Collective dynamics in holographic fractonic solids
Ling-Zheng Xia 1, Lixin Xu 1, Wei-Jia Li 1 · 2025
Read Collective dynamics in holographic fractonic solids by Ling-Zheng Xia 1, Lixin Xu 1, Wei-Jia Li 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-17404.txt.
Introduction
Fractons are odd excitations that can barely move, first found in certain quantum error correcting codes, and they have drawn interest from high energy physics as well. Ling-Zheng Xia, Lixin Xu, and Wei-Jia Li build a holographic model of a fractonic solid, using a black hole in a higher dimensional space to describe the material behaviour. Their aim is a full account of how such a solid vibrates and spreads energy at low energies.
By computing the natural vibration patterns of the black hole, Xia and his co-authors recover every collective mode of the solid. The list holds two sound like waves, one spreading mode, and one unusually slow mode that fades with the fourth power of its wave number. That slow mode stays present even when the crystal symmetry is openly broken.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ling-Zheng Xia 1, Lixin Xu 1, Wei-Jia Li 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-17404
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Collective dynamics in holographic fractonic solids Ling-Zheng Xia 1, Lixin Xu 1, Wei-Jia Li 1 Abstract Fractonic phases of matter, a class of states in which collective excitations with constrained mobility exist, have recently emerged as a novel avenue for ergodicity breaking and garnered broad interest in condensed matter physics. In this work, we consider a (3+1)-dimensional holographic model of fractonic solids and investigate the low-energy collective dynamics systematically. By computing the quasinormal modes of black holes, we obtain all the hydrodynamic excitations on the boundary, including two acoustic phonons, a longitudinal diffusive mode as well as a fractonic subdiffusive mode with the dispersion ω ∼ − i k 4 \omega\sim-ik^{4} . In addition, it is found that the fracton mode remains gapless when translational symmetry is explicitly broken. These results suggest that fractonic excitations are inherently protected by the crystal-dipole symmetry in solids and are qualitatively unaffected by broken spacetime symmetries. I Introduction Fractons, a novel type of collective excitations exhibiting constrained mobility, have attracted broad attention in the study of many-body quantum matter in recent years Chamon 2005 ; Dubovsky et al. 2006 ; Haah 2011 ; Vijay et al. 2015 ; Vijay et al. 2016 ; Qi et al. 2023 ; Jain and Jensen 2022 . Theoretically, it was proposed that the constrained motion of collective modes arises because, in addition to monopole charge, multipole moments such as the dipole moment are also conserved Pretko 2018 ; Pretko et al. 2020 , making individual charge carriers immobile while allowing certain neutral bound states to spread. This mechanism gives rise to a family of subdiffusive modes. Such a dramatic slowing of collective dynamics is a manifestation of ergodicity breaking in the system Prem et al. 2017 ; Pai et al. 2019 . Furthermore, the inherent stability of these excitations also implies potential applications in quantum information storage and processing Brown and Williamson 2020 ; Terhal 2015 ; Bravyi and Haah 2013 . Several reviews summarize developments in these areas (see Gromov and Radzihovsky 2024 ; Nandkishore and Hermele 2019 ; Pretko et al. 2020 ). The effort to formulate a universal description of fracton phases has led to the development of the so-called fracton hydrodynamics. This framework has been built progressively, starting from simple systems with only charge and dipole conservation Gromov et al. 2020 , and later adding other key ingredients like momentum Grosvenor et al. 2021 ; Glorioso et al. 2022 ; Burchards et al. 2022 ; Guo et al. 2022 ; Hart et al. 2022 ; Glorioso et al. 2023 ; Osborne and Lucas 2022 as well as energy Głódkowski et al. 2023 ; Jain et al. 2023 ; Jain et al. 2024 ; Jain 2024 . The dipole symmetry of fractons is related to the breaking of continuous spatial translations Pretko et al. 2020 ; Glorioso et al. 2023 ; Gromov 2019 . Since this symmetry breaking is a ubiquitous feature of solid systems, occurring either spontaneously or explicitly through mechanisms such as lattices, impurities, or defects Chaikin and Lubensky 1995 ; Grüner 1988 , solids serve as a crucial platform for the realization of fractons. However, embedding fractons within the solid-state context raises a natural question: how do the Goldstone modes of a solid (acoustic phonons) coexist and interact with the subdiffusive mode of a fractonic system? The study of fractonic solids will enrich our understanding of fractonic phases as well as the interplay between the dipole symmetry and spacetime symmetries. During the past few decades, the AdS/CFT correspondence, or holographic duality, has become a powerful tool for tackling real-time dynamics of strongly correlated many-body systems Ammon and Erdmenger 2015 ; Baggioli 2019 ; Maldacena 1998 ; Witten 1998 . This approach has proven to be particularly powerful in condensed matter physics, especially for understanding exotic phases of matter where traditional perturbative methods fail Hartnoll et al. 2018 ; Zaanen et al. 2015 . A key point for modeling properties of solids is to break the translational symmetry spontaneously. Among the various holographic systems implementing this symmetry breaking pattern, the holographic axion model stands out as perhaps the most economical. For a detailed review of this model, one can refer to Baggioli et al. 2021 . Inspired by recent theoretical developments, especially the hydrodynamic studies of collective modes in Jain 2024 ; Głódkowski 2025 ; Stahl et al. 2023 and the holographic subdiffusion model in Ganesan and Lucas 2020 , we investigate the collective dynamics of fractonic solids through a generalized holographic axion model coupled with monopole and crystal-dipole gauge fields in the bulk. In particular, we focus on the intricate interaction among the fracton, the energy-momentum tensor, and the acoustic phonons in solid systems. To begin with, we review the effective theory formulation of fractonic solids. In the framework of effective field theory (EFT), the low-energy dynamics of a solid can be described by introducing a set of scalar fields \{\phi^{I},\,I=1,2,\dots,d\} , which serve as co-moving coordinates for the constituent elements of the solid. In the equilibrium state, their vacuum expectation values are linearly dependent on the spatial coordinates Nicolis et al. 2014 , \langle\phi^{I}\rangle=\delta^{I}_{i}x^{i}, (1) where lowercase Latin indices denote spatial directions and uppercase indices label the internal field space. Although this configuration spontaneously breaks the translational invariance, homogeneity is preserved by imposing an internal shift symmetry \phi^{I}\to\phi^{I}+c^{I}. (2) Then, one can construct the general low energy effective action that is invariant under both the spatial translations and internal shifts. The vacuum expectation value ( 1 ) spontaneously breaks the symmetry group down to the diagonal subgroup. The fluctuations of the scalar fields around their equilibrium positions \delta\phi^{I}=\phi^{I}-\langle\phi^{I}\rangle are precisely the Goldstone modes of broken translations. In this way, the phonon dynamics and the associated elasticity of solids can be reproduced in this formulation Nicolis et al. 2014 ; Nicolis et al. 2015 ; Esposito et al. 2017 . In addition, a complex scalar \Psi is introduced to describe the fractonic matter, associated with the monopole and crystal-dipole symmetry Jain 2024 ; Głódkowski 2025 \Psi\to e^{i(a+b^{I}\phi^{I})}\Psi, (3) where a and b^{I} are constant parameters corresponding to the monopole and crystal-dipole transformations, respectively. To derive the Ward identities of the conserved quantities, one can introduce two gauge fields, \mathbb{A}_{\mu} and \mathbb{A}^{I}_{\mu} , which allow us to probe the response of the system and identify the conserved currents. Their gauge transformations are imposed as \begin{cases}\mathbb{A}_{\mu}\to\mathbb{A}_{\mu}+\partial_{\mu}a(x),\\ \mathbb{A}^{I}_{\mu}\to\mathbb{A}^{I}_{\mu}+\partial_{\mu}b^{I}(x),\end{cases} (4) where a(x) and b^{I}(x) are arbitrary local functions. Then, introducing the covariant derivative D_{\mu}\equiv\partial_{\mu}-i\tilde{\mathbb{A}}_{\mu}=\partial_{\mu}-i(\mathbb{A}_{\mu}+\phi^{I}\mathbb{A}^{I}_{\mu}) together with the spatial covariant operator D^{IJ}(\Psi,\Psi)\equiv\Psi D^{(I}D^{J)}\Psi-D^{I}\Psi D^{J}\Psi-i\partial^{\mu}\phi^{(I}A^{J)}_{\mu}\Psi^{2},\quad\text{with}\ D^{I}\equiv\partial^{\mu}\phi^{I}D_{\mu}, (5) one can construct a crystal-dipole invariant Lagrangian Jain 2024 . Moreover, varying the effective action of the theory with respect to the metric and the two gauge fields yields the expression Głódkowski 2025 \delta\mathbb{S}=\int\mathrm{d}^{d+1}x\bigg(\frac{1}{2}T^{\mu\nu}\delta g_{\mu\nu}+J^{\mu}\delta\tilde{\mathbb{A}}_{\mu}+J^{I\mu}\delta\mathbb{A}_{\mu}^{I}\bigg). (6) The total variations above are given by \displaystyle\delta g_{\mu\nu}= \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\xi}g_{\mu\nu}, (7) \displaystyle\delta\tilde{\mathbb{A}}_{\mu}= \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\xi}\tilde{\mathbb{A}}_{\mu}+\partial_{\mu}a(x)+\phi^{I}\partial_{\mu}b^{I}(x) (8) \displaystyle\delta\mathbb{A}^{I}_{\mu}= \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\xi}\mathbb{A}^{I}_{\mu}+\partial_{\mu}b^{I}(x), (9) where \mathcal{L}_{\xi} denotes the Lie derivative with respect to a vector field \xi^{\mu} . The corresponding Ward identities related to spacetime diffeomorphism, monopole transformation, and crystal-dipole transformation are expressed as \displaystyle\partial_{\mu}T^{\mu\nu} \displaystyle=\mathscr{F}^{\nu}_{\ \mu}J^{\mu}+\mathbb{F}^{I\nu}_{\ \ \,\mu}J^{I\mu}, (10) \displaystyle\partial_{\mu}J^{\mu} \displaystyle=0, (11) \displaystyle\partial_{\mu}J^{I\mu} \displaystyle=-J^{\mu}\partial_{\mu}\phi^{I}, (12) where \displaystyle\mathscr{F}_{\mu\nu} \displaystyle\equiv\tilde{\mathbb{F}}_{\mu\nu}+2\mathbb{A}^{I}_{[\mu}\partial_{\nu]}\phi^{I}=2\partial_{[\mu}\tilde{\mathbb{A}}_{\nu]}+2\mathbb{A}^{I}_{[\mu}\partial_{\nu]}\phi^{I}, (13) \displaystyle\mathbb{F}^{I}_{\mu\nu} \displaystyle\equiv 2\partial_{[\mu}\mathbb{A}^{I}_{\nu]}. (14) It is worth pointing out that the