Secret Leader Election in Ethereum PoS: An Empirical Security Analysis of Whisk and Homomorphic Sortition under DoS on the Leader and Censorship Attacks
Tereza Burianová, Martin Perešíni, Ivan Homoliak · 2025
Read Secret Leader Election in Ethereum PoS: An Empirical Security Analysis of Whisk and Homomorphic Sortition under DoS on the Leader and Censorship Attacks by Tereza Burianová, Martin Perešíni, Ivan Homoliak (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-24955.txt.
Introduction
Tereza Burianová and co-authors attack two candidate systems for hiding who leads the next Ethereum block. In proof-of-stake chains, knowing the upcoming proposer invites denial-of-service hits and censorship pressure. Secret leader election schemes hide that name until the block appears. Their 2025 paper builds a test bench modeled on Ethereum's consensus layer and turns the attackers loose.
Configurable adversaries flood leaders, censor transactions, or coordinate against groups of validators at once. Two defenses are compared head to head: Whisk and homomorphic sortition. The study claims the first multi-attacker denial-of-service comparison of its kind. Results weigh how much safety each scheme buys and at what cost. Blockchain engineers get evidence, not whitepaper promises, for a live design choice.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Tereza Burianová, Martin Perešíni, Ivan Homoliak |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-24955
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Secret Leader Election in Ethereum PoS: An Empirical Security Analysis of Whisk and Homomorphic Sortition under DoS on the Leader and Censorship Attacks Tereza Burianová, Martin Perešíni, Ivan Homoliak Abstract Proposer anonymity in Proof-of-Stake (PoS) blockchains is a critical concern due to the risk of targeted attacks such as malicious denial-of-service (DoS) and censorship attacks. While several Secret Single Leader Election (SSLE) mechanisms have been proposed to address these threats, their practical impact and trade-offs remain insufficiently explored. In this work, we present a unified experimental framework for evaluating SSLE mechanisms under adversarial conditions, grounded in a simplified yet representative model of Ethereum’s PoS consensus layer. The framework includes configurable adversaries capable of launching targeted DoS and censorship attacks, including coordinated strategies that simultaneously compromise groups of validators. We simulate and compare key protection mechanisms – Whisk, and homomorphic sortition. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first comparative study to examine adversarial DoS scenarios involving multiple attackers under diverse protection mechanisms. Our results show that while both designs offer strong protection against targeted DoS attacks on the leader, neither defends effectively against coordinated attacks on validator groups. Moreover, Whisk simplifies a DoS attack by narrowing the target set from all validators to a smaller list of known candidates. Homomorphic sortition, despite its theoretical strength, remains impractical due to the complexity of cryptographic operations over large validator sets. 1 Introduction The transition of Ethereum from a Proof-of-Work (PoW) [ 31 ] to a PoS [ 19 ] consensus mechanism marked a significant milestone in the evolution of blockchain technology. Unlike PoW systems, where computational effort is used to determine block proposers, PoS selects proposers based on staked value, aiming to reduce energy consumption and increase scalability. However, this architectural shift introduces new attack surfaces, particularly concerning the predictability and exposure of block proposers [ 36 , 8 , 18 ] . In Ethereum’s PoS, validators are selected in advance to propose blocks using the RANDAO [ 13 ] randomness beacon. Although this design enables validators to prepare for their duties, it inadvertently exposes their schedule of block proposals to adversaries. Since proposer identities are publicly known prior to their assigned slots, attackers can target them with Denial-of-Service (DoS) attacks or apply censorship tactics [ 23 , 3 ] . These attacks can degrade network performance, cause economic loss, or even lead to validator centralization by selectively penalizing certain participants [ 23 ] . By targeting specific proposers who might include undesirable transactions (e.g., OFAC non-compliant relays in 2022 [ 28 ] ), adversaries can enforce censorship, weaken liveness, or economically coerce validators, threatening the integrity of the network [ 3 ] . The visibility of proposers is particularly problematic in scenarios involving Maximum Extractable Value (MEV) [ 16 ] , as it allows attackers to target block proposers from previous slots, expanding their MEV opportunities and gaining financial advantages [ 12 ] . A variety of mechanisms have been proposed to protect proposers in PoS-based systems, ranging from SSLE mechanisms [ 1 ] like Whisk [ 25 ] and Blind-and-Swap [ 5 ] , to homomorphic sortition [ 17 ] , VRF-based protocols such as Algorand [ 18 ] , and decentralization through Distributed Validator Technology (DVT) [ 15 ] . While approaches like DVT, network-layer solutions [ 34 ] , and SnSLE [ 4 , 18 ] face drawbacks related to complexity, latency, or compatibility, SSLE mechanisms offer protocol-level proposer anonymity with minimal assumptions, making it the most promising fit for Ethereum’s consensus. Complementary mechanisms like Proposer-Builder Separation (PBS) [ 21 , 32 ] further mitigate incentives for targeting proposers, though they do not provide strict anonymity. This paper focuses on two SSLE mechanisms: (1) Whisk [ 25 ] , a shuffle-based SSLE protocol leveraging zero-knowledge proofs (ZKPs) and (2) homomorphic sortition [ 17 ] , which leverages fully homomorphic encryption (FHE) for collaborative encrypted leader election. While conceptually different, both approaches share the goal of mitigating adversarial visibility of proposers. To evaluate these mechanisms, we developed a simulation framework that models the consensus behavior of Ethereum [ 14 ] and integrates Whisk and homomorphic sortition. Several adversarial scenarios were designed to test the effectiveness of these protections under conditions such as DoS attacks and targeted censorship. The performance of each mechanism was assessed not only in terms of efficacy but also with respect to computational overhead and feasibility within the strict 12-second slot timing of Ethereum. Contributions The contributions of this paper are as follows: \bullet We made a threat analysis of Ethereum’s PoS proposal selection, identifying specific vectors such as block proposer censorship and DoS. \bullet We made a comparative study and simulation-based evaluation of two proposer protection mechanisms (Whisk and homomorphic sortition). \bullet We elaborated on results, trade-offs, future directions, including integration into the existing Ethereum protocol, and open challenges in scalability. Organization The paper is structured as follows. Section 2 provides background on blockchain architecture, consensus mechanisms, and Ethereum’s PoS. Section 3 describes attacks we dealt with. Section 4 describes the chosen protection mechanisms, focusing on their cryptographic foundations and operational logic. Section 5 outlines the simulation framework and the attack scenarios used for evaluation. Section 6 presents the results of our experiments. Section 7 discusses the results, their implications, and outlines directions for future research. Section 8 provides an overview of related work and Section 9 concludes the paper. 2 Background on Ethereum Ethereum is a general-purpose, permissionless blockchain platform that supports decentralized applications and smart contracts [ 40 ] . It operates on a layered architecture composed of a network/data layer, consensus layer, execution layer and application layer. Communication between participants occurs over a peer-to-peer network, while consensus mechanisms ensure agreement on the global state of the chain. Proof-of-Stake in Ethereum. In Ethereum’s PoS consensus, validator identities are represented by a staked amount of Ether (ETH). Validators participate by proposing blocks, attesting to others’ proposals, and finalizing the chain state. Instead of competing for block production using computational power (as in PoW), validators are deterministically selected to perform these duties based on a shared source of randomness and their staked value [ 19 ] . RANDAO and Proposer Selection. Proposer selection in Ethereum relies on RANDAO, a collaborative randomness beacon. With each block, proposers contribute unpredictable and verifiable values. For each epoch, these values are aggregated into a RANDAO mix and stored in the beacon state [ 13 ] . The randomness seed used for proposer selection is derived from the RANDAO mix two epochs prior, allowing validators to know in advance whether they are selected for the role. Since the proposer selection is deterministic and public, anyone can predict the proposer for any upcoming slot once the relevant RANDAO mix is available [ 6 ] . Such a transparency introduces a vulnerability: adversaries can target known proposers. Note that we will refer to this version of leader election as the status quo throughout the paper. Slot and Epoch Timeline . Ethereum divides time into fixed intervals: slots (12 seconds) and epochs (32 slots). Each slot ideally includes a new block proposal by a designated validator and attestation duties by a validator subset. Validators are informed of roles two epochs in