When risk defies order: On the limits of fractional stochastic dominance

Christian Laudagé, Felix-Benedikt Liebrich · 2025

Read When risk defies order: On the limits of fractional stochastic dominance by Christian Laudagé, Felix-Benedikt Liebrich (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-24747.txt.

Introduction

Christian Laudage and Felix-Benedikt Liebrich study risk measures that respect flexible ranking rules for financial positions, in a 2025 paper. A risk measure sums up a position risk in one number, which guides investment choices. Strong ranking rules such as second-order dominance are sound but rigid, so the authors study measures tied to a threshold utility chosen by the user.

Three results are given. For one common utility class, the measures can be written as a lower envelope of adjusted classical measures. A new class of statistics from decision theory is shown to fall inside this family under mild conditions. Beyond that utility class, impossibility results show that measures matching the ranking rules either do not exist or cannot keep key traits at once. The authors note uses in portfolio choice and risk management.

Catalog record

CREATORChristian Laudagé, Felix-Benedikt Liebrich
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE110 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-24747

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

When risk defies order: On the limits of fractional stochastic dominance Christian Laudagé, Felix-Benedikt Liebrich Abstract . Motivated by recent work on monotone additive statistics and questions regarding optimal risk sharing for return-based risk measures, we investigate the existence, structure, and applications of Meyer risk measures . Those are monetary risk measures consistent with fractional stochastic orders suggested by Meyer 1977a , Meyer 1977b as refinement of second-order stochastic dominance (SSD). These so-called v v -SD orders are based on a threshold utility function v v . The test utilities defining the associated order are those at least as risk averse in absolute terms as v v . The generality of v v allows to subsume SSD and other examples from the literature. The structure of risk measures respecting the v v -SD order is clarified by two types of representations. The existence of nontrivial examples is more subtle: for many choices of v v outside the exponential (CARA) class, they do not exist. Additional properties like convexity or positive homogeneity further restrict admissible examples, even within the CARA class. We present impossibility theorems that demonstrate a deeper link between the axiomatic structure of monetary risk measures and SSD than previously acknowledged. The study concludes with two applications: portfolio optimisation under a Meyer risk measure as objective, and risk assessment of financial time series data. Keywords: Fractional stochastic order, monetary risk measure, return risk measure, risk aversion, second-order stochastic dominance. 1. Introduction How should one decide between two random prospects? This question is central to decision theory, risk management, and financial investment. A classical approach is comparing the prospects in second-order stochastic dominance (SSD) pioneered by Hadar and Russell 1969 , Hanoch and Levy 1969 , checking if there is consensual preference for one payoff over the other among all expected utility (EU) agents who share a probabilistic view of the future; prefer more to less (nondecreasing utility); and are risk averse (concave utility). It has been observed, e.g., by Leshno and Levy 2002 that SSD-based decisions can be hijacked by unrealistically risk-averse EU agents. Even when the preference between two payoffs is intuitively clear, SSD may not provide a ranking. They illustrate this with the choice between two payoff lotteries: the first delivers $1 with certainty; the second offers 1 million dollars with 99% chance, and nothing otherwise. While virtually all decision makers would prefer the second lottery over the first, this preference is not reflected by an SSD ordering. Another drawback of using SSD comparisons is that they do not always yield a decision—it is an incomplete order of random prospects. Two alternatives exist. The first one, suggested by Leshno and Levy 2002 and revisited later by Tzeng et al. 2013 , Tsetlin et al. 2015 , Müller et al. 2017 , and Mao et al. 2021 , modifies the set of relevant utility functions, excludes agents whose risk aversion is deemed extreme, and adds locally risk-loving EU agents. These contributions have been preceded by Meyer 1977a , Meyer 1977b , where the risk aversion of the decision-making EU collective is controlled directly. This approach is crucial for the present paper and has been revisited, e.g., by Huang et al. 2020 , Liu and Meyer 2025 . Several of these contributions, e.g., Müller et al. 2017 , lead to fractional-degree interpolation between classical first- and second order stochastic dominance. Building on this observation, Huang et al. 2020 call their framework fractional degree stochastic dominance . 1 1 1 A related perspective, establishing a direct link to fractional integration, is used in Fishburn 1976 , Fishburn 1980 , where a stochastic order grounded in the so-called Riemann-Liouville fractional integral is proposed. For simplicity, we summarise stochastic orders inspired by these approaches under the umbrella term fractional stochastic orders . The shortfall that stochastic orders may not yield clear decisions among arbitrary prospects remains. A second approach is to summarise prospects with a single value, such as a risk measure—see Artzner et al. 1999 and ( Föllmer and Schied 2016 , Chapter 4) —and choose the one with lower risk. Though coarser than SSD consensus, one can always reach a decision. Moreover, the weaknesses of the EU model underpinning SSD are well known. Risk measures are compatible with different decision frameworks and can, e.g., be Choquet integrals. Not least, risk measures typically comply with the preference of more to less by definition, and many practically relevant examples respect SSD by weakly ordering payoffs that are already weakly ordered in SSD. Such an example is the Expected Shortfall (ES) class parametrised by its confidence level, which has been axiomatised by Wang and Zitikis 2021 . For further aspects regarding its use in practice, see Embrechts et al. 2014 , Koch-Medina and Munari 2016 . Another related example is portfolio choice in mean-risk models studied in Herdegen and Khan 2021 , Herdegen and Khan 2024 , where the variance in the classical mean-variance model is replaced by a risk measure. Such a choice often results in decisions consistent with an underlying stochastic order; see Ogryczak and Ruszczyński 1999 , Gotoh and Konno 2000 . We also refer to Levy 1992 for further discussions on the interplay between SSD and portfolio selection. This manuscript joins both outlined alternatives and studies risk measures that are consistent with respect to fractional stochastic orders that may differ from SSD. This raises the question how exactly the SSD order should be modified. To this end, inspired by Leshno and Levy 2002 , we illustrate why it is reasonable from a risk management perspective to exclude overly risk-loving agents from the consensus collective. Consider two payoff lotteries. Lottery 1 offers a 25% chance to win $1 million and nothing otherwise. Lottery 2 offers a 75% chance to win $400,000 and a 25% chance to lose $100,000. While the probability of winning is higher in lottery 2, the potential gain is smaller, and it carries a downside risk. By contrast, losses are excluded in lottery 1. It is therefore reasonable to prefer lottery 1 over lottery 2. Moreover, a decision maker choosing lottery 2 should be required to hold sufficient risk capital to hedge against potential losses. Figure 1. Fraction of expected utilities \mathbb{E}[u_{c}(X)]/\mathbb{E}[u_{c}(Y)] (left), and ES-curves for X and Y (right). If random variables X_{1} and X_{2} represent the risky payoffs of these lotteries, then X_{1} is not SSD-preferred over X_{2} . In contrast to Leshno and Levy 2002 , this is because EU agents may not be sufficiently risk averse. Consider the exponential utility u_{c}(x)=-e^{-cx} with risk aversion c>0 and the EU of X_{1} relative to the one of X_{2} , f(c):=\frac{\mathbb{E}[u_{c}(X_{1})]}{\mathbb{E}[u_{c}(X_{2})]}. EU agent u_{c} weakly prefers X_{1} over X_{2} if f(c)\leq 1 . As can be seen on the left-hand side of Figure 1 , X_{2} exceeds X_{1} in EU at low risk aversion levels, preventing the intuitive SSD-preference. This is also reflected by the ES-curves on the right-hand side of Figure 1 , where X_{1} being SSD-preferred would mean its ES-curve is not undercut by X_{2} ’s. However, that is precisely what happens at ES confidence levels below 69%, as indicated by the dashed vertical line. In conclusion, excluding EU agents with low risk aversion

Read the complete text