General Relativity Can Prevent a Runaway Greenhouse on Potentially Habitable Planets Orbiting White Dwarfs Rebound ( H. Rein & S. F. Liu 2012 ) , ReboundX ( D. Tamayo et al. 2019 ) , Celmech ( S. Hadden & D. Tamayo 2022 )
Eva Stafne, Juliette Becker · 2025
Read General Relativity Can Prevent a Runaway Greenhouse on Potentially Habitable Planets Orbiting White Dwarfs Rebound ( H. Rein & S. F. Liu 2012 ) , ReboundX ( D. Tamayo et al. 2019 ) , Celmech ( S. Hadden & D. Tamayo 2022 ) by Eva Stafne, Juliette Becker (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-26421.txt.
Introduction
Eva Stafne and Juliette Becker show that Einstein's general relativity can rescue close-in planets around white dwarfs from a runaway greenhouse, in this 2025 arXiv paper. The habitable zone of a dead star sits very near it, so any slight oval in a planet's orbit stirs tidal heat. A companion planet can pump that oval rhythmically, and earlier work warned that even a whisper of it could boil a surface ocean.
The authors add the relativistic twist that near a compact star, orbits precess fast. That steady swing can break the companion's rhythm before the oval grows. For some system layouts, they find, relativity stands guard over habitability. The result matters for picking targets in the hunt for life signs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Eva Stafne, Juliette Becker |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-26421
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
General Relativity Can Prevent a Runaway Greenhouse on Potentially Habitable Planets Orbiting White Dwarfs Rebound ( H. Rein & S. F. Liu 2012 ) , ReboundX ( D. Tamayo et al. 2019 ) , Celmech ( S. Hadden & D. Tamayo 2022 ) Eva Stafne, Juliette Becker Abstract Planets orbiting in the habitable zones of white dwarfs have recently been proposed as promising targets for biosignature searches. However, since the white dwarf habitable zone resides at 0.01 - 0.1 AU, planets residing there are subject to tidal heating if they have any orbital eccentricity. Previous work ( R. Barnes & R. Heller 2013 ) identified nearby planetary companions as potential roadblocks to habitability of planets around white dwarfs, as such companions could induce secular oscillations in eccentricity for the potentially habitable planet, which could in turn heat a surface ocean and induce a runaway greenhouse for even very low values ( e ∼ 10 − 4 e\sim 10^{-4} ) of the eccentricity of the potentially habitable planet. In this work, we examine the potential for general relativistic orbital precession to protect habitable planets orbiting white dwarfs from such a runaway greenhouse, and demonstrate that for some system architectures, general relativity can be protective for planetary habitability. I Introduction White dwarfs, the remnants of low-mass stars, have been identified as potential hosts for habitable planets, both through theoretical studies demonstrating their feasibility ( E. Agol 2011 ; L. Fossati et al. 2012 ; C. T. Whyte et al. 2024 , e.g.,) and observational evidence of intact planets in orbits close to the habitable zone ( A. Vanderburg et al. 2020 ; M. A. Limbach et al. 2025 , e.g.,) . Although no intact habitable planet candidates have yet been confirmed around white dwarfs (likely due to observational challenges such as low transit probabilities and short transit durations), this region of parameter space is especially compelling for biosignature studies ( A. Loeb & D. Maoz 2013 ) . If an Earth-like planet were discovered within the habitable zone of a white dwarf, the combination of deep transit signals and the favorable spectral characteristics of white dwarfs could enable the detection of atmospheric biosignatures using JWST NIRSpec transmission spectroscopy ( L. Kaltenegger et al. 2020 ) or via IR excess with MIRI/MRS ( M. A. Limbach et al. 2022 ) . There are significant challenges to placing planets in the habitable zone of a white dwarf: the habitable zone of a white dwarf resides at 0.01-0.1 AU, well interior to the stellar remnant’s inferred past radius when it was on the red giant branch, and the size of the habitable zone shrinks as a white dwarf cools ( E. Agol 2011 ) . The presence of objects at radii where they should have been engulfed during the red giant phase ( A. Vanderburg et al. 2015 ; Z. Vanderbosch et al. 2020 ; M. A. Limbach et al. 2024 , e.g.,) suggests that planet formation and migration remain active processes after the main sequence. Planets orbiting white dwarfs could either have existed on the main sequence and survived stellar evolution ( J. H. Debes & S. Sigurdsson 2002 ; D. Veras et al. 2013 ; F. C. Adams et al. 2013 ; D. Veras 2016 ) , or have formed after the star started to evolve off of the main sequence ( H. B. Perets 2010 ) , possibly from the debris from tidally disintegrated planets ( D. Veras & K. Heng 2020 ) , a disrupted stellar companion ( L. Chamandy et al. 2025 ) , or common envelope ejecta ( D. R. G. Schleicher & S. Dreizler 2014 ) . The formation of planets after the host star has left the main sequence has been observed to create multi-planet systems around neutron stars ( A. Wolszczan & D. A. Frail 1992 ) and is expected to do so around white dwarfs as well ( E. Bear & N. Soker 2015 ; R. van Lieshout et al. 2018 ) . One challenge to the habitability of planets in the orbiting white dwarfs is the possibility of a runaway greenhouse effect ( J. F. Kasting 1988 ) , a climate state in which a planet, despite having an apparently habitable effective temperature, becomes excessively insulated by greenhouse gases such as water vapor or CO 2 , driving surface temperatures beyond habitable limits. R. Barnes & R. Heller 2013 first identified this issue, showing that in multi-planet systems around white dwarfs, a planet located in the habitable zone can have its orbital eccentricity excited by interactions with neighboring planets. This non-zero orbital eccentricity leads to tidal heating for planets sufficiently close to the central body ( S. J. Peale et al. 1979 ; P. E. Driscoll & R. Barnes 2015 ; A. C. Barr et al. 2018 ; D. Z. Seligman et al. 2024 , e.g.,) , in ways that can significantly affect planetary habitability ( S. I. Rasool & C. De Bergh 1970 ; R. Barnes et al. 2009 ) . Planets in a white dwarf’s habitable zone are particularly susceptible to the effects of tidal heating due to their short-period orbits ( R. Barnes & R. Heller 2013 ; J. Becker et al. 2023 ) . While a lone planet could circularize its orbit and avoid this issue ( D. Veras & J. Fuller 2019 , e.g.,) , in a multi-planet system, eccentricities are continually forced. As a result, the persistent tidal heating can drive the planet’s climate into a runaway greenhouse state, even at relatively low orbital eccentricities ( R. Barnes & R. Heller 2013 , e\leq 10^{-4}-10^{-6} ;) . However, since the habitable zone is so close to the white dwarf, planets residing there will be subject to significant apsidal precession due to general relativity ( A. Einstein 1915 , GR;) . The orbital precession induced by GR could potentially perturb the dynamics of a multi-planet system, altering the amplitude of secular eccentricity cycles, and subsequently the degree of tidal heating that the planet will experience. In this paper, we evaluate how the effects of orbital precession due to GR affects the onset of a runaway greenhouse atmosphere. In Section II , we present a secular framework to model the eccentricity evolution of the inner planet under the influence of both general relativistic precession and planet-induced libration. In Section III , we present the results of our parameter sweep study, conducted using the open source code celmech. In Section IV , we discuss the significance and implications of our results. Finally, in Section V , we conclude with a summary of our results. II Analytic Framework for GR-Stabilized Orbits In this section, we explore how GR might affect planet-planet interactions for planets orbiting white dwarfs. Planet-planet interactions naturally lead to secular oscillations in orbital eccentricity as planets exchange angular momentum ( C. D. Murray & S. F. Dermott 1999 ; K. Batygin & A. Morbidelli 2013 ) , which, in turn, will result in potentially substantial tidal heating ( P. Hut 1981 ) for close-in planets orbiting white dwarfs ( R. Barnes & R. Heller 2013 ; J. Becker et al. 2023 ) . As demonstrated by R. Barnes &