C/N 0 Analysis-Based GPS Spoofing Detection with Variable Antenna Orientations

Vienna Li 1 , Justin Villa 2 , Dan Diessner 2 , Jayson Clifford 2 , Laxima Niure Kandel 2 · 2025

Read C/N 0 Analysis-Based GPS Spoofing Detection with Variable Antenna Orientations by Vienna Li 1 , Justin Villa 2 , Dan Diessner 2 , Jayson Clifford 2 , Laxima Niure Kandel 2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-16229.txt.

Introduction

Vienna Li and four co-authors propose catching GPS spoofing by tilting the antenna. Spoofed satellite signals can mislead aircraft navigation, and simple detectors matter for general aviation and drones. Their proof of concept watches the carrier-to-noise density ratio, a signal-strength measure, while a receiver antenna is held flat, banked right, and banked left.

With a u-blox receiver and a satellite simulator, genuine signals fluctuate with orientation in ways reflecting true satellite geometry. Spoofed signals behave differently: the flat orientation facing the spoofer reads strongest, while both banked positions weaken, betraying the single ground-based source. The authors suggest brief banking maneuvers could give pilots an early spoofing cue from hardware already on board.

Catalog record

CREATORVienna Li 1 , Justin Villa 2 , Dan Diessner 2 , Jayson Clifford 2 , Laxima Niure Kandel 2
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-16229

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

C/N 0 Analysis-Based GPS Spoofing Detection with Variable Antenna Orientations Vienna Li 1 , Justin Villa 2 , Dan Diessner 2 , Jayson Clifford 2 , Laxima Niure Kandel 2 Abstract GPS spoofing poses a growing threat to aviation by falsifying satellite signals and misleading aircraft navigation systems. This paper demonstrates a proof-of-concept spoofing detection strategy based on analyzing satellite Carrier-to-Noise Density Ratio (C/N 0 ) variation during controlled static antenna orientations. Using a u-blox EVK-M8U receiver and a GPSG-1000 satellite simulator, C/N 0 data is collected under three antenna orientations flat, banked right, and banked left) in both real-sky (non-spoofed) and spoofed environments. Our findings reveal that under non-spoofed signals, C/N 0 values fluctuate naturally with orientation, reflecting true geometric dependencies. However, spoofed signals demonstrate a distinct pattern: the flat orientation, which directly faces the spoofing antenna, consistently yielded the highest C/N 0 values, while both banked orientations showed reduced C/N 0 due to misalignment with the spoofing source. These findings suggest that simple maneuvers such as brief banking to induce C/N 0 variations can provide early cues of GPS spoofing for general aviation and UAV systems. I Introduction Global navigation satellite systems (GNSS), particularly GPS, are critical to aviation for accurate positioning, navigation, and timing. However, GPS signals are inherently weak and follow predictable structures, making them vulnerable to spoofing attacks. GPS signals, which are composed of standardized Pseudo-Random Noise (PRN) codes and fixed ephemeris data, are susceptible to spoofing attacks. Common spoofing techniques include meaconing, which involves rebroadcasting real-sky (non-spoofed) signals with a delay, causing the receiver to compute incorrect positions without detecting a signal anomaly. More advanced spoofing involves using a software-defined radio (SDR) to transmit fabricated signals that are aligned in timing and Doppler shift to match the receiver’s expectation and gradually overpower legitimate signals. In aviation, the implications of such spoofing are severe. The Flight Management System (FMS) typically prioritizes GPS as its primary navigation input, falling back on systems like the Inertial Reference System (IRS), DME/DME, and VOR/DME when GPS is unavailable. However, in recent incidents, spoofed signals have not only misled the FMS but also corrupted the IRS, which depends on GPS for periodic updates. When fed false position data, the IRS accumulates errors and loses integrity, while sensor fusion software misinterprets conflicting inputs from ground-based nav-aids and inertial sensors. This integrated navigation aid approach can result in the failure of navigation systems in some aircraft. Despite the growing threat, existing spoofing detection methods are often costly and rely on specialized hardware such as multi-element antennas or cryptographic signal real-sky authentication, limiting their applicability in general aviation [ 5 ] . The goal of this paper is to demonstrate a low-cost and effective method to detect spoofing by leveraging C/N 0 variations during controlled static antenna orientation. In this study, we examine how C/N 0 patterns change when the antenna is rotated among three fixed orientations. Under real-sky (non-spoofed) conditions, natural satellite diversity produces asymmetric C/N 0 changes with orientation. In contrast, spoofed signals—originating from a single fixed transmitter—result in the flat orientation receiving the highest C/N 0 values, with left and right banked positions showing reduced C/N 0 s. This unnatural C/N 0 symmetry is used as a signature for identifying spoofing events. The main contributions of this paper are summarized below: • This paper presents a lightweight receiver-side GNSS spoofing detection technique that uses only standard C/N 0 measurements and satellite metadata, without requiring specialized antennas or hardware modifications. • By leveraging the predictable geometric behavior of GNSS signals and identifying violations of this behavior, our approach enables spoofing detection that is: a) Robust to signal content manipulation, b) Independent of navigation solution anomalies, and c) Low-cost and easily integrable into commercial GNSS receivers. II Literature Review GPS spoofing detection techniques span signal analysis, sensor fusion, and machine learning. Angle-of-arrival (AoA) methods using off-the-shelf chipsets [ 1 ] , clock bias anomalies [ 2 ] , and RSSI-inferred movement [ 3 ] have been effective in detecting inconsistencies from spoofed sources. Banking-induced signal variation in NGSO systems [ 4 ] further supports spatial C/N 0 asymmetry as a detection metric. Broad surveys [ 5 ] , [ 6 ] emphasize the need for lightweight, hardware-independent solutions—especially for UAVs and civil GNSS receivers. Sensor fusion methods using Kalman filters [ 7 ] , AHRS accelerometers [ 6 ] , and motion units [ 8 ] , [ 9 ] have demonstrated strong spoofing detection performance. More recently, machine learning has enabled models based on Hilbert envelopes [ 10 ] , representation learning [ 11 ] , adversarial training [ 12 ] , and deep generative frameworks [ 13 ] . These methods culminate in capsule-based networks for UAV spoofing detection [ 14 ] . However, many of these advanced detection mechanisms face limitations such as high computational complexity, reliance on extensive training data, and challenges in real-time deployment. This study contributes a simple alternative: identifying spoofing via consistent C/N 0 patterns across antenna orientations, requiring no additional hardware or cryptographic overhead. III Experimental Setup Satellite data is collected using a u-blox EVK-M8U GNSS receiver, configured to log NAV-SAT messages at 5-second intervals over a 60-second duration per antenna orientation. Precisely cut foam blocks are used to simulate different antenna orientations and model the banking motion in an aircraft. A horizontally cut foam block is used to simulate a flat antenna orientation, and another block cut at a 45° angle is used to simulate left- and right-banked positions. This setup allows for consistent and repeatable positioning of the receiver. To perform the spoofing experiments, a GPSG-1000 RF signal generator is used to simulate a spoofed GNSS constellation. The spoofed signal is generated using the daily almanac to maintain consistency with real-world satellite configurations, enabling controlled comparisons (Figure 1). The GPSG-1000 simulator produces a spoofed RF signal that is directly fed into the GNSS receiver’s RF input port through a calibrated coaxial cable. To guarantee complete isolation from real-sky (non-spoofed) satellite signals, all spoofing experiments are performed within a custom-built RF shielded enclosure lined with conductive mesh, effectively forming a Faraday cage. All data collected outdoors occurred under clear sky conditions to ensure optimal satellite visibility and signal quality (Figure 2). The Carrier-to-Noise Density Ratio (C/N 0 ) data for each satellite is extracted from the logs, timestamped, and grouped by PRN (satellite ID). Subsequent statistical analysis and graphical visualizations are performed using Python and Matplotlib. To analyze the spoofing effects, the signal strength profiles of real-sky (non-spoofed) and spoofed signals are compared across the different antenna orientations, and the patterns are used to identify inconsistencies that could be exploited to build the spoofing detector. Fig. 1: Spoofing detection experiment setup featuring the patch antenna, red Faraday cage for signal isolation, and GPS simulator on the right. Fig. 2: Outdoor data collection setup for capturing real-sky (non-spoofed) and spoofed GPS signals under controlled antenna orientations. IV Methodology Building on previous studies done at the Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University Center for Aerospace Resilient Systems, this section describes the proposed methodology. In this study, we assume the noise power spectral density remains approximately constant across measurements since noise floor fluctuations are negligible compared to spoofing-induced C/N

Read the complete text