Rethinking Arrow–Debreu: A New Framework for Exchange, Time, and Uncertainty
Nizar Riane · 2025
Read Rethinking Arrow–Debreu: A New Framework for Exchange, Time, and Uncertainty by Nizar Riane (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-16003.txt.
Introduction
Nizar Riane, writing alone, rebuilds general equilibrium theory around trades that can in fact happen. The Arrow-Debreu framework proves elegant results about supply and demand in the abstract. Real trades, though, arise from two-sided feasibility between specific partners. Riane's Effective Trade Model starts from that bilateral test. It does not start from aggregate wishes.
Inside the model, he states the main traits of the price-demand correspondence. He proves that Nash equilibria exist, with production, money, and network structure all included. The analysis extends to time, uncertainty, and open economies. Loanable funds and exchange rates appear from inside the model there. Anticipation is captured by a conditional mode. That choice reflects bounded rationality in place of perfect foresight. Riane concludes that transaction limits, subjective pricing, and decentralised bargaining shape equilibrium. Classical welfare claims are thus called into question.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nizar Riane |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 134 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-16003
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Rethinking Arrow–Debreu: A New Framework for Exchange, Time, and Uncertainty Nizar Riane Abstract † Université Mohammed V de Rabat, Maroc 1 1 1 [email protected] Keywords : General equilibrium – Welfare – Network – Convergence – Quantity theory of money – Uncertainty – Open economy. JEL Classification : Acknowledgements : The author would like to thank Michel Lapidus and Michael Maroun for their insightful comments, which greatly contributed to improving this work. 1 Introduction The Arrow–Debreu Model (ADM) [ AD54 ] has long been a cornerstone of modern economic theory, providing a rigorous mathematical framework for analyzing microeconomic decisions. It offers a formal resolution to an old question posed by Léon Walras in [ Wal74 ] , leveraging advancements in the theory of multifunctions and fixed points. While the ADM is meticulously formulated, it has not been universally embraced by economists. Criticism often targets its assumptions, including perfect competition, the existence of forward markets for every commodity and all conceivable contingencies, and the absence of money as a store of value. This has led some scholars, such as Mark Blaug, to express strong reservations. Blaug famously characterized Arrow and Debreu’s seminal paper [ AD54 ] as marking "the beginning of what has since become a cancerous growth in the very center of microeconomics" (see [ Bla98 ] ). He further argued that "by the time we got to Arrow and Debreu, general equilibrium theory had ceased to make any descriptive claim about actual economic systems and had become a purely formal apparatus about a quasi-economy". His criticism extended to Gérard Debreu’s book, The Theory of Value [ Deb59 ] , which he deemed "probably the most arid and pointless book in the entire literature of economics". Beyond Blaug’s critiques of its theoretical abstraction, it is important to recognize that general equilibrium theory has undergone significant refinements since the publication of Arrow and Debreu’s 1954 paper. Debreu’s The Theory of Value [ Deb59 ] further formalized the framework, particularly in economies facing uncertainty. The role of money within the model has been extensively debated, with insightful contributions from Robert Clower [ Clo67 ] , Frank Hahn [ Hah89 ] , and Joseph M. Ostroy and Ross M. Starr [ OS74 ] and others. The question of equilibrium convergence was explored using nontraditional techniques and more realistic approaches (see, for example, [ HN62 ] ). Additionally, time was explicitly incorporated into the system [ Rad72 ] , and market imperfections-such as equilibrium with indivisible goods-were examined to better align the theory with economic realities [ Sve84 ] . In his book The Methodology of Economics: Or, How Economists Explain [ Bla92 ] , Mark Blaug provocatively asks whether general equilibrium theory should be regarded as an empirical theory or merely as a conceptual framework. To explore this question, one can draw an analogy with classical physics: just as Newtonian mechanics assumes the existence of a Galilean reference frame–a perfectly inertial system in which the laws of motion take their simplest form–general equilibrium theory is grounded in idealized assumptions of complete markets and perfect competition. However, in practice, the Earth is a non-inertial frame of reference: its rotation gives rise to apparent forces, such as the Coriolis effect, which must be accounted for to correctly describe physical phenomena. Likewise, real-world markets are subject to imperfections and incompleteness, forming what one might call a "non-Galilean" economic environment. In such contexts, the neat predictions of general equilibrium theory must be modified to incorporate frictions, constraints, and institutional complexities. Thus, while general equilibrium provides a powerful and elegant framework for understanding economic coordination, its empirical relevance depends on our ability to account for the deviations from its foundational assumptions. Contemplating the ADM, one should recognize that it fundamentally relies on the concepts of theoretical demand and supply—idealized representations of preferences and resource endowments. However, these abstractions often diverge from real-world market transactions, where effective demand and supply, shaped by constraints and actual economic behavior, determine outcomes. A critical reassessment of these distinctions is essential for a deeper understanding of exchange systems and money. In the real economy, effective demand and supply, determined by what individuals can actually transact, take precedence. Transactions reflect tangible constraints, such as budgets, production capabilities, and specifically, the other party capacities and needs, making it a bilateral consent. Utility in real-world exchanges depends on effective allocations-what individuals receive or consume through transactions-rather than theoretical allocations. This distinction underscores the importance of addressing the outcomes of exchanges rather than unattainable aspirations. Markets are not arenas for idealized redistribution but mechanisms for facilitating feasible transactions shaped by constraints and negotiation. Real-world exchanges also separate the roles of buying and selling. Transactions are inherently bilateral: they occur between two parties negotiating terms and quantities, rather than through collective redistribution. The ADM’s implicit assumption of a pooled tribal distribution system-akin to the split necklace problem-fails to capture the sequential and decentralized nature of actual market interactions. In practice, individuals bring goods to the market not for pooling but for specific exchanges, governed by mutually acceptable terms. Moreover, the quantity exchanged in a transaction is inherently constrained. It is determined by the minimum that both parties can support, reflecting their respective limitations. This contrasts with theoretical models that emphasize optimal allocations without considering such practical constraints. Equilibrium is not a pure quantity adjustment process but a dynamic interplay between prices and quantities. Individuals do not merely optimize quantities based on given prices; they actively set prices and negotiate quantities in response to their circumstances and opportunities. This dynamic adjustment process better reflects how markets operate, with equilibrium emerging from these decentralized interactions. In the monetary sphere, the bilateral nature of exchange also provides a lens to trace the circulation of money in the economy from a local perspective. Rather than relying on a global analysis dictated by the quantitative theory of money, this approach emphasizes localized flows of currency, capturing the intricacies of individual transactions and their cumulative effects, and also the impact of the topology of the network relationships. Under this vision, monetary policy takes on a more nuanced role, exerting exotic impacts that simultaneously influence quantities, prices, velocity, and redistribution. By addressing these interconnected factors, monetary interventions could reshape not only aggregate outcomes but also the microeconomic structures underpinning economic activity. The Rational Expectations Hypothesis, which assumes that agents form beliefs based on the true statistical expectation of future variables, has long served as a foundational assumption in anticipation modeling. However, this framework abstracts away from key psychological and informational constraints faced by real-world decision-makers. In practice, individuals do not bet on the future by averaging over full probability distributions. Instead, their anticipations are shaped by bounded rationality, limited attention, memory constraints, and heuristic reasoning. And one should distinguish between anticipation an uncertain future and gambling over a set of lotteries. In light of these limitations, we propose a departure from the traditional use of expectations and instead define anticipation as the conditional mode —that is, the most likely realization of a variable given the agent’s information, memory, and subjective beliefs. This approach better reflects the role of instinctive judgment, focal outcomes, and perceived salience, aligning with Keynes’ notion of " animal spirits " [ Key36