The real-time QCD static potential at high temperature
Margaret E. Carrington, Cristina Manuel, Joan Soto · 2025
Read The real-time QCD static potential at high temperature by Margaret E. Carrington, Cristina Manuel, Joan Soto (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-24746.txt.
Introduction
Margaret Carrington, Cristina Manuel, and Joan Soto published a paper in 2025 computing how strongly two heavy quarks attract each other inside a hot quark-gluon plasma. The attraction, the static potential, decides whether bound quark states survive the heat or melt, and experiments need its precise shape. Their method inserts a semi-hard scale between the temperature and the screening mass and integrates region by region.
With that ladder they reach leading and next-to-leading corrections exactly where bound states pass from narrow resonances to wide ones. Loop diagrams from an effective thermal theory mix with power corrections from full QCD. The resulting thermal shifts to the quarkonium spectrum yield dissociation temperature estimates, checked against lattice simulations and offered as guidance for them.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Margaret E. Carrington, Cristina Manuel, Joan Soto |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 85 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-24746
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The real-time QCD static potential at high temperature Margaret E. Carrington, Cristina Manuel, Joan Soto Abstract We develop a procedure to analytically calculate higher-order contributions to the high-temperature real-time static potential in QCD. It is based on the introduction of a semi-hard external scale, which lies between the hard scale (the temperature) and the soft scale (the screening mass), and the method of integration by regions. We calculate the leading and next-to-leading corrections in the region where bound states transit from narrow resonances to wide ones. The calculation involves both loop diagrams calculated in the Hard Thermal Loop (HTL) effective theory and power corrections to the HTL Lagrangian calculated in QCD. We also calculate the thermal corrections to the heavy quarkonium spectrum, and estimate the dissociation temperatures. We compare our results with recent lattice data and discuss their usefulness to guide lattice inputs in inverse problems. I Introduction The finite-temperature QCD static potential is a basic ingredient to understand the behavior of heavy quarkonium in a thermal medium. It was early realized that the Coulomb-like behavior at short distances would be screened in the medium in an analogous way to that of the Coulomb potential for charged particles. As a consequence, fewer and fewer bound states would be supported as the temperature increases, which leads to the conclusion that the production of charmonium (and eventually bottomonium) would be suppressed in heavy ion collision (HIC) experiments Matsui:1986dk . It took some time to realize that the real-time finite-temperature static potential develops an imaginary part Laine:2006ns . The imaginary part becomes parametrically larger than the real part before screening becomes sizable Escobedo:2008sy . This implies that the disappearance of bound states occurs because they become wide resonances rather than because they are no longer supported by the Yukawa-like potential. The suppression of heavy quark bound state production is indeed observed in current HIC experiments, clearly in the bottomonium ( \Upsilon ) family ALICE:2020wwx ; CMS:2018zza and indirectly for charmonium CMS:2017uuv where recombination effects must be taken into account. Experimental results show that the peaks corresponding to bottomonium states become wider and fuse with the background as the multiplicity (temperature) increases, rather than sequentially disappearing with roughly the same width. This pattern is consistent with the idea that bound states disappear because they decay, and not because the potential is screened to the point that it becomes too shallow to support them. The calculation presented in Laine:2006ns is a leading-order (LO) calculation in Hard Thermal Loop (HTL) effective theory. This implicitly assumes that the typical momentum of the gluons exchanged between the heavy quarks is smaller than the temperature (the hard scale). The effect of higher order contributions on this picture was an important open question that has recently been addressed in ref. Carrington:2024ize . We present here details of this beyond leading order (BLO) calculation. It is based on the fact that a new scale exists ( p\sim(Tm_{D}^{2})^{1/3} where T is the temperature and m_{D}\sim gT is the screening mass) for which the imaginary part of the momentum space potential is of the same order as the real part at LO. This scale fulfills the condition m_{D}\ll p\ll T if the QCD coupling constant g is small enough. For momenta of the order of this new scale, which we call semi-hard, one can exploit the inequalties that order the three scales. We use the method of integration by regions Beneke:1997zp ; Smirnov:2012gma to simplify the calculations. We first discuss the corrections to the momentum space potential and provide expressions for these corrections in two approximations, the fully expanded one, which consistently respects the hierarchy discussed above, and the damped approximation, which partially resums higher order contributions. We then discuss the coordinate space potential for distances corresponding to the semi-hard scale. We show that the soft momentum contributions have a universal form. We calculate the semi-hard momentum contributions by Fourier transforming the momentum space potential calculated previously. Expressions for both the fully expanded and the damped approximations are provided. Next, as a first application, the fully expanded expressions are used to analytically calculate corrections to the thermal energy shifts and thermal decay rates, by treating all corrections to the QCD Coulomb potential perturbatively. We then push our formulas beyond their strict applicability range and compare our results with recent lattice data. The reasonable description we obtain encourages us to propose that our results could serve as inputs for Bayesian methods Jarrell:1996rrw ; Asakawa:2000tr ; Rothkopf:2011ef ; Burnier:2013fca ; Burnier:2013nla , which are needed to obtain the imaginary part of the real-time potential from lattice QCD Rothkopf:2011db ; Burnier:2014ssa ; Burnier:2015tda ; Burnier:2016mxc ; Lehmann:2020fjt ; Boguslavski:2021zga ; Bala:2021fkm ; Dong:2022mbo ; Bazavov:2023dci . Since the LO HTL potential is often used as inputs, our results provide a potentially significant improvement. We organize the paper as follows. In Section II we describe the formalism and discuss the leading-order results of ref. Laine:2006ns . In Section III we explain our approach. In Sections IV and V we present the calculations of the self-energy diagrams, and the ladder and vertex diagrams respectively (see fig. 2 ). In Section VI we discuss our power counting. In Section VII we calculate the coordinate space potential and discuss the universal form of the soft contributions. In Section VIII we present an analytic calculation of the thermal energy shifts and thermal decay widths. In Section IX we compare our results to lattice calculations, and estimate the dissociation temperature. Section X is devoted to the conclusions. II The static potential for p\ll T at LO In this section we give some details of the leading order calculation that will be useful to understand the higher order computations presented in the following sections. We work in the closed-time-path (CTP) formalism of thermal field theory (see the reviews Zhou-CTP ; Rothkopf:2019ipj ; Ghiglieri:2020dpq ) and we use an approach based on the HTL effective theory Braaten:1991gm . The static quark and antiquark are (unthermalised) probe particles that couple to gluons from the time-ordered branch of the CTP contour. The vertices in the anti-time-ordered branch are only needed for the calculation of the gluon self-energy (see section IV ). We use dimensional regularization throughout. Additional information about the definitions and notational conventions we use are given in appendix A . The static potential can be obtained from the Wilson loop \displaystyle W={\cal P}\;{\rm Exp}\left(ig\oint dx^{\mu}A_{\mu}(x)\right) (1) where the symbol {\cal P} indicates path ordering along the rectangular path shown in fig. 1 . The potential is defined as \displaystyle V(\vec{r})=\lim_{t\to\infty}v(t,\vec{r}) \displaystyle v(t,\vec{r})=\frac{i}{t}\ln[C(t,\vec{r})] \displaystyle C(t,\vec{r})=\frac{1}{N_{c}}\langle W_{1}W_{2}W_{3}W_{4}\rangle (2) where we have used W=W_{1}W_{2}W_{3}W_{4} and the notation W_{i} refers to the Wilson line corresponding to each of the four branches of the loop as shown in fig. 1 . Figure 1: The Wilson loop used in eq. ( 2 ). We calculate the potential perturbatively by expanding in g to obtain \displaystyle C_{0}(t,\vec{r})+g^{2}C_{1}(t,\vec{r})+g^{4}C_{2}(t,\vec{r})+\dots={\rm Exp}\left[-it\left(g^{2}v_{1}(t,\vec{r})+g^{4}v_{2}(t,\vec{r})+\dots\right)\right]\,. (3) Matching orders in g gives \displaystyle V_{1}(\vec{r}) \displaystyle=\lim_{t\to\infty}v_{1}(t,\vec{r})=\lim_{t\to\infty}\left(\frac{iC_{1}(t,\vec{r})}{t}\right)\ (4) \displaystyle V_{2}(\vec{r}) \displaystyle=\lim_{t\to\infty}v_{2}(t,\vec{r})=\lim_{t\to\infty}\left(\frac{iC_{2}(t,\vec{r})}{t}-\frac{iC^{2}_{1}(t,\vec{r})}{2t}\right)\,. (5) When we take the limit t\to\infty the lines along the right and the left sides can be set to one. This means that the only component of the vector potential that contributes in eq. ( 1 ) is the