The Shape of Math To Come The title is an homage to Ornette Coleman’s 1959 album, “The Shape of Jazz to Come”.
Alex Kontorovich · 2025
Read The Shape of Math To Come The title is an homage to Ornette Coleman’s 1959 album, “The Shape of Jazz to Come”. by Alex Kontorovich (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-15924.txt.
Introduction
Alex Kontorovich, as sole author, surveys how computational tools are changing the daily practice of mathematics and what may follow soon. Formal verification systems and AI assistants now interact with research work in ways that were rare a generation ago. The overview reflects on those interactions for the short to medium term.
Kontorovich considers how proof assistants, computer algebra, and learning-based tools reshape proving, checking, and discovering results. The essay weighs both the reach these tools add and the shifts they force in how mathematicians trust and share arguments. Readers get a practitioner's map of a field in transition, written for researchers weighing how much of their workflow to hand to machines. The piece is a reflection and overview rather than a report of new theorems.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alex Kontorovich |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-15924
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Shape of Math To Come The title is an homage to Ornette Coleman’s 1959 album, “The Shape of Jazz to Come”. Alex Kontorovich Abstract We present an overview of how certain computational tools currently interact with mathematical practice, and reflect on the implications for research mathematics in the short to medium term, as the field navigates the emerging age of AI and formal verification systems. 1 Introduction. This paper will discuss a vision for what research mathematics may look like in the age we now seem to be entering, of AI and formalization. Given the pace of progress, my words will likely be obsolete almost the instant they appear, but I will nevertheless take the risk of setting down how I see the landscape, in September 2025. My own involvement in formalization began about five years ago (see [ 9 ] ), driven by the particular challenges of my research area. Analytic number theory is characterized by particularly long, technical arguments spanning scores of pages. These proofs typically synthesize numerous lemmas, each valid only within constrained ranges of their parameters, which must align perfectly at the end for the main theorem to hold. This intricate dance of parameters and constraints is both what I love about the subject, and what makes it treacherous: a single minus sign error buried somewhere deep in the middle of one of these technical arguments can invalidate the entire main result. When an argument involves something like a complicated algebraic manipulation, I can use a computer algebra system such as Sage or Mathematica to verify it once and for all; then I no longer waste time going over that part of the argument again and again to ensure no errors were made. Shouldn’t there be similar software, but to track the logical dependencies and parameter constraints across my entire paper? Such software does exist, and is called an Interactive Theorem Prover; see § 7 . It, in principle, allows users to “formalize” their papers, entering the proof line by line until the computer certifies that the argument is complete. The reality, however, is sobering. As things currently stand, I cannot even state formally most theorems of interest to me, much less prove them. The existing formal libraries (see § 7.2 ) would need to grow by orders of magnitude before doing research on top of them becomes a reality. This leads to a fundamental conundrum: new mathematics seems to grow at an exponential rate, say, \delta , and formal libraries also grow exponentially, at a rate, say, \varepsilon ; but as far as I can tell, we currently have: \delta>\varepsilon. So if this inequality persists, formalization will never catch up to natural language mathematics research, and the dream of software as useful to reasoning as computer algebra systems are to symbolic manipulation will forever remain a distant mirage. Unless, that is, formalization can be “supercharged” by automation. And so I’ve gone from wanting to do research math, to wanting sufficient formalization to do research math, to wanting sufficient AI to do sufficient formalization to do research math! What follows is my vision for how we might get there, and how things might look if/when we do. The old adage: “It’s hard to make predictions, especially about the future,” variously attributed to Yogi Berra, Niels Bohr, and others, is very apt here. So before we begin, let’s take a step back. 2 In the Year 2000… At the turn of the millennium, some of the world’s most prominent mathematicians gathered in Tel Aviv for a conference to discuss what mathematics might look like in the 21st century. The proceedings were published as a special issue in GAFA called “Visions of Mathematics”, and I strongly recommend reading the whole issue [ 1 ] . A particularly prescient contribution was given by Tim Gowers, titled “Rough Structure and Classification” [ 11 ] . Section 2 of Gowers’s paper is provocatively called: “Will Mathematics Exist in 2099?” In it, he imagines a “dialogue between a mathematician and a computer in two to three decades’ time” – and here we are! His imagined dialogue is eerily similar to the experiences so many of us now have on a regular basis when interacting with “chatbots” such as OpenAI’s GPT, Google’s Gemini, Anthropic’s Claude, xAI’s Grok, and others: Figure 2.1: A snippet from [ 11 ] Gowers notes: “The idea of the dialogue is that the computer is very helpful to the mathematician, while not doing anything particularly clever ” (emphasis added). So, in that vein: let’s establish some common ground and be precise about what I shall mean by a “Large Language Model” (LLM). 3 What is an LLM? We’ve all had the following experience: when reading a book, you reach the bottom of a page mid-sentence, and as your fingers fumble, struggling to turn to the next page, your mind can’t help but race ahead, filling in how the sentence might continue. For example: Figure 3.1: The bottom of a page from “Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows” by J. K. Rowling We read that “[Harry] did not even know what all [the Horcruxes] were. Meanwhile he was at a loss to know how to…” How to what ? Your mind instinctively begins to generate possibilities. How to “destroy” the Horcruxes? Or perhaps how to “find” them? Or, far less plausibly, how to “sandwich”? I imagine standing at a game of Family Feud, hearing Steve Harvey announce: “Survey says!…” But here the “survey” doesn’t poll 100 random people – it samples all available human text! The results might look something like this: given the context, roughly 20% of people, say, would continue the sentence with “destroy,” another 7% would use, “find,” and perhaps a tiny 0.003% would suggest “sandwich.” This , at its core, is a Large Language Model: it is a function whose input is “context” – a possibly very long sequence of “tokens” (words, punctuation marks, etc.) – and whose output is not the next word (as is commonly misconstrued), but rather a probability distribution over all possible next tokens. Figure 3.2: An LLM is a function from context (a sequence of tokens) to a likelihood distribution of potential next tokens For our purposes, we can set aside the unfathomable engineering that makes such a function possible: the architecture (transformers), the representation of data (embeddings in high-dimensional vector spaces), the training process (gradient descent, pre-training, fine-tuning), and so on. We simply take as given that such a function exists. It is on top of such a model that one builds the aforementioned chatbot; the bot must decide how to choose the actual next token from the probability distribution the model outputs. This choice depends on parameters like the “temperature” – perhaps always selecting the most likely token (which tends to produce somewhat stilted prose), or sampling randomly from the distribution, or various options in between. Once a token is chosen, the bot appends it to the context, and feeds the entire sequence back through the model; it then chooses the next token, and the next and the next, until it selects a special token that signals “stop talking.” (We will return later to more complex agentic behavior,