Mixed LR- C ( α ) C(\alpha) -type tests for irregular hypotheses, general criterion functions and misspecified models
Jean-Marie Dufour, Purevdorj Tuvaandorj · 2025
Read Mixed LR- C ( α ) C(\alpha) -type tests for irregular hypotheses, general criterion functions and misspecified models by Jean-Marie Dufour, Purevdorj Tuvaandorj (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-17070.txt.
Introduction
Jean-Marie Dufour and Purevdorj Tuvaandorj build a new kind of test for fitted models in this 2025 paper. Standard tests can break when a model is wrong or a value sits at an edge. Edge cases arise when a value cannot go below zero. The authors seek a test that stays sound in both hard cases.
Their test adjusts the fit scores for the free and fixed cases apart. Its large-sample spread stays the same known curve even when the model is wrong. It needs only rough first guesses for side values. Tests on risk and life-span models keep the right size and good power. A real data case shows sharper findings than a standard test.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jean-Marie Dufour, Purevdorj Tuvaandorj |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 55 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-17070
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Mixed LR- C ( α ) C(\alpha) -type tests for irregular hypotheses, general criterion functions and misspecified models Thanks: First version: November 29, 2024; This version: June 12, 2025. Jean-Marie Dufour, Purevdorj Tuvaandorj Abstract This paper introduces a likelihood ratio (LR)-type test that possesses the robustness properties of C ( α ) C(\alpha) -type procedures in an extremum estimation setting. The test statistic is constructed by applying separate adjustments to the restricted and unrestricted criterion functions, and is shown to be asymptotically pivotal under minimal conditions. It features two main robustness properties. First, unlike standard LR-type statistics, its null asymptotic distribution remains chi-square even under model misspecification, where the information matrix equality fails. Second, it accommodates irregular hypotheses involving constrained parameter spaces, such as boundary parameters, relying solely on root- n n -consistent estimators for nuisance parameters. When the model is correctly specified, no boundary constraints are present, and parameters are estimated by extremum estimators, the proposed test reduces to the standard LR-type statistic. Simulations with ARCH models, where volatility parameters are constrained to be nonnegative, and parametric survival regressions with potentially monotone increasing hazard functions, demonstrate that our test maintains accurate size and exhibits good power. An empirical application to a two-way error components model shows that the proposed test can provide more informative inference than the conventional t t -test. Keywords : asymptotically pivotal statistics; boundary parameters; C ( α ) C(\alpha) -type tests; misspecification; nuisance parameters; LR tests; extremum estimation 1 Introduction Neyman 1959 introduced the C(\alpha) statistic as a versatile approach for testing composite hypotheses, especially in cases where exact optimal tests are unavailable or maximum likelihood estimates (MLEs) are difficult to obtain. This paper introduces a likelihood ratio-type C(\alpha) test (referred to hereafter as LRC α ) for nonlinear hypotheses. The test statistic is constructed using log-likelihood functions that are “orthogonalized” against the score functions of nuisance parameters, which account for the direction of estimation error. Neyman 1959 ’s original C(\alpha) statistic is a score-type test, where a score function associated with the parameter of interest is orthogonalized against the nuisance parameter scores. As a result, the relationship between the proposed statistic and Neyman’s C(\alpha) statistic mirrors the relationship between the classical likelihood ratio (LR) test and the Lagrange multiplier (LM) test. 1 1 1 In fact, Neyman 1959 considers a more general score-type function, referred to as the Cramér function . LR tests are attractive because they are firmly anchored in likelihood theory, invariant to re-parameterization, enjoy Neyman–Pearson optimality, and—under correct specification—yield a simple chi-square null asymptotic distribution that delivers powerful inference without ad-hoc variance estimates. This pivotality property, however, relies on the information-matrix equality; when the model is misspecified, the equality fails, the LR statistic ceases to pivot and size distortions may arise. Our misspecification-robust, C(\alpha) -style adjustment overcomes this by “orthogonalising” the restricted and unrestricted criteria before differencing. The resulting LRC α statistic restores the chi-square null law while retaining the advantages of LR statistics, and it does so under the much weaker requirement that nuisance parameters be merely root- n consistent—whereas conventional LM, LR, and Wald tests require full asymptotic normality of the estimates ( Newey and McFadden 1994 ; Gouriéroux and Monfort 1995 ) . Accordingly, the LRC α test operates under weaker assumptions than standard LR procedures, remains valid in a variety of non-regular problems, and thus provides a valuable addition to the econometrician’s toolkit. Below, we outline several (not mutually exclusive) scenarios in which C(\alpha) -type tests—and the proposed LRC α test in particular—are especially effective. 1. Nonnormal distribution – the nuisance parameter estimator may fail to weakly converge to a random vector, or its asymptotic distribution may deviate from Gaussianity. Such nonnormal distributions can arise, for example, when shrinkage methods are employed to estimate nuisance parameters. In these situations, the C(\alpha) statistic remains applicable, even when the classical Wald, score, and LR statistics may not be directly applicable without appropriate modifications. A prominent example of a non-regular problem where the C(\alpha) test proves effective is inference after model selection or regularization. For further discussion, see Chernozhukov et al. 2015 , Belloni et al. 2016 , Belloni et al. 2018 and Chernozhukov et al. 2018 . 2. Parameter space – the C(\alpha) test does not rely on specific assumptions about the parameter space. For instance, the parameters can be subject to inequality constraints ( Silvapulle and Sen 2011 ) , or the model parameters may lie on the boundary of the parameter space. These constraints can also reflect researchers’ prior knowledge, such as box constraints imposed during the optimization of likelihood or other objective functions. Examples of models with boundary-related issues include GARCH-type models and random coefficient models, where the variance parameters are constrained to be nonnegative. The C(\alpha) test remains asymptotically pivotal under the null hypothesis, even when the model parameters, or some of their components, lie either in the interior or on the boundary of the parameter space, as long as the nuisance parameter is n^{1/2} -consistently estimable. To our knowledge, this robustness property in a general constrained estimation setting has not been previously explored. 3. Computational advantage – the C(\alpha) statistic offers flexibility in incorporating auxiliary estimators of the nuisance parameters obtained through various estimation methods. These include Bayesian estimators for SVAR models ( Kilian and Lütkepohl 2017 , Chapter 5) , OLS estimators for ARCH models ( Francq and Zakoian 2019 , Chapter 6) , two-step estimators for sample selection and limited dependent variable models ( Wooldridge 2010 ) , and minimum distance or moment-matching estimators for macroeconometric models ( DeJong and Dave 2012 ) . Whenever convenient, computationally cheaper or numerically stable estimators for the nuisance parameters can be employed in the C(\alpha) statistics. Classical examples where MLEs are challenging to compute but computationally attractive M - and moment estimators are readily available include the Cauchy likelihood and mixture distributions ( van der Vaart 1998 , Chapter 5.7) . 4. Data combination – in the C(\alpha) statistic, the source from which the nuisance parameter estimate is obtained is not need to be specified as long as the nuisance parameter is estimated with a reasonable precision. For example, the parameter estimates can obtained by data combination ( Imbens and Lancaster 1994 ; Ridder and Moffitt 2007 ) or by calibration ( Cocci and Plagborg-Møller 2024 ) obtained from other data sources. The literature on C(\alpha) tests is vast, having developed Neyman’s original score-type approach into a rich body of work. Contributions include Le Cam 1956 , Bhat and Nagnur 1965 , Bühler and Puri 1966 , Bartoo and Puri 1967 , Moran 1970 ; Moran 1973 , Chibisov 1973 ; Chibisov 1980 , Chant 1974 , Ray 1974 , Singh and Zhurbenko 1975 , Foutz 1976 , Vorob’ev and Zhurbenko 1979 , Bernshtein 1976 ; Bernshtein 1978 ; Bernshtein 1980a ; Bernshtein 1980b ; Bernshtein 1981 , Le Cam and Traxler 1978 , Neyman 1979 , Tarone 1979 ; Tarone 1985 , Tarone and Gart 1980 , Wang 1981 ; Wang 1982 , Basawa 1985 , Ronchetti 1987 , Smith 1987a ; Smith 1987b , Berger and Wallenstein 1989 , Hall and Mathiason 1990 , Paul and Barnwal 1990 , Wooldridge