Hydrodynamic interactions destroy motility-induced phase separation in active suspensions

Tingtao Zhou, John F. Brady · 2025

Read Hydrodynamic interactions destroy motility-induced phase separation in active suspensions by Tingtao Zhou, John F. Brady (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-25616.txt.

Introduction

Fluid-mediated interactions destroy a famous clustering effect in active matter, Tingtao Zhou and John Brady show in a 2025 paper. Motility-induced phase separation arises from the non-equilibrium nature of active systems: swimmers slow down where they crowd, and dense and dilute regions split apart. Whether the effect survives in wet systems, where hydrodynamic interactions act through the fluid, has been debated.

Theory and large-scale simulations of the squirmer model give an answer. Collision-induced pusher force dipoles, present even for the simplest neutral swimmers, destroy the separation once hydrodynamics is included. Rotational interactions shorten persistence length, and translational ones drive confinement-scale flows. Boundary dipoles can mimic aggregation instead. The authors also show how to recover the separation in fluidic environments.

Catalog record

CREATORTingtao Zhou, John F. Brady
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-25616

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Hydrodynamic interactions destroy motility-induced phase separation in active suspensions Tingtao Zhou, John F. Brady Abstract Motility-Induced Phase Separation (MIPS) is a distinctive phenomenon in active matter that arises from its inherent non-equilibrium nature. Despite recent progress in understanding MIPS in dry active systems, it has been debated whether MIPS can be observed in wet systems in which fluid-mediated hydrodynamic interactions (HI) are present. We use theory and large-scale Active Fast Stokesian Dynamics simulations of the so-called squirmer model to show that collision-induced pusher force dipoles, which are present even for the simplest neutral squirmers (stealth swimmers), destroy MIPS when HI are included. Both rotational and translational HI independently suppress phase separation: rotation by shortening a swimmer’s persistence length (and thus reducing the swim pressure), translation by a confinement-scale advective fluid flow. We further clarify that collisional dipoles between swimmers and boundaries can generate attractive flows that promote particle aggregation observed in some previous simulations and experiments. Finally, we show how to recover MIPS in fluidic environments by tuning the magnitude of the HI through brush-like surface coatings on the active particles. Active matter exhibits rich and fascinating collective behaviors, such as flocking, bacteria turbulence Dunkel et al. 2013 ; Dombrowski et al. 2004 and motility-induced phase separation (MIPS) Cates and Tailleur 2015 , opening a vast avenue for developing non-equilibrium statistical mechanics. Among these, MIPS – the coexistence of dense and dilute phases of active particles at sufficiently high denisty and persistence — is theoretically predicted for simple self-propelling particles with merely excluded volume interactions, such as Active Brownian Particles (ABPs). Phenomenologically, it has been observed that particles in higher-density regions slow down and self-trap to form a dense phase in coesistence with a dilute phase. This insight has been developed into field-theory descriptions for MIPS Tailleur and Cates 2008 ; Fily and Marchetti 2012 ; Speck et al. 2014 . An alternate mechanical perspective shows that MIPS is a non-equilibrium phase separation governed by a mechanical force balance between the two phases Takatori et al. 2014 ; Omar et al. 2023 . Despite theoretical progress in understanding dry MIPS, such idealized conditions are often complicated by other physics in reality: for microbes or active colloidal particles/droplets, the surrounding fluid mediates long-ranged, many-body hydrodynamic interactions (HI) that may alter the collective behavior. The simplest model to investigate the role of HI on active matter is the so-called squirmer model Lighthill 1952 ; Blake 1971 . A squirmer is a force- and torque-free sphere with a prescribed surface slip velocity due to active swimming at low Reynolds number. In addition to translating without disturbing the fluid, an individual squirmer can also generate a force dipole, or stresslet, flow field that decays as 1/r^{2} ; a positive dipole is a ‘pusher’ or extensile swimmer, while a negative dipole is a ‘puller’ or contractile swimmer. A zero force dipole is a ‘neutral’ swimmer, with the velocity disturbance decaying as 1/r^{3} , the form of the velocity disturbance caused by phoretic motion. In dilute suspensions, HI can be approximated by far-field multipole expansions, whereas in densely packed suspensions, near-field lubrication interactions dominate. The full range of HI is required to describe suspensions at intermediate concentrations. On one hand, far-field HI predict hydrodynamic instabilities and strong mixing in a dilute suspension of pushers, while a suspension of pullers remains stable Saintillan and Shelley 2008 . On the other hand, numerical studies with full HI highlight the importance of lubrication interactions in pattern formation, such as aggregation and band formation for a monolayer of ‘pullers’ Ishikawa and Pedley 2008 ; Ishikawa et al. 2008 and bound states for a neutral squirmer Volvox Drescher et al. 2009 ; Ishikawa et al. 2020 . Regarding MIPS, a ‘squirming disks’ model Matas-Navarro et al. 2014 has suggested suppression of MIPS due to the rotational diffusion of active disks enhanced by near-field HI. However, another simulation Zöttl and Stark 2014 of squirmers confined in a quasi-2D channel, but rotating and translating in 3D, has shown clustering. Given the small number of particles ( O(200) ) used in previous numerical simulations, an investigation of larger systems is needed to resolve the seemingly inconsistent observations and to reveal how HI affects MIPS. In this Letter, we combine theory and large-scale simulations to show that full HI destroy MIPS due to a many-body effect—collision-induced dipoles. Using Active Brownian Particles (ABPs) as a basic model for dry active matter, we focus on the simplest swimmer, a so-called stealth swimmer, as schematically shown in Fig. 1 (A), to demonstrate the leading-order effects of HI. A stealth swimmer generates no velocity disturbance as it moves through the fluid, but when two particles ‘collide’ the non-hydrodynamic interparticle forces that prevent the swimmers from overlapping now create a pusher hydrodynamic velocity disturbance (Fig. 1 (C)). This collision-induced dipolar flow dominates the long-range HI and alone can destroy MIPS. To illuminate the role of boundary confinement, we focus on shear-stress-free and no-flux boundary conditions at z=\pm h/2 that represent liquid films, as shown in Fig. 1 (B). As noted in previous studies on HI-induced like-charge attraction Squires and Brenner 2000 and aggregation of bottom heavy swimmers Drescher et al. 2009 , the collision between particles and a wall generates strong flows and fluid-mediated interactions between particles. To separate this mechanism, we constrain the motion and orientation of the swimmers within the xy plane. Our simulation method extends a fast version of the Active Stokesian Dynamics method Brady and Bossis 1988 ; Fiore and Swan 2019 ; Elfring and Brady 2022 to enable large-scale systems of O(10^{4}) particles. Figure 1: (A) Sketch of a neutral stealth swimmer. The surface slip velocity U_{S} is a constant, hence no disturbance flow when swimming alone. (B) A swimmer confined in a liquid film of thickness h . At the liquid-air interfaces, zero shear-stress boundary conditions apply. The swimmer’s motions are constrained in 2D. (C) Sketch of a collision-induced dipole. During a head-on collision, the hard-sphere repulsion between particles 1 and 2 induces a ‘pusher’-like dipolar flow field at leading order. Numerical method— To simulate a suspension of swimmers with HI, we integrate the dynamics of N swimmers of radii a according to the overdamped force/torque balance Elfring and Brady 2022 0=-\bm{\mathcal{R}}_{\cal FU}\cdot(\bm{\mathcal{U}}+\bm{\mathcal{U}}^{s})+\bm{\mathcal{F}}^{p}-\bm{\mathcal{R}}_{\cal FE}:\bm{\mathcal{E}}^{s}\,. (1) In Eq. ( 1 ), \bm{\mathcal{U}}=(\bm{U}_{1},\bm{U}_{2}\ldots\bm{U}_{N};\bm{\varOmega}_{1},\bm{\varOmega}_{2},\ldots\bm{\varOmega}_{N}) is a vector of the translational and rotational velocities of all N particles, and \bm{\mathcal{U}}^{s} is the corresponding swim velocities. The grand (many-body) resistance tensors \bm{\mathcal{R}}_{\cal FU} and \bm{\mathcal{R}}_{\cal FE} couple the generalized force/torque to the velocity and rate of strain \bm{\mathcal{E}}^{s} due to swimming, respectively, and are functions of the configuration of all N particles. The nonhydrodynamic force \bm{\mathcal{F}}^{p} is a short-range hard-sphere force that prevents particles from overlapping. The swim velocity of particle \alpha relates to the squirmer coefficient B_{1} by \bm{U}_{\alpha}^{s}=-U_{0}\bm{q}_{\alpha}=-\frac{2}{3}B_{1}\bm{q}_{\alpha} , with constant amplitude U_{0} and direction \bm{q}_{\alpha} . We ignore Brownian motion of the swimmers and assume that their reorientation comes from the inherent noise of the surface slip velocity ( \bm{\varOmega}^{s}_{\alpha} ) that does not generate a disturbance flow, which is possible for spherical swimmers, and model this noise as a random process with rotational diffusivity D_{R} . The symmetric first moment of activity, \bm{\mathcal{E}}^{s} , relates

Read the complete text