Mechanism generating reverse buoyancy flux at the small scales of stably stratified turbulence
Soumak Bhattacharjee 1, Stephen M. de Bruyn Kops 2, Andrew D. Bragg 1 · 2025
Read Mechanism generating reverse buoyancy flux at the small scales of stably stratified turbulence by Soumak Bhattacharjee 1, Stephen M. de Bruyn Kops 2, Andrew D. Bragg 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-16176.txt.
Introduction
Soumak Bhattacharjee and two co-authors explain a curious reversal inside stably stratified turbulence, the kind found in oceans and atmospheres where density layering resists mixing. At small scales the buoyancy flux flips sign, so turbulent potential energy converts back into kinetic energy instead of the usual forward flow, and the effect strengthens as the Prandtl number grows.
Through filtering analysis, the authors tie the flip to ramp-cliff structures in the density field, sharp fronts already known to explain odd dissipation trends. Their math shows this local mechanism dominates at the smallest scales and drives the reversal, while larger scales also carry a non-local contribution. Direct numerical simulations of strongly stratified turbulence confirm the picture.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Soumak Bhattacharjee 1, Stephen M. de Bruyn Kops 2, Andrew D. Bragg 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 47 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-16176
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Mechanism generating reverse buoyancy flux at the small scales of stably stratified turbulence Soumak Bhattacharjee 1, Stephen M. de Bruyn Kops 2, Andrew D. Bragg 1 Abstract Previous studies have shown that at the small-scales of stably stratified turbulence, the scale-dependent buoyancy flux reverses sign, such that there is a conversion of turbulent potential energy (TPE) back into turbulent kinetic energy (TKE) at these scales. Moreover, the magnitude of the reverse flux becomes stronger with increasing Prandtl number P r Pr . Using a filtering analysis we demonstrate analytically how this flux reversal is connected to the mechanism identified in Bragg & de Bruyn Kops (JFM 2024 Vol 991 A10) that is responsible for the surprising observation that the TKE dissipation rate increases while the TPE dissipation rate decreases with increasing P r Pr in stratified turbulence. The mechanism identified by Bragg & de Bruyn Kops, which is connected to the formation of ramp-cliff structures in the density field, is shown to give the scale-local contribution to the buoyancy flux. At the smallest-scales this local contribution dominates and explains the flux reversal, while at larger scales a non-local contribution is important. Direct numerical simulations (DNS) of 3D statistically stationary, stably stratified turbulence in the strongly stratified regime confirm the theoretical analysis, and indicate that while on average the local contribution only dominates the buoyancy flux at the smallest scales, it remains strongly correlated with the buoyancy flux at all scales. The results show that ramp-cliffs are not only connected to the reversal of the local buoyancy flux but also the non-local part. At the small scales (approximately below the Ozmidov scale), ramp structures contribute exclusively to reverse buoyancy flux events, whereas cliff structures contribute to both forward and reverse buoyancy flux events. keywords † † affiliation: 1 Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Duke University, Durham, NC 27708, USA 2 Department of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering, University of Massachusetts Amherst, Amherst, MA 01003, USA MSC Codes (Optional) Please enter your MSC Codes here 1 Introduction The study of turbulence in stably stratified fluids is vital for understanding and modeling atmospheric and oceanic flows. The background mean density gradient can arise due to temperature and/or salinity gradients throughout the fluid, and leads to buoyancy forces that inhibit vertical motion and generate spatially intermittent and layered flow structures that are of tremendous consequence, yet difficult to understand ( Fernando 1991 ; Staquet & Sommeria 1996 ; Riley & Lindborg 2012 ; Caulfield 2025 ) . The relative diffusivity of the scalar on which density depends is quantified by the Prandtl number Pr\equiv\nu/\kappa , where \nu and \kappa are the momentum and the scalar diffusivities, respectively. For thermally stratified air Pr\approx 0.7 , for thermally stratified water Pr\approx 7 , whereas Pr\approx 700 for salt stratified water. Despite this wide range, much of the literature on stratified turbulence has focused on Pr=1 , as also noted by Okino & Hanazaki 2020 , primarily because direct numerical simulations (DNS) with Pr>1 are Pr^{3/2} times more computationally expensive (in terms of spatial resolution requirements) compared to Pr\approx 1 flows. Gerz et al. 1989 observed that stratified, turbulent shear flows feature a counter-gradient (reverse) heat flux when the stratification is strong for Pr=5 but not for Pr=0.7 . Komori & Nagata 1996 compared grid generated turbulence using thermally stratified water at Pr=6 with that using salt-stratified water at Pr=600 and found that higher-Prandtl-number fluids develop stronger, smaller-scale reverse buoyancy fluxes. In their recent study of forced, stratified turbulence using DNS with 0.7\leq Pr\leq 8 and for varying stability strengths, Legaspi & Waite 2020 observed that at high-wavenumbers the buoyancy flux becomes positive, indicating conversion of potential energy to kinetic energy at small-scales, which had also been discussed in Holloway 1988 ; Bouruet-Aubertot et al. 1996 ; Carnevale et al. 2001 . While different arguments have been given for the origin of the reverse buoyancy flux, there is no general consensus on the mechanism that leads to its development or Pr dependence. For example, Holloway 1988 suggests that non-linear interactions transfer potential energy downscale more effectively than it does kinetic energy; this leads to a relative excess of potential energy which is converted to kinetic energy through the buoyancy flux, also discussed in Legaspi & Waite 2020 . The plausibility of this argument is, however, unclear. Indeed, if kinetic energy is transferred downscale less effectively than potentially energy, this would seem to suggest that kinetic energy might pile up at some scales, not potential energy, and some of this could then be transferred to the potential field. But this is the opposite of what was suggested in Holloway 1988 . Riley et al. 2023 recently investigated the decay of a stably-stratified turbulence and observed that higher Pr leads to a smaller mixing coefficient \Gamma\equiv\langle\chi\rangle/\langle\epsilon\rangle , where \langle\chi\rangle and \langle\epsilon\rangle are the average turbulent potential and kinetic energy dissipation rates, respectively ( Okino & Hanazaki 2019 , c.f.) . In order to explain this, Bragg & de Bruyn Kops 2024 analysed the equations governing the velocity and density gradients in stratified turbulence, which describe \langle\chi\rangle and \langle\epsilon\rangle , and they identified a new mechanism that explains why \Gamma decreases with increasing Pr . According to this mechanism, the emergence of ramp-cliff structures in the density field causes the mean density gradient to oppose the production of fluctuating density gradients (reducing \langle\chi\rangle ), and support the growth of velocity gradients (increasing \langle\epsilon\rangle ). They also showed, using asymptotic analysis, that this effect should grow with increasing Pr (although the effect will saturate at sufficiently large Pr ), and this is why \Gamma reduces as Pr increases. Results from DNS (using the same database as Riley et al. 2023 ) confirm these arguments. The objective of this paper is to establish the connection between the gradient field dynamics, along the lines noted by Bragg & de Bruyn Kops 2024 , with the small-scale buoyancy flux reversal that has been observed in previous studies of stratified turbulence. Should such a connection exist, it would provide a mechanistic explanation for the occurrence of a small-scale buoyancy flux reversal, linking it to ramp–cliff structures, a fundamental feature of of scalar turbulence driven by a mean scalar gradient. The rest of the paper is organised as follows: in §2 we present our theoretical analysis that establishes the connection, in §3 we summarise the DNS used, and in §4 we present and discuss the results from our DNS and consider them in view of the theoretical analysis. Finally, in §5 we summarise the findings and discuss future work. 2 Theory We consider a stably stratified flow with fluctuating \phi and mean \Phi_{b}=(\rho_{r}+\gamma z)g/(N\rho_{r}) densities (that have been normalized so that they have the dimensions of a velocity), where \rho_{r} is the reference density, \gamma<0 is the constant, mean density-gradient, g is the magnitude of the gravitational acceleration, and N\equiv\sqrt{-g\gamma/\rho_{r}} is the Brünt-Väisälä frequency. Note that the mean density gradient \gamma\hat{\bm{e}}_{z} points in the direction of gravity \hat{\bm{g}}=-\hat{\bm{e}}_{z} since \gamma<0 . The Navier-Stokes-Boussinesq equations are given by \displaystyle D_{t}\bm{u} \displaystyle=-\left(1/\rho_{r}\right)\nabla p+2\nu\nabla\bm{\cdot}\bm{S}-N\phi\hat{\bm{e}}_{z}+\bm{F}, (1) \displaystyle D_{t}\phi \displaystyle=\kappa\nabla^{2}\phi+Nu_{z}, (2) where D_{t}\equiv\partial_{t}+{\bm{u}}\,\bm{\cdot}\bm{\nabla}\, is the material derivative operator, \bm{u} is the velocity, \nu is the kinematic viscosity, \kappa=\nu/Pr is