Photonic Simulation of Beyond-Quantum Nonlocal Correlations (e.g. Popescu-Rohrlich Box) with Non-Signaling Quantum Resources
Kunal Shukla, Anirudh Verma, Kanad Sengupta, Sanchari Chakraborti, Manik Banik, C. M. Chandrashekar · 2025
Read Photonic Simulation of Beyond-Quantum Nonlocal Correlations (e.g. Popescu-Rohrlich Box) with Non-Signaling Quantum Resources by Kunal Shukla, Anirudh Verma, Kanad Sengupta, Sanchari Chakraborti, Manik Banik, C. M. Chandrashekar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-26271.txt.
Introduction
Far apart labs can share links that no past tale can match, yet quantum rules cap how strong those links can be. Kunal Shukla and co-authors fake a link past that cap in a 2025 study, with no cheat notes passed in the dark. Their rig runs on a four bit light chip.
The trick uses live links between close systems, plus a dash of true chance that blocks any hid call. That mix can make the famed post quantum box, with or with no quantum link to start. The team maps how the fake scales to groups of three or more. The rig gives labs a safe way to probe what past quantum links could do.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kunal Shukla, Anirudh Verma, Kanad Sengupta, Sanchari Chakraborti, Manik Banik, C. M. Chandrashekar |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 58 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-26271
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Photonic Simulation of Beyond-Quantum Nonlocal Correlations (e.g. Popescu-Rohrlich Box) with Non-Signaling Quantum Resources Kunal Shukla, Anirudh Verma, Kanad Sengupta, Sanchari Chakraborti, Manik Banik, C. M. Chandrashekar Abstract Bell nonlocality exemplifies the most profound departure of quantum theory from classical realism. Yet, the extent of nonlocality in quantum theory is intrinsically bounded, falling short of the correlations permitted by the relativistic causality (the no-signaling) principle. A paradigmatic example is the Popescu–Rohrlich correlation: two distant parties sharing arbitrary entanglement cannot achieve this correlation, though it can be simulated with classical communication between them. Here we show how such post-quantum correlations can instead be simulated using intrinsically non-signaling physical resources, and implement the proposed scheme using a quantum circuit on a four-qubit photonic platform. Unlike the conventional approaches, our method exploits dynamical correlations between distinct physical systems, with intrinsic randomness suppressing any signaling capacity. This enables the realization of post-quantum correlations both with and without entanglement. We also analyze how the simulation scheme extends to beyond quantum nonlocal correlations in multipartite systems. Our experimental demonstration using a photonic system establishes a versatile framework for exploring post-quantum correlations in both foundational settings and as a resource for computation and security applications. Introduction.– Quantum mechanics, the most successful theory to describe the microscopic phenomena, leads to predictions that defy classical worldviews. For instance, Bell’s seminal 1964 theorem Bell 1964 establishes that local measurement outcomes on composite quantum systems cannot always be reproduced by local-causal models Bell 1966 ; Mermin 1993 ; Brunner et al. 2014 . This prediction has been confirmed in a series of landmark experiments through violations of Bell inequalities Freedman and Clauser 1972 ; Aspect et al. 1981 ; Aspect et al. 1982a ; Aspect et al. 1982b ; Zukowski et al. 1993 ; Weihs et al. 1998 ; Tittel et al. 1998 ; Hensen et al 2015 ; Handsteiner et al 2017 ; Collaboration 2018 . One of the most studied inequalities is the Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt (CHSH) inequality Clauser et al. 1969 , where classical correlations are bounded by 2 , but quantum mechanics allows violations up to Tsirelson’s bound of 2\sqrt{2} Cirel’son 1980 . Popescu and Rohrlich, however, showed that nonlocality can be of stronger form: their hypothetical PR-box achieves the algebraic maximum 4 of the CHSH expression, while respecting the no-signaling (NS) principle thereby prohibiting faster than light communication Popescu and Rohrlich 1994 (see also Popescu 2014 ). Despite satisfying NS, the PR correlation carries striking consequences. For instance, they trivialize communication complexity, allowing any function to be computed with only a constant amount of communication between two parties van Dam 2012 . This apparent absurdity has led to the conjecture that nontrivial communication complexity is a fundamental axiom of quantum mechanics Brassard et al. 2006 ; Buhrman et al. 2010 . Subsequently, several other principles have been identified that constrain the set of physically realizable correlations Pawłowski et al. 2009 ; Navascués and Wunderlich 2009 ; Fritz et al. 2013 ; Cabello 2013 ; Naik et al. 2022 ; Patra et al. 2023 . In quantum theory, nonlocality typically arises from entangled states shared between spatially separated parties. In such a spacelike scenario, measurements on the local parts of the entangled states produce nonlocal correlations bounded by Tsirelson’s limit. In contrast, timelike scenarios—where classical communication is permitted between the parties—allow simulation of arbitrary nonlocal correlations, including the PR correlations Hall 2011 ; Toner and Bacon 2003 ; Brassard et al. 2016 . These two regimes can be unified in the quantum-circuit picture using entangling gates that induce global interaction among distinct quantum systems. However, such a gate can serve either as a non-signaling resource or as a signaling resource depending on how its input preparations are initialized Bennett et al. 2003 ; Harrow 2004 ; Harrow and Shor 2010 ; Hayden and Penington 2020 . Here, we show that restricted access to multi-qubit gates can be used to simulate PR correlation, even when they act as non-signaling resources. Crucially, these beyond-quantum correlations are not generated through the conventional mechanism of creating entanglement between distinct quantum systems. Instead, the gate dynamically controls correlations across different physical systems, while intrinsic randomness within the gate ensures that the overall process remains non-signaling. We implement this mechanism on a four-qubit photonic platform with deterministic quantum gate operations using polarization-path degrees of freedom of photons Kolangatt et al. 2024 ; Sengupta et al. 2025 , validating the recently proposed one-time-pad (OTP) model for PR correlations Sidhardh and Banik 2024 , which can be viewed as a De-Broglie-Bohm type model for PR correlation Bub 2013 . In our experiment, the suitable combination of Hadamard, CNOT, and Toffoli gates suppresses the signaling capacity of the resource. We realize a photonic circuit that generates a two-qubit maximally entangled state with fidelity 93.9\% , simulates CHSH violations exceeding 3.9 —well beyond Tsirelson’s bound—and with visibilities above 99\% across multiple bases. In addition, numerical simulations confirm that PR correlations can be obtained without entanglement, but through the preparation of classically correlated states following the same underlying principle of harnessing dynamic correlations and randomness. We further extend our framework to multipartite settings, demonstrating the potential of quantum circuits as versatile platforms for simulating beyond-quantum resources. Theory.– A typical bipartite Bell scenario involves two spatially separated parties, Alice and Bob, who after receiving classical inputs x\in\mathcal{X} and y\in\mathcal{Y} , respectively, from a referee returns classical outputs a\in\mathcal{A} and b\in\mathcal{B} . Throughout, we assume the input and output sets to be of finite cardinalities. Repeated runs of the experiment generate an input–output correlation (also called a behavior) P\equiv\{p(a,b|x,y)\penalty\ |\penalty\ \sum_{a,b}p(a,b|x,y)=1\penalty\ \forall\penalty\ x,y\} . A correlation is called non-signaling (NS) if neither party can signal to the other, i.e., \displaystyle P(a|x,y) \displaystyle=P(a|x,y^{\prime}),\penalty\ \penalty\ \forall\penalty\ \penalty\ a,x,y,y^{\prime}, (1a) \displaystyle P(b|x,y) \displaystyle=P(b|x^{\prime},y),\penalty\ \penalty\ \forall\penalty\ \penalty\ b,x,x^{\prime},y. (1b) A correlation is called quantum if it can be obtained through local measurements on a bipartite quantum system, namely if it admits a realization of the form p(a,b|x,y)=\mathrm{Tr}[(\pi^{a}_{x}\otimes\pi^{b}_{y})\rho_{AB}], (2) for some \rho_{AB}\in\mathcal{D}(\mathcal{H}_{A}\otimes\mathcal{H}_{B}) , where \mathcal{H}_{A} and \mathcal{H}_{B} denote the Hilbert spaces corresponding to Alice and Bob, respectively. Moreover, the operators {\pi^{a}_{x}}\subseteq\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{H}_{A}) and {\pi^{b}_{y}}\subseteq\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{H}_{B}) respectively satisfy \sum_{a}\pi^{a}_{x}=\mathbf{I}_{A} and \sum_{b}\pi^{b}_{y}=\mathbf{I}_{B} , for all x,y . Here, \mathcal{D}(\cdot) and \mathcal{P}(\cdot) denote the sets of density operators on \mathcal{H}_{A}\otimes\mathcal{H}_{B} and positive operators on \mathcal{H}_{A} or \mathcal{H}_{B} , respectively, while \mathbf{I} denotes the identity operator. For a finer classification of quantum correlations, we refer to the recent breakthrough result of Slofstra Slofstra 2019 . A correlation is called classical (more specifically Bell local) if it admits a local-causal decomposition, i.e., \displaystyle p(a,b|x,y)=\int_{\Lambda}d\lambda\,\mu(\lambda)\,p(a|x,\lambda)p(b|y,\lambda), (3) where \mu(\lambda) is a probability distribution over hidden variables \lambda\in\Lambda Brunner et al. 2014 . The sets \mathcal{N},\penalty\ \mathcal{Q},\penalty\ \mathcal{L} of NS, quantum, and local correlations, respectively, satisfy the strict set inclusions \mathcal{L}\subsetneq\mathcal{Q}\subsetneq\mathcal{N} . In the simplest binary-input–binary-output scenario the CHSH inequalities turns out to be the necessary and sufficient criteria to establish nonlocality of a correlation Fine 1982 . Denoting \mathcal{A}=\mathcal{B}=\{+1,-1\} , the CHSH inequalities, up to local relabelings, take the form \mathcal{S}:=|\braket{a_{0}b_{0}}+\braket{a_{0}b_{1}}+\braket{a_{1}b_{0}}-\braket{a_{1}b_{1}}|\leq 2, (4) where \langle a_{x}b_{y}\rangle:=\sum_{a,b=\pm 1}ab\;p(a,b|x,y) . The quantum set \mathcal{Q} is highly nontrivial and lies strictly between \mathcal{L} and \mathcal{N} Barizien and Bancal 2025 . Local correlations achieve a maximum CHSH score of 2 ,