Combined Exoplanet Mass and Atmospheric Characterization for Accelerated Exoplanetology

Julien de Wit 1, Sara Seager 1,2,3, and Prajwal Niraula 1 · 2025

Read Combined Exoplanet Mass and Atmospheric Characterization for Accelerated Exoplanetology by Julien de Wit 1, Sara Seager 1,2,3, and Prajwal Niraula 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-25323.txt.

Introduction

To learn what a distant planet's air is made of, astronomers usually first weigh the planet, and that step can stall work. Julien de Wit, Sara Seager, and Prajwal Niraula review a shortcut in this 2025 paper. A planet crossing its star reveals its size, and a space telescope can read its air by the light that filters through. The standard order does mass first, then air, which slows the flow of new results.

Small programs with the Webb telescope have already weighed planets while studying their air. The authors gather those cases and ask how far the shortcut could spread. For about a fifth of planets with known mass, a small Webb program could match or beat the current mass value. Their claim is that, for the most promising planets, teams could skip ahead to the air study and gain speed.

Catalog record

CREATORJulien de Wit 1, Sara Seager 1,2,3, and Prajwal Niraula 1
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-25323

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Combined Exoplanet Mass and Atmospheric Characterization for Accelerated Exoplanetology Julien de Wit 1, Sara Seager 1,2,3, and Prajwal Niraula 1 Abstract Today’s most detailed characterization of exoplanet atmospheres is accessible via transit spectroscopy (TS). Detecting transiting exoplanets only yields their size, and it is thus standard to measure a planet’s mass before moving towards their atmospheric characterization, or even the publication of their discovery. This framework, however, can act as a bottleneck for high-throughput exoplanetology. Here, we review existing applications of an alternative approach deriving exoplanet masses in small JWST atmospheric exploration programs and quantify the potential of its systematic application. We find that for ∼ \sim 20% of transiting exoplanets with existing mass constraints, a small JWST exploration program could yield the planetary mass with a similar–or better—precision. Such results suggest that proceeding directly with atmospheric exploration programs for favorable exoplanets (i.e., with a transmission spectroscopy metric, TSM, ≥ \geq 100) could substantially reduce the time from detection to exoplanet atmospheric study and further support JWST’s scientific output over its lifetime while saving up to 20% of resources on radial-velocity (RV) facilities. Furthermore, it can substantially increase the sample of characterized planets of three distinct subpopulations (Neptune-sized, young, and hot-star exoplanets), each providing specific insights into formation and evolution processes. As the field of exoplanets increasingly turns to directly imaged planets, mastering the determination of planetary masses from atmospheric spectra will become essential. {affiliations} Department of Earth, Atmospheric and Planetary Sciences, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 77 Massachusetts Avenue, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02139, USA; Department of Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 77 Massachusetts Avenue, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA; Department of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 77 Massachusetts Avenue, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA Towards an era of high-throughput, high-precision exoplanetology. Two decades ago, only a handful of planetary candidates were discovered each year. The space-based missions Kepler 1 and TESS 2 increased that rate to hundreds annually, yielding thousands of transiting planets. While planet discovery from those missions has now plateaued, renewed high discovery rates are anticipated with the upcoming PLATO 3 and Roman 4 space missions—meaning the gap between candidate identification and confirmation will widen further. With the new missions and with an ever-growing population of transiting exoplanets, the astronomical community will be poised with the prospects of in-depth ensemble studies of exoplanet atmospheres—primarily thanks to the James Webb Space Telescope 5 JWST; . These two important changes in scale and scope translate into challenges and opportunities for the field. What’s in a name? One of the reasons we have seen such an increase in the number of known exoplanets is a cultural shift in what we call a planet 6 . In the first decade or so of exoplanets being discovered by the transit method (i.e., pre-Kepler), researchers were adamant that an astronomical object could only be called a “planet” if verified by a mass measurement 7 . Brown dwarfs and binary star systems as well as “noise” (from stellar activity to instrument systematics) all have ways of posing as planets, and mass was thought to be the best way to rule out these false positives. Fast-forward to the era of Kepler, and now TESS, where our community happily accepts that a statistically “validated” planet may be deemed worthy of publication while lacking a mass measurement, thus illustrating a progressive shift in what we call a planet. The validation of Kepler’s very first planet candidate (KOI-4.01, now Kepler-1658 b) required a whole decade and input from both radial-velocity and asteroseismology data 8 , for example. While we still maintain a difference between “confirmed” (i.e., mass-measured) and “validated” (no mass but shown with high confidence to be of planetary nature), many studies and planet counts include validated planets. The reason for the cultural shift away from requiring a confirmation is that if a planet is detectable by a transit survey, it is often easily detectable by many other observatories and can thus be “validated”. However, it is not a given that a precise mass measurement (i.e., a “confirmation”) will be easily within reach. While this is especially true for faint host stars or low-mass planets—because radial velocity requires dispersing starlight, standard (i.e., RV-based) mass measurements in general creates a bottleneck as RV instruments can only look at one star at a time whereas transit missions are monitoring hundreds of stars at once. Two textbook examples The recent cases of the hot Jupiters WASP-193 b 9 and V1298 Tau b 10 highlight two variants of the aforementioned bottleneck. Detected in 2015 amongst the WASP Survey data and validated shortly after with TRAPPIST-South, WASP-193 b required another 8 years before confirmation as a planet (and publication of its discovery), as constraints on its mass remained elusive for years. While the planet is a giant exoplanet ( R_{p}=1.464\pm 0.058~R_{\rm Jup} ), its unexpectedly-low density ( \sim 20 \times smaller than Jupiter’s) delayed RV-based insights. Years after its detection, RV measurements finally yielded the first constraint on its mass ( M_{p}=0.139\pm 0.029~M_{\rm Jup} , i.e., \sim 20% relative mass uncertainty—hereafter RMU). For V1298 Tau b, the issue in deriving a RV-based mass constraint was not a low planetary density, but rather high levels of stellar activity leading to stellar rotational modulation an order of magnitude above the expected planetary signal for this giant exoplanet. Recently, TS yielded V1298 Tau b’s mass with a RMU below 10\% 11 , 12 , 13 and rejected at the \sim 40 \sigma level of confidence the best fit RV mass 14 . Other examples of TS-enabled mass measurements are presented in Refs. 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 13 , notably. A new synergy for mass and atmosphere measurements We envision a new cultural shift for what is needed to consistently pass the bar from the discovery stage to the characterization stage (e.g., acquisition of JWST transmission spectra), similar to the one for our working definition of a planet. Such a cultural shift would save RV resources and speed up the atmospheric exploration of dozens of exoplanets. This cultural shift would translate into a revised detection-to-characterization framework to be applied to a subsample of new exoplanets ( Figure 1 ). This revised framework would benefit from a two-birds-one-stone approach, yielding preliminary atmospheric and mass constraints in one go, specifically from the few transit observations typical of JWST’s atmospheric exploration programs. Measuring exoplanet mass via transmission spectroscopy was proposed over a decade ago 19 . Conceptually, information about the planetary mass is accessible through the atmospheric scale height ( H=kT/\mu g —k is the Boltzmann constant, T is the temperature, \mu is the molecular weight, and g is the gravity), which is the primary driver for the amplitude of absorption features 20 . Practically, the new-generation of observatories (esp. JWST) were needed to provide data with the resolution, coverage, and precision to yield independent constraints on its temperature, composition, and pressure profile (example presented in Figure 2 ). The original study 19 focused mostly on mass assessments for small planets, demonstrating notably the viability of such an alternative mass-measurement method for Earth-sized planets around M dwarfs within up to 40 pc and super-Earths around K dwarfs (and later types) within up to 80 pc with up

Read the complete text