Temperature derivative divergence of the electric conductivity and thermal photon emission rate at the critical end point from holography

Yi-Ping Si, Danning Li, Mei Huang · 2025

Read Temperature derivative divergence of the electric conductivity and thermal photon emission rate at the critical end point from holography by Yi-Ping Si, Danning Li, Mei Huang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-25636.txt.

Introduction

Quark-gluon plasma is the hot soup of particles that filled the early universe, and theory predicts a critical end point in its phase map. Yi-Ping Si and co-authors use a holographic model of the plasma in this 2025 paper, tuned with machine learning, to study two signals near that point.

Both the plasma's electric conductivity and its rate of thermal light emission rise most steeply near the change temperature, matching earlier work and, at one setting, lattice calculations. Sharper still, the temperature slopes of both quantities blow up at the critical end point itself. Such spikes could serve as fingerprints when experiments hunt for the point.

Catalog record

CREATORYi-Ping Si, Danning Li, Mei Huang
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-25636

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Temperature derivative divergence of the electric conductivity and thermal photon emission rate at the critical end point from holography Yi-Ping Si, Danning Li, Mei Huang Abstract The thermal photon emission rate d ​ Γ d ​ k \frac{d\Gamma}{dk} and DC eletric conductivity σ Q \sigma_{Q} of the strongly coupled quark-gluon plasma (sQGP) are investigated around the critical end point in a N f = 2 + 1 N_{f}=2+1 holographic QCD model with parameters obtained from machine-learning. It is found that both thermal photon emission rate and eletric conductivity grow most obviously around T c T_{c} , which agrees with the previous studies, and the result of eletric conductivity at zero chemical potential resembles the lattice results. Moreover, it is found that both the temperature derivative of the eletric conductivity and thermal photon emission rate diverge at the critical end point. I Introduction The existence and location of the critical endpoint (CEP) in the QCD phase diagram has been widely investigated theoretically Pisarski:1983ms ; Asakawa:1989bq ; Stephanov:1998dy ; Hatta:2002sj ; Stephanov:1999zu ; Hatta:2003wn ; Schwarz:1999dj ; Zhuang:2000ub . The search for CEP serves as a prominent goal of heavy ion collision (HIC) experiments in facilities like RHIC at BNL, FAIR at GSI, NICA at DUBNA, and HIAF in Huizhou. The non-monotonic behavior of baryon number fluctuations has been considered as a signature of the CEP STAR:2010-CEP ; Exp-CEPsearch-2017 ; STAR-2020-Non-monotonic ; STAR2022-cumulants . The latest STAR results Ashish2024 ; STAR:2025zdq didn’t show clear evidence of the existence of CEP for collision energy \sqrt{s}> 7.7 GeV. From the analysis in Ref. Shen:2024ptz , the baryon number fluctuation signature might be distorted by the hadronization process. Therefore, a different signature of the CEP which is insensitive to the hadronization would be needed. For the quark-gluon plasma (QGP) produced in the HICs, one important class of observables is the electromagnetic probes, which mainly include photons and dileptons. The thermal-photon and dilepton produced in heavy-ion collisions are important observables in studying the properties of QGP David2019-Photon-Dilepton-rev ; Geurts2022-Photon-Dilepton-rev02 . Due to their colorless nature and relatively long mean free path, once generated, they pass through the fireball with barely further interaction. Thus the information about the early stage of the collision and its subsequent evolution is well preserved by those electromagnetic probes. Photons produced in HIC can be divided into different types, including prompt (produced in early hard patron scattering), thermal (produced in QGP and latter hadron phases) and decay (from the deacy of final-state hadrons) photons. The prompt and thermal photons are of particular interest experimentally, and are referred to as "direct" photons. However, photons produced in various stages are detected collectively. Therefore, it’s necessary to differentiate photon production from different sources. Thermal photons mainly contribute to the total production in the low transverse momentum region. The observed excess of the direct photon in Au+Au (PHENIX) PHENIX:2008uif and Pb+Pb (ALICE) Wilde:2012wc is attributed to thermal photons. Much theoretical work has been devoted to calculating the production of direct photons, including perturbative QCD (pQCD) calculations for leading order (LO) pQCD-LO2001 and next-to-leading order (NLO) pQCD-NLO2013 , lattice simulations latticePhoton-2022 ; HotQCDCollaboration:2024-latticePhoton , and results from effective models such as holographic models Caron-Huot ; Stefano2015 ; YangDLConductPLB . However, a clear understanding of the possible signature of the CEP from photon emissions has not yet been concluded. Apart from photon emission, the transport properties are necessary for the understanding of QGP and the behavior near critical endpoint as well. Many effective models are constructed to study the real time evolution of the plasma (e.g. Boltzmann transport, hydrodynamics and hadronic cascade Molnar:2001-Boltzmann-Transport ; Gale:2013-Hydro-Simulation-Review ; Bleicher:1999-parton-cascade-01 ; Bass:1998-parton-cascade-02 ); the transport coefficients serve as parameters in those models. For example, it has been shown that strong electromagnetic fields are generated in the HIC process, and the electric conductivity, the transport coefficient which descibes how the medium reacts to an external electric field, is crucial for such simulations. Except for phenomenological applications, the transport coefficients themselves characterize the nonequilibrium dynamics of strongly coupled plasmas and the behaviors of which can also indicate phase transition. It has been shown that an enhancement of bulk viscosity occurs around T_{c} Kharzeev:2007-bulk-viscosity-at-TC-0mu-lat ; Karsch:2007-bulk-viscosity-at-TC-0mu-lat ; Karsch:2007-bulk-viscosity-at-TC-03 and the claim that shear viscosity can indicate phase transition has been made as well Lacey:2006bc-shearAsCEPsign . Similarly, the electric conductivity of QGP which is directly related to the photon and soft dilepton production, also has the possibility to serve as a signal of phase transition. In fact, it has already been shown by both lattice results GertAartsAmato2013PRL ; GertAartsAmato2014JHEP ; 2019ELEconductivityLattice (for a review see GertAarts2020 ) and various phenomenological studies Stefano2013 ; Stefano2015 ; I.I.YangKiritisis:2016ugz ; ArefevaRussia2021 that a "rapid growth" or "jump" occurs at the transition temperature T_{c} . For the crossover region, it’s pseudo-transition temperatures, but for simplicity we’ll still call them T_{c} here and below. Moreover, a series of recent work based on NJL model Nishimura:2023-diverge-conductivity ; Nishimura:2024-diverge-conductivity predicts that the electric conductivity will diverge at the CEP. Besides, in spite of the abundant studies, there’s no consensus on the magnitude of the electric conductivity yet Huang:2022qdn-uncertainElectricConduct . This suggests that the research on the electric conductivity is far from settled. Although much work has been done to investigate the photon production through pQCD and lattice calculations, as for the search for CEP, these results are very limited in the region of interest. Specifically speaking, QGP around CEP is strongly coupled and thus the perturbative methods are not applicable, while lattice calculation is limited within zero or small baryonic chemical potential regions due to the "fermion sign" problem. On the other hand, the gauge/gravity duality (GGD) Maldacena1997-GGD-01 ; Witten1998-GGD-02 ; Gubser1998-GGD-03 has emerged as a powerful tool to investigate the strongly coupled QGP. The duality claims that a strongly coupled gauge theory in four-dimensional spacetime is dynamically equivalent to a gravitational theory in AdS_{5} spacetime. Inspired by this, many holographic models have been proposed based on either string theory constructions (top-down) Karch:2002-Adding-Flavors-To-AdSCFT-D3D7 ; Sakai-Sugimoto:2004 or properties of QCD (bottom-up) HardWall2005 ; SoftWall-01 ; EMD-01 ; Gursoy:2007-ImprovedQCD-Part1 ; Gursoy:2007-ImprovedQCD-Part2 ; Iatrakis:2010-VQCD ; Danning2013-1 ; Danning2013-2 . The calculation of photon emission rate using gauge/gravity duality was first investigated in Caron-Huot , where the photon emission rate of \mathscr{N}=4 supersymmetric Yang-Mills (SYM) plasma under both weakly and strongly coupled circumstances were given. The calculations for the non-conformal plasma soon followed up I.I.YangKiritisis:2016ugz ; YangDLConductPLB ; Stefano2015 . The strong electromagnetic field can be created in the HICs; consequently, extensions of photon production in anisotropic plasmas ArefevaRussia2021 have also been explored, in which an external magnetic field induced the anisotropy. Despite all these efforts, the photon emission near the CEP remains largely unexplored in the context of holography. Among all those bottom-up models, the Einstein-Maxwell-dilaton (EMD) model EMD-01 ; Yang:2014bqa was constructed to mimick the equations of state that captures the crossover transition. Recently, the machine learning method ChenXun has been employed to determine the key parameters of the EMD model. Using this machine-learning model, we will calculate the thermal photon emission rate and electric conductivity of a strongly coupled QGP in thermal equilibrium. Actually these two quantities can be calculated using the same retarded correlator Caron-Huot . To achieve that, we need to

Read the complete text