Temporal Understanding under Deictic Frame of Reference

Damin Zhang, Julia Rayz · 2025

Read Temporal Understanding under Deictic Frame of Reference by Damin Zhang, Julia Rayz (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-16685.txt.

Introduction

Damin Zhang and Julia Rayz probe how language models grasp time in a 2025 study. Two frames shape how we place events in time. The deictic frame uses past, present, and future as its poles. The sequential frame uses before and after as its poles. Their data set holds real events drawn from Wikidata, a free fact base.

Models judge how alike event pairs feel in time, under each frame. Under the present-based frame, scores fade in a graded, lopsided way. Future events fade fastest, and past scores jump around most. Under the before-after frame, split pairs turn sharply unlike at once. Span links and event length sway the calls too. The map shows where model time sense holds firm or frays.

Catalog record

CREATORDamin Zhang, Julia Rayz
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-16685

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Temporal Understanding under Deictic Frame of Reference Damin Zhang, Julia Rayz Abstract Understanding time is fundamental to human cognition, where temporal experience is often conceptualized through spatial metaphors grounded in sensory-motor experience. For example, “summer is approaching” parallels “We are approaching the summer”. In such expressions, humans rely on a frame of reference (FoR) to interpret meaning relative to a particular viewpoint. Extending this concept to time, a temporal frame of reference (t-FoR) defines how temporal relations are perceived relative to an experiencer’s moment of “now”. While Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable advances in natural language understanding, their ability to interpret and reason about time remains limited. In this work, we introduce TUuD (Temporal Understanding under Deictic t-FoR), a framework that evaluates how LLMs interpret time-event and event-event relations when the reference point of “now” dynamically shifts along a timeline. Following recent work on temporal cognition li2025other , LLMs are prompted to rate the similarity between the current moment and a target event from 0.00 (completely dissimilar) to 1.00 (highly similar), where similarity quantifies perceived temporal alignment between the two points. Our results show that four evaluated LLMs exhibit measurable adaptation to a deictic t-FoR, with similarity ratings peaking around the present and decreasing toward past and future events. The adaptation, however, weakens beyond near-term contexts, suggesting that while LLMs display partial human-like temporal cognition, their temporal reasoning remains sensitive to reference-frame shifts and temporal distance. K eywords temporal understanding \cdot frame of reference 1 Introduction Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable progress across diverse natural language understanding and reasoning tasks zhao2023survey ; chang2024survey . Despite these advances, reasoning about time remains a persistent challenge jain2023language ; wallat2024temporal . LLMs often struggle to interpret temporal expressions, reason over sequences of events, or maintain consistency when temporal references are shifted or randomized. These limitations are especially evident in tasks involving temporal commonsense, event ordering, or time-sensitive question answering wallat2024temporal ; wei2022chain ; chu2024timebench ; yuan2024back . Temporal reasoning (TeR) refers to the ability to understand, represent, and reason about temporal relations between events or states. Prior research has primarily evaluated temporal reasoning through question-answering benchmarks such as TimeQA chen2021timeqa , TempLAMA dhingra2022time , and MCTACO zhou2019going . While these datasets have advanced the field, they typically operate within a fixed or absolute temporal context, where temporal anchors are explicitly provided. This approach raises concerns about data leakage and memorization effects, particularly when models have been pre-trained on similar or identical factual content, and often fails to assess whether models can adapt to different temporal perspectives or dynamically shifting reference points. In contrast, human temporal cognition is inherently perspectival. Cognitive and linguistic studies suggest that humans conceptualize time through spatial metaphors, grounded in embodied experience lakoff1999review ; mcglone1998back ; gentner2002time . For instance, “We are approaching Tuesday” (moving-ego perspective) versus “Tuesday is approaching” (moving-time perspective) reflects distinct frames of reference (FoR) for the same temporal relation. From a philosophical standpoint, this aligns with the distinction between A-series time, where events are ordered relative to the observer’s subjective “now”, and B-series time, where events are ordered objectively by succession. Such perspectival differences are central to how humans experience and reason about time. However, most existing temporal reasoning benchmarks implicitly assume a fixed extrinsic frame of reference, overlooking how models might behave when the reference point of “now” shifts dynamically. This gap leaves open an important question: Can LLMs adapt their temporal understanding when evaluated under a changing temporal frame of reference, particularly a deictic (experiencer-based) one ? To address this, we introduce TUuD (Temporal Understanding under Deictic t-FoR), a framework designed to evaluate LLMs’ ability to interpret and reason about temporal relations under a deictic t-FoR. TUuD systematically shifts the reference point of “now” across past and future moments to generate multiple time-event and event-event pairs. By measuring the similarity judgements between these pairs, TUuD enables a fine-grained analysis of how models perceive relative temporal distances and whether they exhibit human-like adaptation to perspectival temporal shifts. Considering hardware constraints and comparable text generation performance on the LM Arena leaderboard, we select four representative LLMs: Qwen3-30B-A3B-Instruct-2507, Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct, GPT-4.1-mini-2025-04-14, and Gemini-2.5-flash, for evaluation on our anonymized, temporally structured dataset derived from TimeQA. Our findings reveal that all evaluated LLMs demonstrate measurable adaptation to a deictic t-FoR, with similarity ratings that peak around the present and gradually decline toward the past and future. However, the degree and stability of this adaptation vary across models and temporal distances. These results highlight that, while LLMs can internalize deictic temporal relations to some extent, their temporal understanding remains fragile beyond near-term contexts, suggesting both cognitive parallels and systematic biases in LLM-based temporal reasoning. 2 Related Work 2.1 Temporal Reasoning Benchmarks Question-answering datasets such as SQuAD rajpurkar2016squad ; rajpurkar2018know and Natural Questions kwiatkowski2019natural primarily construct temporal questions within a single, fixed time period. However, some questions may have different answers depending on when they are asked. To address this, several datasets include time-sensitive questions, such as TimeQA chen2021timeqa , TempLAMA dhingra2022time , SituatedQA zhang2021situatedqa , StreamingQA liska2022streamingqa , RealtimeQA kasai2023realtime , TempReason tan2023towards , and MenatQA wei2023menatqa . Temporal commonsense knowledge, such as the fact that a leap year generally occurs every four years, is another important aspect of temporal reasoning. Datasets like MCTACO zhou2019going and TimeDial qin2021timedial focus specifically on evaluating models’ understanding of temporal commonsense. Beyond datasets targeting specific temporal properties or sequential relations, comprehensive benchmarks such as TRAM wang2024tram evaluate temporal reasoning across multiple tasks. Additionally, datasets such as TimeQuestions jia2021complex , ExpTime yuan2024back , TGQA xiong2024large , and ToT fatemi2024test leverage knowledge graphs to assess models’ understanding of time-event and event-event relations. 2.2 Frame of Reference A frame of reference (FoR) is a coordinate system used to determine the position of a figure relative to a ground from a particular perspective talmy2003toward , typically corresponding to the viewpoint of an observer. From a philosophical perspective, time can be conceptualized as either an A-series or a B-series mctaggart1908unreality . The A-series represents a tensed and dynamic view of time, where events are located relative to the observer’s subjective “now” (the deictic center) as past, present, or future. In this view, a future event successively becomes present and eventually shifts into the past. In contrast, the B-series reflects a tenseless and static ordering of events, where each event is positioned as earlier than or later than another, independent of any observer’s temporal standpoint. From a cognitive perspective, time is commonly represented through two conceptual metaphors: moving ego (ME) and moving time (MT). In the ME perspective, time is stationary while the observer (ego) moves forward through it, such as “We are approaching Tuesday”. In the MT perspective, the observer remains stationary while time itself flows toward them, for example, “Tuesday is approaching”. A temporal frame of reference (t-FoR) typically involves three components: a target event (TE), a reference point (RP), and an origo (O). The TE denotes the event being fixed, the RP provides the point of comparison relative to the TE, and the O serves as the anchoring perspective. As on the of the first attempts to integrate temporal perspectives within a FoR framework, moore2004ego distinguishes between ego-centered MT and non-deictic MT, proposing an

Read the complete text