On the algebraic properties of the Böröczky configuration

Jake Kettinger, Shahriyar Roshan Zamir · 2025

Read On the algebraic properties of the Böröczky configuration by Jake Kettinger, Shahriyar Roshan Zamir (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-17029.txt.

Introduction

Jake Kettinger and Shahriyar Roshan-Zamir study a famous line-and-point pattern in a 2025 paper. The pattern is the Böröczky configuration of lines and multiple points. It shows extreme behavior in algebra and combinatorics. It appears in problems about powers of ideals and point-line incidences.

The authors compute a key constant for the pattern's defining ideal. That constant, the Waldschmidt constant, measures asymptotic containment behavior. They also bound the degrees of the ideal's minimal generators. Their bound comes from a weighted projective plane construction. Applying it to an elliptic curve yields a fresh counterexample. The example defeats a hoped-for containment between ideal powers. Such counterexamples guide algebraists about where general theorems must stop.

Catalog record

CREATORJake Kettinger, Shahriyar Roshan Zamir
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-17029

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the algebraic properties of the Böröczky configuration Thanks: Mathematics Subject Classification: 13A50, 14N20, 14L30. Thanks: Key Words: Böröczky Configuration, Containment Problem, Weighted Projective Space, Non-Standard Grading, Elliptic Curves. Jake Kettinger, Shahriyar Roshan Zamir Abstract . The Böröczky configuration of lines and (multiple) points exhibits extremal behavior in commutative algebra and combinatorics. Examples of this appear in the context of the containment problem for ordinary and symbolic powers and the proof of the Dirac-Motzkin conjecture by Green and Tao. This paper studies the algebraic properties of Böröczky configurations for arbitrary values of n n . Our results compute the Waldschmit constant of the defining ideal of these configurations. Moreover, we use the weighted projective plane ℙ ⁡ ( 1 , 2 , 3 ) {\mathbb{P}}(1,2,3) to give an upper bound for the degree of the minimal generators of their ideal. Finally, this construction is applied to an elliptic curve in ℙ 2 \mathbb{P}^{2} to give a new counterexample to the containment I ( 3 ) ⊆ I 2 I^{(3)}\subseteq I^{2} . 1. Introduction The goal of this note is to study the algebraic properties of the Böröczky configuration of lines and points. The Böröczky configuration, defined for every n\geq 3 , consists of lines, ordinary points, where exactly two lines meet, and triple points, where exactly three lines of the configuration meet; see Section 4 for a precise definition. Let B_{n} denote the set of all lines and all intersection points of the Böröczky configuration. There are two competing definitions of this configuration in the literature. One used by Green and Tao [ GT13 ] in their proof of the Dirac-Motzkin conjecture, and one used by Füredi and Palásti [ FP84 ] which, among other results, provides a negative answer to a question of Paul Erdös. An essential difference between the two is that Green and Tao consider this construction in the real projective plane while Füredi and Palásti make use of it in the real affine plane. The latter construction described in [ FP84 ] , considered in the affine chart U_{2} of \mathbb{P}^{2} , is the one of interest to us and henceforth is referred to “the Böröczky configuration.” It it notable that their construction is a special case of an earlier construction by Burr, Grünbaum and Sloane [ SAB74 ] which uses elliptic integration; see [ FP84 , Section 6] . We draw another connection to elliptic curves in Section 5 . The algebraic context in which the Böröczky configuration arises is the containment problem of ordinary and symbolic powers. The specific problem related to this paper is for height 2 ideals in the standard graded polynomial ring k[x_{0},x_{1},x_{2}] , namely those ideals that define points in {\mathbb{P}}^{2} . Craig Huneke asked if the containment (1.1) I^{(3)}\subseteq I^{2} always holds, where I^{(3)} denotes the third symbolic power of I . Henceforth Equation 1.1 is referred to as the containment problem. While Equation 1.1 holds for general points in {\mathbb{P}}^{2} [ BH09 , Remark 4.3] , the first counterexample to this containment was given in [ DSTG13 ] . Sets of points that fail Equation 1.1 are special and demonstrate high levels of symmetry. The containment problem, and its variants such as [ HH11 , Conjecture 4.1.1] and [ Gri20 , Conjecture 2.1] , have generated a plethora of research; see [ DS21 , DHN+15a , DHN+15b , CHM+16 , HS15 , MS18 , Dra17 , Ake17 ] . A survey of the results on the containment problem can be found in [ SS16 ] . Both real and projective Böröczky configurations exhibit extremal behavior in algebraic and combinatorial contexts. Let \mathcal{B}_{n} denote the set of triple points of B_{n} with I_{n} as its homogenous defining ideal. The main observation of [ CHM+16 ] is the fact that I_{12}^{(3)}\not\subseteq I_{12}^{2} ; this was the first counterexample to the containment problem over the real numbers. It is noteworthy that Green and Tao’s interest in the projective Böröczky is its extreme behavior in the context of the Dirac-Motzkin conjecture [ GT13 , p.10] : These (Böröczky) sets, it turns out, provide the example of non-colinear sets of n points with fewest number of ordinary lines, at least for large n . In fact they are the only configurations, up to projective equivalence, that achieve the lower bound for the number of ordinary lines, which contain ordinary points only, of a configuration of lines and point as conjectured by Dirac and Motzkin; see [ GT13 , Theorem 2.2] . We summarize the known results about the Böröczky configuration. The authors in [ FKLBTG17 ] consider \mathcal{B}_{12} and another configuration of lines and points to show combinatorial data alone does not determine the containment I^{(3)}\subseteq I^{2} . For small values of n , the authors in [ LBS16 , FKLBTG18 ] consider a parameter space of \mathcal{B}_{n} , in order to investigate other rational counterexamples to the containment problem, and [ Kab19 ] studies some combinatorial aspects of Böröczky configuration. Finally, [ Kab22 ] shows, albeit using Macaulay2, that I_{n} satisfies Equation 1.1 for 1\leq n\leq 11 . This paper aims to start the first systematic study of the set \mathcal{B}_{n} and the algebraic properties of I_{n} for arbitrary values of n . The following is a summary of our results. Assuming that 3\mid n , Proposition 3.2 shows the set of triple intersection points \mathcal{B}_{n} admits an action of D_{6} and Proposition 3.3 computes the number of orbits of size 3 and 6 of this action. Next, Theorem 4.3 computes the Waldschmit constant of I_{n} . The Waldschmit constant is an important algebraic invariant of an ideal which yields a natural lower bound for the degree of the minimal generators. In Corollary 4.6 we use the properties of the weighted projective space {\mathbb{P}}(1,2,3) to give an upper bound for the degree of the minimal generators of I_{n} . Proposition 4.8 shows the smallest degree form in I_{n}^{(3)} is the product of the lines of B_{n} , the vector space (I_{n}^{(3)})_{n} is one dimensional, generated by this product and admits the alternating sign representation of D_{6} . In Section 5 we describe how applying this construction to points on an elliptic curve resulted in a new counterexample to Equation 1.1 . Finally, Section 6 presents some open problems. Acknowledgments 1.1 . The authors thank Alexandra Seceleanu for comments on earlier versions of this paper. We thank Tomasz Szemberg for helpful discussions during the UWE Fest conference. Roshan Zamir received support from the NSF grants DMS–2401482 and DMS-2342256 RTG: Commutative Algebra at Nebraska. 2. Action of D_{6} on \mathbb{P}^{2} Fix k to be the field of complex numbers. Consider the natural action of D_{6} , the dihedral group of order 6 , on \mathbb{A}_{k}^{2} given by the symmetries of an equilateral triangle. Fix an embedding of \mathbb{A}^{2} into \mathbb{P}^{2} via (2.1) (a,b)\to[a:b:1]. The induced action of D_{6} on \mathbb{P}^{2} is given by g\cdot[a:b:c]=[g(a,b):c] and is referred to as “the action of D_{6} on {\mathbb{P}}^{2} .” Equivalently, one can identify D_{6} with a subgroup of PGL {}_{3}(k) generated by \left\langle\left[\begin{matrix}\cos(\frac{2\pi}{3})&-\sin(\frac{2\pi}{3})&0\\ \sin(\frac{2\pi}{3})&\cos(\frac{2\pi}{3})&0\\ 0&0&1\end{matrix}\right],\left[\begin{matrix}1&0&0\\ 0&-1&0\\ 0&0&1\end{matrix}\right]\right\rangle This induces an action of D_{6} on U_{2} , the standard affine chart of \mathbb{P}^{2} identified with {\mathbb{A}}^{2} . The

Read the complete text