Gravitational entropy of fluids with energy flux

Roberto A. Sussman, Sebastián Nájera, Fernando A. Pizaña, Juan Carlos Hidalgo · 2025

Read Gravitational entropy of fluids with energy flux by Roberto A. Sussman, Sebastián Nájera, Fernando A. Pizaña, Juan Carlos Hidalgo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-25007.txt.

Introduction

Roberto Sussman, Sebastián Nájera, Fernando Pizaña, and Juan Carlos Hidalgo examine whether a proposed measure of gravitational entropy really grows in a family of exact universe models. Gravity seems to create order from disorder as structure forms, and the Clifton-Ellis-Tavakol proposal tries to quantify that arrow of time. Their test beds are spherical solutions sourced by a shear-free fluid carrying an energy flux.

Earlier work treated these solutions as mere toy radiating spheres. Read as cosmologies instead, all expanding members obey the entropy growth law, and the entropy form integrates consistently with Einstein's equations. A link to the balance between two kinds of curvature is also explored.

Catalog record

CREATORRoberto A. Sussman, Sebastián Nájera, Fernando A. Pizaña, Juan Carlos Hidalgo
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-25007

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Gravitational entropy of fluids with energy flux Roberto A. Sussman, Sebastián Nájera, Fernando A. Pizaña, Juan Carlos Hidalgo Abstract We examine gravitational entropy growth within the formalism of Clifton, Ellis and Tavakol (CET) applied to a class of spherically symmetric exact solutions whose source is a shear-free fluid with energy flux in a comoving frame. By considering these solutions as potential cosmological models, we update previous literature that considered them only as restricted toy models of radiating spheres collapsing in a Vaidya background. In the present paper we examine the integrability of the CET entropy form in connection with Einstein’s equations in the fluid flow approach, proving as well that all expanding configurations comply with the growth of CET gravitational entropy. Finally, we examine the connection between the CET gravitational entropy and the notion of a gravitational “arrow of time” based on the ratio of Weyl to Ricci curvature. Some of the solutions also provide potentially useful and viable inhomogeneous generalizations of FLRW models, thus suggesting an appealing potential for applications to current cosmological research. keywords Gravitational Entropy, Theoretical Cosmology, Exact Solutions 1 Introduction Observational evidence and theoretical considerations (the near homogeneity and isotropy of the CMB) Aghanim et al. 2020 ; Arbey and Mahmoudi 2021 ; Grohs and Fuller 2023 strongly suggest the early universe up to matter-radiation decoupling to be close to thermal equilibrium. However, an entropy defined in terms of thermal interactions necessarily should reach a maximum and stop growing when structure formation sets in and the Universe becomes gravity dominated and non-thermal. Given this outlook, Penrose Penrose 1979 conjectured that some sort of gravitational entropy notion was needed to account for structure formation that takes place when thermal processes that increased entropy in the early Universe plasma are no longer dominant. Penrose also remarked that the Weyl tensor can be thought of as encoding the free gravitational field, as it is nonzero even in the absence of sources, in which case the Ricci tensor vanishes (hence it is the curvature associated with the sources). Bearing in mind these theoretical connections, Penrose proposed the concept of a gravitational “arrow of time” that guides self-gravitating systems undergoing structure formation to evolve through timelike directions in which an early dominant Ricci curvature should be overtaken by an increasing Weyl curvature as the Universe evolved away from the early plasma into a non-linear structure formation process associated with the long range gravitational interaction. Penrose and other authors have speculated that when this ratio is non-decreasing it should signal a direction of increasing inhomogeneity, producing an increase of entropy in the sense of the application to self-gravitating systems in the framework of the microcanonical ensemble. As the system becomes more inhomogeneous a wider range of densities and momenta are accessed, which increase the volume of accessible states in the phase space. In more recent appraisals of Penrose’s proposal Pelavas and Coley 2006 ; Zhao et al. 2018 ; Guha and Chakraborty 2020 ; Gregoris and Ong 2022 the Ricci scalars can be replaced by the Kretschmann scalar that is nonzero even in vacuum solutions (allowing for the application to vacuum spacetimes). The “arrow of time” proposal holds for known Petrov type D dust solutions along the comoving frame, with an increasing ratio of Weyl to Ricci scalar curvature as inhomogeneity increases and becomes completely encoded in the Weyl tensor. In fact, in inhomogeneous LTB and Szekeres models (for which the magnetic Weyl tensor vanishes) the components of the electric Weyl tensor are determined by the exact density deviation from a homogeneous density background. It is possible to prove that this relation between inhomogeneity and dominance of Weyl curvature also holds in LTB and Szekeres models with nonzero pressure. However, the ratio of Weyl to Ricci curvature might not increase as inhomogeneity grows in a comoving frame in spacetimes with more elaborate sources. In 1985 Bonnor Bonnor 1985 defined a “thermodynamical arrow of time” as a future direction of inhomogeneity growth, to distinguish with Penrose’s “gravitational arrow of time” associated with the future direction of increasing ratio of Weyl to Ricci curvature. Bonnor proved that both “arrows of time” coincided for dust models, but not for heat conducting shear-free models that have been used to model collapsing radiating spheres in a Vaidya exterior background. For these solutions the ratio of Weyl to Ricci scalar curvatures decreases as inhomogeneity grows while collapse proceeds with increasing proper time. Rudjord et al ystein Rudjord et al. 2008 and more recently Chakraborty et al Chakraborty et al. 2021 ; Chakraborty et al. 2024 revisited and validated Bonnor’s result for these models, considering also the ratio of the scalar C_{abcd}C^{abcd} to the Kretschmann scalar to allow applying the ratio to vacuum spacetimes. Nevertheless, Bonnor’s result was tested only on a class of shear-free fluids with energy flux described as heat conduction only to model radiating spheres collapsing in a Vaidya background. In the the present article we show that Bonnor’s result does not hold in the same class of solutions when considering them as expanding cosmological models not restricted by any exterior matching. Further theoretical development on the role of Weyl curvature in structure formation was achieved by Clifton, Ellis and Tavakol (CET), whose gravitational entropy proposal Clifton et al. 2013 also regards Weyl curvature as encoding the free gravitational field, but instead of proposing a scalar formulation they propose an analogue of the Gibbs one-form constructed from an effective gravitational energy-momentum tensor that emerges from the algebraic decomposition of the Bel-Robinson tensor, which is the only divergence-free tensor that can be constructed from the Weyl tensor. The CET entropy proposal is theoretically more robust than previous formulation by Penrose and other in terms of curvature scalars. However, the Bel-Robinson tensor is fourth order, hence CET considered as a candidate for the effective energy-momentum tensor the second order tensors that result from the algebraic decomposition of the Bel-Robinson tensor as a tensor product of two second order tensors (i.e. the “square root” of the Bel Robinson tensor). This algebraic decomposition had been examined by Bonilla and Senovilla Bonilla and Senovilla 1997a ; Bonilla and Senovilla 1997b ; Bonilla and Senovilla 1998 , showing that it is only unique and non-degenerate for Petrov types N and D (wavelike and Coulomb-like spacetimes), with a degeneracy of non-unique second order tensors for the remaining Petrov types. The unique second order root of the Bel-Robinson tensor for spacetimes of Petrov types D and N, can be invariantly projected in terms of an arbitrary 4-velocity field and its orthogonal rest spaces, leading to the definition of ”gravitational” state variables: density, energy flux and stress tensor, with these variables unrelated to the state variables from the energy-momentum tensor of the sources Pelavas and Coley 2006 ; Pelavas and Lake 2000 . From these geometric state variables, CET construct the 4-velocity projected component of an analogue of the thermodynamical Gibbs one form, that defines a convective derivative of a gravitational entropy, with a gravitational temperature as its integrating factor. Since this procedure does not determine the gravitational temperature (as would be the case with an equation of state in a thermal system), CET introduce an ad hoc gravitational temperature in terms of the definition

Read the complete text