SN Ia-CSM 2020aeuh: Massive binary C/O WD merger?

© 2025  N. N. Chugai · 2025

Read SN Ia-CSM 2020aeuh: Massive binary C/O WD merger? by © 2025  N. N. Chugai (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-16840.txt.

Introduction

N. N. Chugai studies one odd stellar explosion in a 2025 astronomy paper. The event, called SN 2020aeuh, was a type Ia supernova. Such explosions come from white dwarfs, the dense remains of dead stars. Around this one sat a shell of gas, which is unusual.

Chugai models the light curve, meaning how the brightness rose and fell. From it he estimates the mass of fresh nickel and the shell. The shell is light, wide, and moving fairly slowly outward. Those facts fit a merger of two heavy white dwarfs. The merger likely threw off gas, then waited decades before exploding. The paper tests that story against the observations.

Catalog record

CREATOR© 2025  N. N. Chugai
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE15 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-16840

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

SN Ia-CSM 2020aeuh: Massive binary C/O WD merger? © 2025 N. N. Chugai Abstract I explore the origin of the circumstellar (CS) shell of the unusual SN Ia 2020aeuh based on the light curve model abd observational constraints. I estimate the 56 Ni mass (1.1 M ⊙ M_{\odot} ), CS shell mass (0.04–0.2 M ⊙ M_{\odot} ), radius ( 2 × 10 16 2\times 10^{16} cm), and expansion velocity ≲ 200 \lesssim 200 km s -1 . Large 56 Ni mass and properties of the CS shell are consistent with the scenario of massive binary white dwarf merger that has been accompanied with the ejection of ∼ 0.1 \sim 0.1 M ⊙ M_{\odot} of matter. It is argued that SN 2020aeuh exploded not earlier than 30 yr after the merger. keywords: stars – supernovae; stars – binary stars PACS codes: 1 Introduction A variety of supernovae SN Ia interacting with a dense circumstellar matter (CSM) came into limelight after the detection of SN 2002ic with the SN 1991T-like spectrum (Hamuy et al. 2003) and the circumstellar (CS) H \alpha emission with the apparent signature of the CS interaction. Currently, the category of SN Ia-CSM comprises 28 events (Sharma et al. 2023). In all the cases spectra show CS emission lines of hydrogen and/or helium; this fact presumably indicates a single degenerate scenario for these SN Ia. Unusual SN 2020aeuh studied in detail by Tsalapatas et al (2025) belongs to this subclass, but it stands out by two spectacular features: (i) the CS interaction turned on only at about +50 days after the discovery, so the initial luminosity maximum of SN Ia on +15 day is well seen being separated from the CS interaction luminosity bump; (ii) the CSM does not show either hydrogen or helium emission lines; instead it demonstrates O i 7774 Å and C ii 5890 AA narrow emission lines impying C/O-rich matter (Tsalapatas et al. 2025). Authors estimate the mass of the CS shell to be 1-2 M_{\odot} and the radius of \approx 10^{16} cm (Tsalapatas et al. 2025). The O i and C ii emission lines from CSM compells ones to propose the origin of the CSM in the scenario of double C/O white dwarf (WD) merger (Tsalapatas et al. 2025, Soker 2025) 2 2 2 SN I via double C/O WD merger (cf. Webbink 1979) . Yet authors acknowledge (Tsalapatas et al. 2025) that large CSM mass is difficult to reconcile with this scenario. A 3D-simulation of binary WDs fly-by collision in parabolic orbits results in the ejection, at best, of a few tenths of solar mass, far below required amount ( >1 M_{\odot} ) (Tsalapatas et al. 2025). On the other hand, the high maximum luminosity on day +15 (-19.7 mag) means that SN 2020aeuh belongs to a family of overluminous SNe Ia that suggests a merger of massive C/O WDs (Taubenberger et al. 2013). The ejection of a few tenths of solar mass during the merger of massive C/O WD, e.g., with masses 1 M_{\odot} + 0.8 M_{\odot} , might be an appropriate scenario for SN 2020aeuh provided the actual CS mass significantly smaller than the solar mass. The challenging problem of the origin of the CSM around SN 2020aeuh emphasises the significance of the CSM mass estimate as a possible telltail of the underlying mass-loss mechanism. The goal of this paper is an alternative estimate of the CS shell mass based of the CS interaction modelling. It turns out that the CSM mass is a small fraction of the solar mass, so the double C/O WD merger scenario for SN 2020aeuh seems plausible. 2 Preliminaries Spectra obtained at the CS interaction stage ( \geq+81 day) are similar to the spectrum of SN 2002ic (disregarding H \alpha ) on day 244 (Wang et al. 2004): they are composed by broad emission bands, primarily of Fe ii lines, that originate from a fragmented cold dense shell (CDS) formed between forward and reverse shocks (Chugai et al. 2004). The Ca ii emission lines both ultraviolet doublet and infrared triplet permit ones to infer the expansion velocity of the CDS. Clear-cut blue edge of Ca ii 3933 Å on day +99 (cf. Tsalapatas et al. 2025) suggests the CDS expansion velocity of \approx 11000 km s -1 . This important obeservable is used below to additionaly constrain the CS interaction model. Less obvious is the issue of the CSM expansion velocity. The O i 7774 Å emission with the FWHM of \sim 1300 km s -1 (Tsalapatas et al. 2025) is apparently related to the CS shell. The narrow core ( \sim 200 km s -1 ) and broad wings ( \pm 2000 km s -1 ) of O i 7774 Å remind CS emission lines from a slowly expanding shell with a large Thomson optical depth ( \tau_{\tiny{T}}>1 ), similar to early SN 1998S (Chugai 2001). However, for SN 2020aeuh this broadening mechanism is rulled out, because for the shell with the radius of 10^{16} cm and 1 M_{\odot} mass composed of carbon and oxygen the Thomson optical depth is small, \tau_{\tiny{T}}<0.1 (for the double ionization of C and O). Figure 1: Theoretical profile of a line emitted by the CS shell with the spherical velocity distribution, but non-spherical density distribution of equatorial type with the emissivity depending on the polar angle \theta as \epsilon\propto(1-|\cos{\theta}|)^{3} for different cosine of an inclination angle. Another possibility is that the O i 7774 Å line forms due to the supernova interaction with a slowly expanding clumpy CSM likewise, e.g., the intermediate width H \alpha of IIn supernova SN 1988Z (Chugai & Danziger 1994). The crushed CS clouds fragmented and accelerated in the forward shock (Klein et al. 1994) produce a broad velocity spectrum of the line-emitting gas, which also has been suggested for the SN 2002ic H \alpha profile (Chugai & Chevalier 2007). In the framework of this mechanism the preshock expansion velocity of the clumpy shell in SN 2020aeuh is presumably \lesssim 200 km s -1 (the upper limit is the spectral resulution). Remarkably, admitting CSM anisotropy one can produce the line profile similar to O i 7774 Å, if one assumes a spherical expansion of the CSM with a constant velocity of 2000 km s -1 and axially symmetric matter distribution with the density maximum at the equator. To illustrate the point we adopt the line emissivity ( erg cm -3 s -1 ) distribution aong the polar angle \theta to be \epsilon\propto(1-|\cos{\theta}|)^{q} . For q=3 the line profile observed from the polar direction with zero inclination ( \cos{i}=1 ) (Fig. 1) is indeed similar to the observed O i 77774 Å line on day +99 (cf. Tsalapatas et al. 2025). However, similarity disappears even for a small deviation from the polar zxis. For \cos{i}=0.95 the profile loses sharp vertex, while for the larger deviation from the polar axis ( \cos{i}=0.8 ) the profile acquires two horn shape – classic signature of equatorial belt. Small probability of the favorable line of sight ( <0.05 ) makes this anisotropic model interesting, but improbable for SN 2020aeuh. A spherical clumpy CS shell thus is a more appropriate assumption for SN 2020eauh. The total radiated energy of the second

Read the complete text