Reply to the Comment on “Magnetic moments in the Poynting theorem, Maxwell equations, Dirac equation, and QED”

Peter J. Mohr · 2025

Read Reply to the Comment on “Magnetic moments in the Poynting theorem, Maxwell equations, Dirac equation, and QED” by Peter J. Mohr (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-25403.txt.

Introduction

Peter Mohr published this short reply in 2025 as part of an exchange in theoretical physics. Another author's comment raised concerns about Mohr's earlier paper on magnetic moments, which dealt with the Poynting theorem, the Maxwell equations, the Dirac equation, and quantum electrodynamics. The reply states only that it addresses the concerns raised in that comment. Readers following the dispute should read it alongside the original paper and the comment it answers.

Catalog record

CREATORPeter J. Mohr
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE2 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-25403

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Reply to the Comment on “Magnetic moments in the Poynting theorem, Maxwell equations, Dirac equation, and QED”
Peter J. Mohr

Abstract
This reply addresses concerns expressed in a comment (arXiv:2508.16689v1) on the paper given in the title (arXiv:2501.02022v2), hereafter referred to as the paper.



The comment asks why a particular angular average was given for the
magnetic dipole field. The reason is that it is the appropriate one for
the longitudinal magnetic dipole field. There are two expressions for
the field. One is transverse
\bm{B}_{\bm{m}}^{\rm T}(\bm{x})
and another
is longitudinal
\bm{B}_{\bm{m}}^{\rm L}(\bm{x})
, where

\displaystyle\bm{\nabla}\cdot\bm{B}_{\bm{m}}^{\rm T}(\bm{x})=0,\qquad\bm{\nabla}\times\bm{B}_{\bm{m}}^{\rm L}(\bm{x})=0.

(1)

For
|\bm{x}|>0
they are equal:

\displaystyle\bm{B}_{\bm{m}}^{\rm T}(\bm{x})=\bm{B}_{\bm{m}}^{\rm L}(\bm{x})=\frac{\mu_{0}}{4\pi}\,\frac{3\bm{\hat{x}}(\bm{\hat{x}}\cdot\bm{m})-\bm{m}}{|\bm{x}|^{3}}\qquad\mbox{for}\quad|\bm{x}|>0.

(2)

However, they have different behavior at
\bm{x}=0
. This is
shown by taking the angular average of each expression. For
|\bm{x}|>0
the angular average vanishes for both. On the other hand, the
angular average reveals the behavior at
\bm{x}=0

\displaystyle\frac{1}{4\pi}\int{\rm d}{\it\Omega}\,\bm{B}_{\bm{m}}^{\rm T}(\bm{x})=\frac{2\mu_{0}}{3}\,\bm{m}\,\delta(\bm{x}),\qquad\frac{1}{4\pi}\int{\rm d}{\it\Omega}\,\bm{B}_{\bm{m}}^{\rm L}(\bm{x})=-\frac{\mu_{0}}{3}\,\bm{m}\,\delta(\bm{x}).

(3)

Derivations of both of these expressions appear in the paper and will
not be repeated here. Also Eq. (144) of the paper gives

\displaystyle\bm{B}_{\bm{m}}^{\rm T}(\bm{x})

\displaystyle=

\displaystyle\bm{B}_{\bm{m}}^{\rm L}(\bm{x})+\mu_{0}\,\bm{m}\,\delta(\bm{x}).

(4)

The subsequent statement in the comment:“This means that Eq. (17) of
PJM … is wrong because it must be replaced by the angular average”
contains two errors. First, Eq. (17) of the paper is correct and
second, there is no reason why it should be replaced by its angular
average. The conclusion that the rest of the paper is wrong based on
the remarks in the comment is incorrect. The confusion in the comment
appears to be based on the assumption that all magnetic dipole fields
are transverse, which is not true. Incidentially, Eqs. (3), (4), and
(6) of the comment are missing factors of
1/(4\pi)

Read the complete text