Reciprocal swimming in viscoelastic granular hydrogels
Hongyi Xiao †, Jing Wang †, Achim Sack, Ralf Stannarius, Thorsten Pöschel · 2025
Read Reciprocal swimming in viscoelastic granular hydrogels by Hongyi Xiao †, Jing Wang †, Achim Sack, Ralf Stannarius, Thorsten Pöschel (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-16586.txt.
Introduction
Hongyi Xiao leads four co-authors in a 2025 lab study of a tiny swimmer in soft grains. The swimmer flaps two wings back and forth, like a scallop. The bath is a near-slick gel of soft hydrogel balls that stick a bit. Reciprocal motion, the same path back and forth, should not move a swimmer at slow scales.
Yet the swimmer did move when flap pace matched the gel's rest pace. It moved the other way than in hard, dry grains. At faster or slower flap pace, it stayed put past a brief start. X-ray shots show low-density zones form near the wings. Drag gaps from those zones, plus swimmer mass, explain the move. The find may aid soft-matter bots and grain work.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hongyi Xiao †, Jing Wang †, Achim Sack, Ralf Stannarius, Thorsten Pöschel |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 26 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-16586
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Reciprocal swimming in viscoelastic granular hydrogels Hongyi Xiao †, Jing Wang †, Achim Sack, Ralf Stannarius, Thorsten Pöschel Abstract We experimentally study a scallop-like swimmer with reciprocally flapping wings in a nearly frictionless, cohesive granular medium consisting of hydrogel spheres. Significant locomotion is found when the swimmer’s flapping frequency matches the inverse relaxation time of the material. Remarkably, the swimmer moves in the opposite direction compared to its motion in a cohesion-free granular material of hard plastic spheres. At higher or lower frequencies, we observe no motion of the swimmer, apart from a short initial transient phase. X-ray radiograms reveal that the wing motions create low-density zones, which in turn give rise to a hysteresis in drag and propulsion forces. This time-dependent effect, combined with the swimmer’s inertia, accounts for locomotion at intermediate frequencies. I Introduction Understanding active locomotion, such as the propulsion of living matter ( Goldstein 2016 ; Childress et al. 2012 ; Vogel 2020 ) or active colloids ( Buttinoni et al. 2013 ; Herminghaus et al. 2014 ; Ebbens et al. 2014 ) , is a challenging problem. In a Newtonian liquid at low Reynolds numbers, effective locomotion requires an asymmetrical sequence of shape changes. Reciprocal deformation cannot cause net propulsion due to the linearity and time reversibility of the Stokes equation, explained by Purcell’s scallop theorem ( Purcell 1977 ) . In non-Newtonian liquids with nonlinear rheological properties such as shear-dependent viscosity and normal-stress differences, swimmers are not constrained by this theorem, as they can achieve locomotion by periodic asymmetrical and symmetrical shape changes, e.g., cells with waving flagella and flapping scallops ( Lauga 2011 ; Arratia 2022 ; Qiu et al. 2014 ; Xu et al. 2024 ) . Non-continuum effects play an important role in complex fluids with heterogeneous microstructures, such as colloids, polymer solutions, and granular materials ( Balin et al. 2017 ; Zhang et al. 2018 ) . In highly concentrated polymer solutions, molecules can form gel-like networks, resulting in nonlinear rheological properties of the fluid. Swimmers can take advantage of effects such as normal stresses that increase with shear rate ( Normand & Lauga 2008 ; Pak et al. 2012 ; Datta et al. 2022 ) and shear-rate–dependent viscosity arising from body movements ( Fu et al. 2009 ; Qiu et al. 2014 ; Riley & Lauga 2017 ) . Propulsion gaits that stretch polymers in shear flow, thereby reducing the local viscosity around the swimmer, can enhance swimming efficiency under these conditions ( Fu et al. 2010 ; Wróbel et al. 2016 ) . In these situations, the flow of polymeric liquids can still be understood within the framework of fluid mechanics. Locomotion in granular media is a particularly rich problem, with examples ranging from sandfish lizards that undulate through sand ( Maladen et al. 2009 ; Goldman 2014 ) , to worms that burrow in soil via peristalsis ( Dorgan 2018 ) , and southern sand octopuses that fluidize the substrate to alter the resistance of submerged sand ( Montana et al. 2015 ) . These systems are challenging to understand because granular matter can behave either like a flowing liquid ( Forterre & Pouliquen 2008 ; Xiao et al. 2017 ; Xiao et al. 2018 ) or like a load-bearing solid ( Majmudar et al. 2007 ; Bi et al. 2011 ) , depending on the conditions. The solid-like behaviour arises from the jamming transition, which can be induced by isotropic pressure or shear ( Liu & Nagel 1998 ; Bi et al. 2011 ; Behringer & Chakraborty 2018 ) , and has important implications for locomotion. For instance, particles ahead of an intruder in a static bed often remain jammed, effectively enlarging the penetrating object ( Müller et al. 2014 ; Buchholtz & Pöschel 1998 ; Brzinski III et al. 2013 ; Harrington et al. 2020 ; Kang et al. 2018 ) . At large stresses, collective particle rearrangements dissipate elastic energy, giving rise to elasto-plastic behaviours ( Schall & van Hecke 2010 ; Xiao et al. 2020 ; Xiao et al. 2023 ) . Most studies on locomotion, therefore, model granular materials as elasto-plastic or perfectly plastic continua, for which reduced-order approaches such as resistive force theory are applicable ( Askari & Kamrin 2016 ; Agarwal et al. 2021 ; Agarwal et al. 2023 ) . Granular materials containing highly deformable, cohesive, or nearly frictionless particles can display pronounced viscoelasticity, as in food products, powders, cosmetics, and crude oil. Their flow behaviour differs markedly from that of model materials, such as dry glass or plastic beads and poppy seeds, which are typically used in laboratory studies. Granular hydrogels provide a particularly interesting cohesive model system because they combine very low friction coefficients ( \approx 0.01 ) with high elastic deformability (elastic moduli 0.01\dots 1\,\text{kPa} ) ( Ashour et al. 2017 ; Shakya et al. 2024 ) . Due to their high water content, liquid capillary bridges can form between hydrogel particles, inducing cohesive forces. These effects lead to distinct time-dependent behaviours in shear flows ( Wang et al. 2022 ; Dijksman & Mullin 2022 ; Farmani et al. 2025 ) and silo discharge ( Harth et al. 2020 ; Wang et al. 2023 ; Stannarius et al. 2019 ) . Because granular hydrogels combine viscoelasticity, reminiscent of polymeric liquids, with reconfigurable heterogeneous packing, swimming in such media is of particular interest. Beyond fundamental physics, it may also be relevant for applications such as microrobots navigating among blood cells. This study presents experiments with a scallop-inspired swimmer driven by two counter-rotating blades that flap reciprocally. The swimmer moves within a bed of hydrogel spheres and, as will be shown, generates propulsion only within a specific frequency range of flapping. This behaviour contrasts to swimmers in beds of frictional polystyrene spheres ( Xiao et al. 2025 ) , where both the swimming direction and its frequency dependence differ from those observed in rigid frictional particles. II Experimental methods and materials The experimental setup for the scallop-inspired swimmer in granular media is shown in Figure 1 based on our previous study ( Xiao et al. 2025 ) . Figure 1: Experimental setup for swimming in granular media. The apparatus consists of a pair of wings operating in a reservoir filled with granular particles. The inset shows a photograph of the hydrogel particles. The swimmer consists of a pair of counter-rotating, square wings ( 15\,\text{mm}\times\text{15}\,\text{mm} , thickness 1\,\text{mm} ), 3D printed from resin. Each wing is mounted on a vertical carbon-fibre rod (diameter 2\,\text{mm} ), supported by ball bearings, with the rods separated by 10\,\text{mm} . A servo motor drives one rod directly, while the other is coupled through a pair of identical gears, ensuring symmetric counter-rotation of the wings. A Cartesian coordinate system is defined with x the lateral direction, y the swimming direction ( Figure 1 inset), and z the vertical axis pointing upward. The wings flap between \theta_{1}=80^{\circ} (opened) and \theta_{2}=20^{\circ} (closed), respectively. To prepare the hydrogel granulate, we started from dry powder sieved to a narrow size distribution [0.20,0.23]\,\text{mm} . After swelling in distilled water, the particles assumed diameters [1,2]\,\text{mm} . The hydrogel particles were removed from the water bath with a strainer and placed