfy v^{\prime}_{a}=\frac{m_{a}-m_{b}}{m_{a}+m_{b}}v_{a}+\left(1-\frac{m_{a}-m_{b}}{m_{a}+m_{b}}\right)v_{b}, (1) with v^{\prime}_{b} obtained by interchanging a and b in ( 1 ). We consider an infinite system of initially resting point particles numbered 0,1,2,\dots with initial positions x^{0}_{k}=k and masses m,1,m,1,\dots , m\geq 1 . At time t=0 , particle 0 (with mass m ) receives rightward velocity v_{0}=1 , and the entire system is gradually set into motion in which the particles undergo elastic collisions and can enter the negative half-axis. Their dynamics is observed in the window containing N first particles, i.e., it is terminated at t=t_{\rm{fin}} when particle N-1 is hit for the first time. The following observables are to be considered: \mathcal{R}(t) - the position of the rightmost moving particle at time t (blast front); \mathcal{C}(t) - the number of collisions up to time t ; \mathcal{E}_{x\geq 0}(t) - the energy of particles with coordinates x\geq 0 at time t . We will also consider \mathcal{C}_{\rm fin}=\mathcal{C}(t_{\rm{fin}}) and \mathcal{E}_{\rm fin}=\mathcal{E}_{x\geq 0}(t_{\rm{fin}}) – the total observed number of collisions and the energy of all particles with x\geq 0 at t=t_{\rm{fin}} . The numerical values

Read the complete text