One century data of 𝝉 \boldsymbol{\tau} CMa: a (2+1)+1 system with a short-period overcontact binary and an eccentric intermediate orbit with probably no apsidal motion
S. Rosu 1, J. Maíz Apellániz 2, L. Sciarini 1, R. C. Gamen 3,4, J. A. Molina-Calzada 2,5, G. Holgado 6, & R. H. Barbá 7 · 2025
Read One century data of 𝝉 \boldsymbol{\tau} CMa: a (2+1)+1 system with a short-period overcontact binary and an eccentric intermediate orbit with probably no apsidal motion by S. Rosu 1, J. Maíz Apellániz 2, L. Sciarini 1, R. C. Gamen 3,4, J. A. Molina-Calzada 2,5, G. Holgado 6, & R. H. Barbá 7 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-16202.txt.
Introduction
Sophie Rosu and six co-authors untangle Tau Canis Majoris, a crowded star system watched for over a century. What looks like one bright point is four stars. Two evolved giant O stars circle each other over about three hundred fifty years. One of them also has a close companion on a one hundred fifty-five day orbit.
The team used sharp images and spectra to find which star hosts a known eclipsing pair. That pair circles in just over a day. The evidence points to a pair of B stars tucked inside the brighter giant's companion. Long records also show slow drift in one orbit. The wide pair's pull explains it best, not a slowly turning oval orbit. The verdict stays tentative until more data lands, but the system's family tree is now far clearer.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | S. Rosu 1, J. Maíz Apellániz 2, L. Sciarini 1, R. C. Gamen 3,4, J. A. Molina-Calzada 2,5, G. Holgado 6, & R. H. Barbá 7 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 8 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-16202
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
One century data of 𝝉 \boldsymbol{\tau} CMa: a (2+1)+1 system with a short-period overcontact binary and an eccentric intermediate orbit with probably no apsidal motion S. Rosu 1, J. Maíz Apellániz 2, L. Sciarini 1, R. C. Gamen 3,4, J. A. Molina-Calzada 2,5, G. Holgado 6, & R. H. Barbá 7 Abstract 𝝉 \boldsymbol{\tau} Canis Majoris (CMa) is an intriguing system that has captured astronomers’ attention for more than a century. The two main components Aa and Ab are two evolved O stars on a 350 years orbit. Aa is itself a SB1 with a 155-days period and a 0.3 eccentricity. Since Hipparcos, we know that a 1.28-days period eclipsing binary (EB) is hidden somewhere in Aa or Ab, but nowhere else. Our recent analysis finally disentangles the system. We calculated the visual Aa–Ab orbit from AstraLux imaging. We detected the SB2 nature of Aa based on STIS spectra, the companion of the O star (Aa1) being a B+B binary (Aa2 = = Aa2a + + Aa2b). Multiple lines of evidence point towards Aa2 being the EB: time delays in the eclipsing orbit detected by TESS, high mass for Aa2 from SB1 from constraints from the orbit of Aa1, and a lack of radial-velocity motion of Ab synchronised with the eclipsing orbit. This remains as a tentative conclusion pending further analysis. We detect secular changes in the SB1 orbit of Aa1 on a baseline longer than a century. At this stage, the effect is most likely caused by the change in velocity of the Aa center of mass due to the Aa–Ab visual orbit. Apsidal motion is most probably not the culprit. \lefttitle Rosu et al. \righttitle \tau CMa: the hierarchical quadruple system \jnlPage 17 \jnlDoiYr 2025 \doival \aopheadtitle Proceedings IAU Symposium keywords Binaries (including multiple): close – Binaries: spectroscopic – Binaries: eclipsing – Binaries: astrometric – Stars: early-type – Stars: individual: \tau CMa – Stars: massive 1 \boldsymbol{\tau} CMa: Stellar multiplicity does not have to be simple \tau CMa, located at the center of NGC 2362, is among the 15 brightest O-type systems in our sky. Its multiplicity is complex, as illustrated in Fig. 1 . We combined astrometry (Sect. 2 ), spectroscopy (Sect. 3 ), photometry (Sect. 4 ), and three-body simulations (Sect. 5 ) to disentangle \tau CMa A’s, though more is to come (Sect. 6 ). A E B C D year = 1951 year = 2004 year = 1835 year = 1835 year = 1834 d = 88-206 mas d= 0 .\!\!{{}^{\prime\prime}} 93 d = 8 .\!\!{{}^{\prime\prime}} 3 d = 14 .\!\!{{}^{\prime\prime}} 5 d= 84 .\!\!{{}^{\prime\prime}} 6 B2: V B2 Vn B5 Vnnn B0.7 V P_{\text{orb}}\sim 350 years Aa SB1 in 1928 SB2 Ab E in 1997 Probably single O9.2 II P_{\text{orb}}=154.86 days Aa1 OC8.5 Ib((f)) Aa2 Eclipsing Overcontact binary P_{\text{orb}}=1.282 days Aa2a B0:nn Aa2b B0:nn Figure 1: Hierarchy of \tau CMa. Results of our analysis are in orange. First image: 3 channel DDS2 RGB image. Second image: AstraLux 3"\times 3" cut-out of the region around \tau CMa A. 2 Astrometry: Long visual outer orbit Aa–Ab We combined data from Maíz Apellániz & Barbá 2020 with new AstraLux and STIS data. AstraLux lucky imaging. Data taken between 1951-1967 are incompatible with each others. We thus computed three possible orbits assuming e=0 (see Table 2 and Fig. 3 ), and showed that the parameters i,\Omega,M_{\text{Aa,Ab}},K_{\text{Aa,Ab}} are well-constrained. HST/STIS spectroscopy. Aa shows a broad component that moves in anti-phase with Aa1 (see Fig. 3 ). Thus, Aa is a SB2, with Aa2 a fast rotator. We determine the mass of Ab \sim\,25\pm 5\,M_{\odot} from the cluster age and its O9.2 II spectral type. Figure 2: Visual orbit of Aa–Ab. Colours indicate three possible orbits based on different sets of data. Figure 3: STIS spectroscopy: Aa (left) and Ab (right). Table 1: Three possible orbital solutions for Aa–Ab. P_{\text{orb}} T_{0} a i \Omega M_{\text{Aa,Ab}} K_{\text{Aa,Ab}} (yr) (yr) (mas) ( ∘ ) ( ∘ ) ( M_{\odot} ) (km s -1 ) 306.8 1970.4 174.1 81.7 298.9 103.5 20.5 354.5 1960.9 184.5 82.1 298.3 92.3 18.8 408.7 1949.3 198.8 82.5 297.5 86.9 17.6 Table 2: Orbital solution for Aa1–Aa2. Parameter Value T_{0} (HJD) 2\,455\,098.3\pm 0.4 \omega_{0} ( ∘ ) 84.3\pm 1.1 e 0.280\pm 0.005 P_{\text{orb}} (d) 154.900\pm 0.004 K_{P} (km s -1 ) 87.0\pm 0.5 a_{P}\sin\,i ( R_{\odot} ) 1.189\pm 0.007 M_{P}\sin^{3}i ( M_{\odot} ) 9.34\pm 0.16 \chi^{2}_{\text{red}} 0.89 3 Spectroscopy: Intermediate orbit Aa1–Aa2 Radial velocity analysis. We combined 125 RVs spanning 117 years that we analysed as in Rosu et al. 2020 ; Rosu et al. 2022a ; Rosu et al. 2022b to derive the orbital solution (Table 2 ). Newly accumulated data were combined with data from Struve & Pogo 1928 ; Struve & Kraft 1954 ; Stickland et al. 1998 , and LiLiMaRlin ( Maíz Apellániz et al. 2019 ) . Combining M_{\text{Aa,Ab}} with constraints on \sin i_{\text{Aa1,Aa2}} and M_{\text{Aa2}}/M_{\text{Aa1}}\sim 1.0-1.5 , we deduced that the orbit is nearly edge on, and that M_{\text{Aa1}}\sim 30\,M_{\odot} , and M_{\text{Aa2}}\sim 38\,M_{\odot} . The only sign of Aa2 in the deconvolved spectra is under broad profiles in some lines, suggesting that Aa2 has early-B spectrum/spectra. Furthermore, the velocity amplitude of Aa2 is much lower than that of Aa1, thus M_{\text{Aa2}}>M_{\text{Aa1}} . It only works if Aa2 is made up of two early-B fast rotators of \sim 19\,M_{\odot} each! Secular changes in the SB2 orbit of Aa1. Over the period 2004-2025, we detected a relative average acceleration of the center of mass of Aa with respect to Ab of 0.22\pm 0.06 km s -1 yr -1 that is consistent with the expectations of the visual Aa–Ab orbit if it is circular (Sect. 2 ), as well as a mass ratio between Ab and Aa of 1.00\pm 0.53 consistent with the expected one (within the large error bar). Most likely, and to the first author dismay, there is no apsidal motion. 4 Photometry: Short-period orbit Aa2a–Aa2b TESS light curves of \tau CMa reveal that the close eclipsing binary is an overcontact binary with a 1.282 days period (Fig. 5 ). Detailed analysis is ongoing to derive stars and orbital parameters. Figure 4: TESS light curves of the eclipsing binary. Figure 5: TRES simulations: \dot{\omega} in Aa1–Aa2 if induced by Aa2a–Aa2b (left) or Ab (right) for different i_{\text{mut}} . 5 Three-body simulations with TRES We performed three-body simulations with TRES ( Toonen et al. 2016 ; Sciarini et al. 2025 ) to assess whether Aa2a–Aa2b (Case 1, Fig. 5 , left panel) and/or Ab (Case 2, Fig. 5 , right panel) could be (partly) responsible for an apsidal motion in Aa1–Aa2. Case 1. We considered the triple system Aa1–(Aa2a–Aa2b). If the mutual inclination i_{\text{mut}} between the two orbits is 0^{\circ} , the apsidal motion rate \dot{\omega} amounts to \sim 3.1^{\circ} yr -1 , while if i_{\text{mut}}=180^{\circ} , \dot{\omega}\sim-2.2^{\circ} yr -1 . These are the two extreme cases; any other i_{\text{mut}} leads to a value for \dot{\omega} intermediate between 3.1 and -2.2^{\circ} yr -1 . Case 2. We considered the triple system (Aa1–Aa2)–Ab. Whatever i_{\text{mut}} , \dot{\omega}\leq 0.002^{\circ} yr -1 . Should an apsidal motion be measured in Aa1–Aa2, would Aa2a–Aa2b be the culprit, not Ab. 6 What we still do not know