Frequency domain laser ultrasound for inertial confinement fusion target wall thickness measurements

Martin Ryzy, Guqi Yan, Clemens Grünsteidl, Georg Watzl, Kevin Sequoia, Pavel Lapa, Haibo Huang · 2025

Read Frequency domain laser ultrasound for inertial confinement fusion target wall thickness measurements by Martin Ryzy, Guqi Yan, Clemens Grünsteidl, Georg Watzl, Kevin Sequoia, Pavel Lapa, Haibo Huang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-15997.txt.

Introduction

Martin Ryzy and six co-authors measure the wall thickness of fusion fuel capsules with laser-driven ultrasound in the frequency domain. In inertial confinement fusion, hollow millimetre spheres hold the fuel, and implosion efficiency demands near-perfect capsule geometry. Their method excites zero-group-velocity guided wave resonances, whose frequencies encode the local wall thickness.

A contactless laser ultrasound microscope reads those resonances without touching the capsule. Along the equator of a high-density carbon capsule about two millimetres wide, the measured thickness agrees excellently with infrared interferometry reference values, the team reports. The shell's many resonances are also studied through plate dispersion calculations and finite element wave simulations. The method scales to many target materials, including metals and metal-doped targets, which broadens quality control for fusion experiments.

Catalog record

CREATORMartin Ryzy, Guqi Yan, Clemens Grünsteidl, Georg Watzl, Kevin Sequoia, Pavel Lapa, Haibo Huang
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-15997

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Frequency domain laser ultrasound for inertial confinement fusion target wall thickness measurements Martin Ryzy, Guqi Yan, Clemens Grünsteidl, Georg Watzl, Kevin Sequoia, Pavel Lapa, Haibo Huang Abstract In inertial confinement fusion experiments hollow, spherical mm-sized capsules are used as a container for nuclear fuel. To achieve maximum implosion efficiency, a perfect capsule geometry is required. This paper presents a wall thickness measurement method based on zero-group velocity guided elastic wave resonances. They are measured with a non-destructive, contactless frequency domain laser ultrasound microscopy system. Wall thickness measurements along the equator of a high-density carbon capsule with a diameter of around 2 mm 2\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\mathrm{m} and a wall thickness of around 80 µ ​ m 80\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolMicro m} excellently agree with infrared interferometry reference measurements. In addition, the multi-resonant nature of a spherical shell is studied by complementing experimental observations with plate dispersion calculations and finite element wave propagation simulations. The presented method is scalable and can be applied to a broad range of target materials, including metals, or metal-doped targets. I Introduction The implementation of nuclear fusion reactions under controlled laboratory conditions is one of the most challenging scientific and technological endeavors of our time. Yet it has the potential to significantly contribute to liberating us from the dependency on fossil fuel-based energy production. One of the most promising approaches in nuclear fusion research is inertial confinement fusion (ICF) hurricane_physics_2023 . Using that technique, a net target energy gain has been recently achieved in ignition experiments conducted at the National Ignition Facility (NIF) at the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory in California, USA abu-shawareb_achievement_2024 . The deuterium-tritium fuel forms a uniform ice-layer on the interior of a mm-sized spherical ablator target capsule made of high-density carbon (HDC) or other materials biener_diamond_2009 ; ross_high-density_2015 ; cardenas_progress_2018 ; braun_tungsten_2023 . To reach the extreme temperature and pressure to start a fusion reaction, the capsule is compressed by repulsive forces created by abrupt target material ablation initiated by X-ray irradiation. As this mechanism sets high demands on target material quality and symmetry braun_tungsten_2023 ; kritcher_design_2024 ; tollefson_how_2024 , precise, non-destructive characterization methods are required, which enable the selection of the most promising capsules for the high-yield ignition fusion experiments. One of the key parameters is the wall thickness uniformity of the capsules. HDC capsules have a thickness variation rejection criterion of 0.35\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolMicro m} out of an average wall thickness of 80\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolMicro m} . For optically transparent or translucent target materials, such as poly( \alpha -methylstyrene), polystyrene and glow discharge polymer plastic capsules, the wall thickness can be determined by optical methods like infrared interferometry for instance caseyEvidenceThreeDimensionalAsymmetries2021 . However, for any opaque target materials like metals, or metal-doped materials, optical methods are limited due to the low optical penetration depth. As an alternative, X-ray imaging can be used for this class of samples. Due to limited sensor array size and the need to fit the entire 2\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\mathrm{m} capsule within the field of view, the ultimate wall thickness variation measurement precision is around \pm$0.15\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolMicro m}$ , or more than one third of the wall thickness nonuniformity allowed for HDC capsules. Considering that future shells can be bigger and made of higher-Z metals, not every capsule is imageable by X-ray transmission imaging. Thus, to pave the way for a broader range of target materials, alternative wall thickness measurement techniques are required. Ultrasonic elastic waves also penetrate optically absorbing or reflective solids, and thus are suitable for gauging their thickness scrubyLaserUltrasonicsTechniques1990 ; cheeke_nondestructive_2012 . A precise method for this is the measurement of resonance frequencies of guided elastic waves in plates or plate-like structures. They sustain an infinite number of laterally propagating wave-modes, which are characterized by strongly non-linear dispersion curves f\!=\!f(k) . Here, f is the acoustic frequency and k the angular (in-plane) wavenumber. In elastically isotropic materials such guided waves are denoted as Lamb-waves viktorov_rayleigh_1967 ; graff1991_p431 . Resonances occur at frequencies associated with local minima of the dispersion curves, i. e., at points where their group velocity v_{g}\!=\!2\pi\,\nicefrac{{\partial{}f}}{{\partial{}k}} vanishes. Depending on the elastic properties, in some dispersion branches, such minima can occur at points with a non-zero wavenumber (finite wavelength), and they are called zero-group velocity (ZGV) resonances tolstoy_wave_1957 ; gibson_lamb_2005 ; pradaLaserbasedUltrasonicGeneration2005 ; prada_local_2008 . Excited with a local acoustic source, their wave-motion remains confined in the excitation region, and they can thus be considered as local prada_local_2008 . As their frequency f_{\mathrm{ZGV}} inversely scales with the local plate thickness h graff1991_p431 ; every_intersections_2016 , relative thickness changes can be locally probed by measuring the ZGV resonance frequency f_{\mathrm{ZGV}} and using the relation pradaLaserbasedUltrasonicGeneration2005 \frac{\Delta{}f_{\mathrm{ZGV}}}{f_{\mathrm{ZGV}}}=-\frac{\Delta{h}}{h}\mathrm{.} (1) Laser ultrasonic (LUS) techniques scrubyLaserUltrasonicsTechniques1990 ; spytek_non-contact_2023 are particularly well suited for that task, as they can provide local acoustic generation and detection pradaLaserbasedUltrasonicGeneration2005 . Based on that technique, thickness measurements of mm- watzl_simultaneous_2025 or sub-mm thick metalic plates Gruensteidl2018_v112_p251905 , imaging of \mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolMicro m} -range thickness variations in a silicon wafer balogun_high-spatial-resolution_2011 , or sub-micron layer on a substrate thickness variation measurements ces_thin_2011 have been demonstrated. Apart from that, a multitude of other laser ultrasonic, ZGV-based material characterization methods have been developed in the last two decades prada_power_2008 ; yan_estimation_2021 ; ryzy_determining_2023 ; thelen_laser-excited_2021 ; Yan2020_v116_p102323 , including elastic constant characterization clorennec_local_2007 ; ces_characterization_2012 ; grunsteidl_inverse_2016 ; watzl_situ_2022 . Guided waves including ZGV-resonances have also been studied in curved plates like hollow cylinders, or spherically curved shells. If the relative thickness, which is the ratio of plate-thickness h and outer radius R , is low, guided waves approximately behave like in straight plates. Neglecting circumferential modes, they can be described by Lamb’s theory. The larger the relative thickness, the stronger the deviation is, and the effect is more pronounced for low frequencies (large wavelengths) lamb_vibrations_1882 ; towfighi_elastic_2003 ; clorennec_local_2007 ; ces_characterization_2012 . For instance, C̀es et al. showed that even for a hollow Zirconium alloy cylinder with a relative thickness of 12\text{\,}\mathrm{\%} , the first ZGV-resonance frequency deviates less than 0.1\text{\,}\mathrm{\%} from its straight-plate counterpart ces_characterization_2012 . Most LUS techniques rely on pulsed laser excitation, with typical pulse durations ranging from the ns- to fs-scale. This results in broadband excitation of acoustic frequencies typically in the MHz to low GHz range, with some specialized system reaching into the low THz range scruby_5_1990 ; grahn_picosecond_1989 ; matsuda_fundamentals_2015 . However, generating acoustic signals with sufficient signal-to-noise ratio often requires sample ablation. But in cases where ablation damage is unacceptable, and only a narrow frequency band is required, e. g. when measuring single resonances, time-domain LUS may not be optimal. Frequency domain laser ultrasound (FreDomLUS) offers an alternative, which circumvents the mentioned issues by using a time-harmonic intensity modulated low power excitation laser in combination with phase sensitive detection. This way, narrow bands around an acoustic resonance can be probed directly in the frequency domain with a fine frequency resolution murray_high-sensitivity_2004 ; ryzy_measurement_2018 ; grunsteidl_evaluation_2020-1 ; grunsteidl_measurement_2020 ; ryzy_determining_2023 . This technique was used to measure plate-resonances at GHz frequencies in fragile, micron-scaled plates for instance grunsteidl_evaluation_2020-1 ; grunsteidl_measurement_2020 ; ryzy_determining_2023 . In this paper, we demonstrate ZGV-resonance based local wall thickness measurements in a spherical, hollow 80\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolMicro m} thin HDC-capsule with a frequency domain laser ultrasound (FreDomLUS) microscopy setup. In addition, broadband FreDomLUS measurements reveal the intriguing resonance landscape of

Read the complete text