Production of radioactive 22 Na in core-collapse supernovae: the Ne-E(L) component in presolar grains and its possible consequences on supernova observations

Marco Pignatari, Sachiko Amari, Peter Hoppe, C. Fryer, S. Jones, A. Psaltis, A.M. Laird, F. Herwig, L. Roberti, Thomas Siegert, Maria Lugaro · 2025

Read Production of radioactive 22 Na in core-collapse supernovae: the Ne-E(L) component in presolar grains and its possible consequences on supernova observations by Marco Pignatari, Sachiko Amari, Peter Hoppe, C. Fryer, S. Jones, A. Psaltis, A.M. Laird, F. Herwig, L. Roberti, Thomas Siegert, Maria Lugaro (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-16246.txt.

Introduction

M Pignatari and ten co-authors trace a radioactive clue left inside ancient dust grains. The grains formed in exploded stars before the Sun was born, and some carry a neon mix that points to decayed sodium-22. That sodium forms when hydrogen seeps into a dying star's helium shell and survives until the blast.

The team's supernova models make sodium-22 mostly in that shell, in amounts spanning a wide range. The decay could feed the fading blast's glow from five hundred days on, for years, before titanium-44 takes over. It would also shine a distinct gamma-ray line that telescopes might catch from a near blast. The same decay may add to a galaxy-wide glow from antimatter electrons meeting their twins. The work links grain chemistry in the lab to what sky watchers might see after the next near supernova.

Catalog record

CREATORMarco Pignatari, Sachiko Amari, Peter Hoppe, C. Fryer, S. Jones, A. Psaltis, A.M. Laird, F. Herwig, L. Roberti, Thomas Siegert, Maria Lugaro
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-16246

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Production of radioactive 22 Na in core-collapse supernovae: the Ne-E(L) component in presolar grains and its possible consequences on supernova observations Marco Pignatari, Sachiko Amari, Peter Hoppe, C. Fryer, S. Jones, A. Psaltis, A.M. Laird, F. Herwig, L. Roberti, Thomas Siegert, Maria Lugaro Abstract Presolar graphite grains carry the isotopic signatures of their parent stars. A significant fraction of presolar graphites shows isotopic abundance anomalies relative to solar for elements such as O, Si, Mg and Ca, which are compatible with nucleosynthesis in core-collapse supernovae (CCSNe). Therefore, they must have condensed from CCSN ejecta before the formation of the Sun. Their most puzzling abundance signature is the 22 Ne-enriched component Ne-E(L), interpreted as the effect of the radioactive decay of 22 Na ( T 1 / 2 T_{1/2} = 2.6 years). Previous works have shown that if H is ingested into the He shell and not fully destroyed before the explosion, the CCSN shock in the He shell material produces large 22 Na amounts. Here we focus on such CCSN models, showing a radioactive 26 Al production compatible with grains measurements, and analyze the conditions of 22 Na nucleosynthesis. In these models, 22 Na is mostly made in the He shell, with a total ejected mass varying between 2.6 × \times 10 -3 M ⊙ and 1.9 × \times 10 -6 M ⊙ . We show that such 22 Na may already impact the CCSN light curve 500 days after the explosion, and at later stages it can be the main source powering the CCSN light curve for up to a few years before the 44 Ti decay becomes dominant. Based on the CCSN yields above, the 1274.53 keV γ \gamma -ray flux due to 22 Na decay could be observable for years after the first CCSN light is detected, depending on the distance. This makes CCSNe possible sites to detect a 22 Na γ \gamma -ray signature consistently with the Ne-E(L) component found in presolar graphites. Finally, we discuss the potential contribution from the 22 Na decay to the galactic positron annihilation rate. I Introduction The radioactive isotope 22 Na ( T 1/2 = 2.6 years) can be made by proton-capture reactions and the \beta + decay of 22 Mg in different stellar environments, such as classical novae ( José & Hernanz 1998 , e.g.,) and core-collapse supernovae ( Woosley & Weaver 1995 , CCSNe, e.g.,) . 22 Na decays to the stable isotope 22 Ne relatively shortly after its production, with its half-life orders of magnitude smaller than typical stellar and astronomical timescales. However, the 22 Na alive at the time of the ejection, and now decayed, is measurable today thanks to meteoritic stardust analysis. Black & Pepin 1969 first observed the so-called Ne-E(L) component in carbonaceous meteorites, which is characterized by an extremely high 22 Ne enrichment relative to the solar abundance. This was later identified as being carried by presolar graphite grains ( Amari et al. 1990 ) . Instead, much smaller or negligible signatures were detected for the other two Ne stable isotopes 20 Ne and 21 Ne 1 1 1 The most abundant Ne stable isotope in nature is 20 Ne, with the solar Ne composition being 90.48%, 0.27% and 9.25% for 20 Ne, 21 Ne and 22 Ne, respectively ( https://www.nndc.bnl.gov/nudat3/ ). . Since Clayton 1975 , the commonly-accepted explanation of the 22 Ne-rich Ne-E(L) component is that the observed 22 Ne condensed in grains as 22 Na. Being a noble gas, the original stellar Ne could not condense in dust, and its component directly implanted in the formed grains seems to be extremely small. Therefore, the 22 Ne excess derives from condensation of 22 Na into the grains. As a confirmation of this scenario, Heck et al. 2018 analysis of low-density graphite grains from the Orgueil (CI1) meteorite found that ( 22 Na-) 22 Ne-rich grains are quite common: 6 out of 7 grains on one mount are 22 Ne-rich and 5 of them carry an isotopic signature compatible with a CCSN origin (the remaining 22 Ne-rich grain, 8m-13, was proposed to be formed instead by a low-mass, low-metallicity AGB star). If 22 Ne would be implanted, other Ne isotopes, 20 Ne and 21 Ne, should also have been implanted. In Murchison low-density grains, only 22 Ne was detected instead ( Nichols et al. 1994 ) . Of the 5 22 Ne-rich Orgueil low-density grains from CCSNe mentioned above, only one grain contained measurable 21 Ne ( Heck et al. 2018 ) . For this grain with 21 Ne, it was estimated that the nucleosynthetic 22 Ne (i.e., implanted 22 Ne) would be 0.5% of the total 22 Ne in the grain. Therefore, even in this peculiar case, the majority of the 22 Ne measured is still from 22 Na. Multiple isotopic anomalies measured in single graphites indicate that a significant fraction of them condensed from CCSN ejecta ( Travaglio et al. 1999 , e.g.,) . Among others, the measured range of C isotopic ratio and excesses in 15 N, 26 Al, 28 Si and 44 Ti are all signatures shared with presolar SiC grains of type X, also made in CCSN ejecta ( Zinner 2014 ; Nittler & Ciesla 2016 ; Boujibar et al. 2021 ; Liu et al. 2024b , and references therein) . However, the 22 Ne-rich Ne-E(L) component is still not quantitatively explained by CCSN simulations. Amari 2009 discussed the possibility to reproduce the measured upper limit of 0.01 for 20 Ne/ 22 Ne in single graphites ( Nichols et al. 1992 ) , using predictions from CCSN models by Rauscher et al. 2002 and Chieffi & Limongi 2004 . Even the lowest 20 Ne/ 22 Ne ratio in CCSNe found in the He/C zone was almost an order of magnitude higher than the upper limit of 0.01 (0.096 and 0.088 for Rauscher et al. 2002 and Chieffi & Limongi 2004 , respectively) and no ejecta matched the observed Ne isotope ratios. Therefore, Amari 2009 confirmed that Ne-E(L) was not generated by Ne isotopes directly implanted in dust, supporting the 22 Na cosmogenic origin. The former O-rich C shell ( Meyer et al. 1995 , or the O/Ne zone,) is the most 22 Na-rich part of typical CCSN ejecta, but it only carries a small 22 Na abundance of a few parts per million by mass. Amari 2009 tentatively proposed that the 22 Na to explain the Ne-E(L) component was produced in the O/Ne zone, but a quantitative solution is still problematic. This is because it is extremely unlikely to form large C-rich dust in O-rich environments ( Ebel & Grossman 2001 , e.g.,) and C-rich grains with typical CCSN signatures are not generally consistent with abundances from O-rich material ( Lin et al. 2010 ) . More recently, Sieverding et al. 2018 reconsidered the additional production of 22 Na by neutrino spallation in the more external (and less O-rich) O/C zone, mostly via the 22 Ne( \nu e , e - ) 22 Na reaction, locally increasing the 22 Na for some of the models up to a few 10 -6 in mass fraction. While such quantities would be compatible with the typical 22 Na abundances in

Read the complete text