Groups versus quandle-like invariants of 3-manifolds
Lực Ta · 2025
Read Groups versus quandle-like invariants of 3-manifolds by Lực Ta (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-24098.txt.
Introduction
Luc Ta compares two ways to build invariants, quantities that can tell three-dimensional spaces apart. One way uses groups, the classic algebraic tool. The other uses risandles, nonassociative structures brought in recently for this purpose, in analogy to the quandles used for knots.
Ta shows the two routes match at a deep level: the category of groups and the category of nonempty, faithful risandles are equivalent. He also defines a fundamental risandle for a space, which encodes the coloring invariants of Ishii, Nakamura, and Saito. For infinitely many spaces, the match lets one recover the fundamental group from the fundamental risandle, and the reverse as well.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lực Ta |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-24098
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Groups versus quandle-like invariants of 3-manifolds Lực Ta Abstract . Risandles are nonassociative algebraic structures recently introduced to construct invariants of 3 3 -manifolds. In this note, we show that the categories of groups and nonempty, faithful risandles are equivalent. In analogy to knot quandles, we also introduce fundamental risandles of 3 3 -manifolds, which categorify the risandle coloring invariants of Ishii, Nakamura, and Saito [ 6 ] . For infinitely many 3 3 -manifolds, the equivalence of categories recovers the fundamental group from the fundamental risandle and vice versa. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 20N02, 57K31; Secondary 20J15, 57K12 1. Introduction In 2024, Ishii, Nakamura, and Saito [ 6 ] introduced nonassociative algebraic structures called risandles to construct coloring invariants of smooth, closed, connected, oriented 3-manifolds. The inspiration for risandles came from similar algebraic structures called quandles , which Joyce [ 9 ] and Matveev [ 11 ] independently introduced in 1982 to construct complete knot invariants. Risandles are one of several kinds of quandle-like algebraic structures used to study invariants of 3-manifolds; see, for example, [ 3 ] [ 13 ] [ 12 ] [ 4 ] [ 5 ] [ 14 ] . The classification problems for these structures are important for computing coloring invariants and cocycle invariants of knots and 3 -manifolds [ 15 ] . To address the classification problem for risandles, we prove the following. Let \mathsf{Grp} and \mathsf{Ris}_{\mathrm{fai}} denote the categories of groups and nonempty, faithful risandles, respectively. Theorem 1.1 . The functor \mathcal{R}\colon\mathsf{Grp}\xrightarrow{\sim}\mathsf{Ris}_{\mathrm{fai}} sending each group G to the risandle \mathcal{R}(G)\coloneq(G,\triangleright) with operation h\triangleright g\coloneq hg^{-1} is an equivalence of categories. The inverse functor \mathcal{L}\colon\mathsf{Ris}_{\mathrm{fai}}\xrightarrow{\sim}\mathsf{Grp} sends each nonempty, faithful risandle X to its right multiplication group \RMult(X) . In analogy with knot quandles, we also introduce fundamental risandles \mathcal{F}(M) of smooth, closed, connected, oriented 3 -manifolds M . Fundamental risandles categorify the risandle coloring invariants introduced in [ 6 ] via ( 7.1 ), and they also satisfy the following. Theorem 1.2 (Theorem 7.3 ) . The fundamental risandle is an invariant of 3-manifolds up to orientation-preserving diffeomorphism. Theorem 1.3 (Theorem 9.5 ) . There exist infinitely many 3-manifolds M such that the fundamental risandle \mathcal{F}(M) and the fundamental group \pi_{1}(M) recover one another via \mathcal{L} and \mathcal{R} . 1.1. Structure of the paper In Section 2 , we recall several definitions and notational conventions from the theories of right quasigroups and quandles. In Section 3 , we define the category \mathsf{Ris} of risandles, and we temporarily introduce algebraic structures called risacks having one fewer axiom than risandles. We also discuss the functors \mathcal{L}\dashv\mathcal{R} appearing in Theorem 1.1 as adjoint functors between \mathsf{Grp} and \mathsf{Ris} . In Section 4 , we record several algebraic properties of risandles. As applications, we show that all risacks are risandles and provide coordinate-free characterizations of risandles and faithful risandles. In Section 5 , we use the results of Section 4 to prove Theorem 1.1 . In Section 6 , we discuss free risandles \langle X\rangle and quotients of risandles by congruence relations. These notions come from universal algebra, and we will need them to define fundamental risandles. In Section 7 , we introduce fundamental risandles \mathcal{F}(M) of 3 -manifolds M and prove Theorem 1.2 (Theorem 7.3 ). We also explain how fundamental risandles categorify the risandle coloring invariants introduced in [ 6 ] ; see ( 7.1 ). In Section 8 , we study the fundamental risandle \mathcal{F}(M) of the lens space M=L(n,1) , where n\in\mathbb{Z}^{+} is a positive integer. In Section 9 , we pose two open questions about the relationship between fundamental risandles \mathcal{F}(M) and fundamental groups \pi_{1}(M) . Finally, we prove Theorem 1.3 (Theorem 9.5 ). Notation . We use the following notation throughout this paper. Denote the composition of functions \varphi\colon X\to Y and \psi\colon Y\to Z by \psi\varphi . Given a set X , let S_{X} denote the symmetric group of X , and let \id_{X}\in S_{X} denote the identity map of X . Let \mathbb{Z}^{+} denote the set of positive integers. 2. Right quasigroups Following [ 17 ] [ 1 ] [ 16 ] in analogy with quandles, we will define risandles as a special class of right quasigroups (that is, magmas such that all right multiplication maps are permutations). Definition 2.1 ( [ 1 ] [ 16 ] ) . A right quasigroup is a pair (X,s) where X is a set and s\colon X\to S_{X} is a function from X to its symmetric group. For all x\in X , we call the map s_{x}\coloneq s(x) a right multiplication map or right translation . If s_{x}=\id_{X} , then we call x a right identity element of X . Finally, if s is injective, then we say that (X,s) is faithful . Equivalently, a right quasigroup is a pair (X,\triangleright_{X}) where X is a set and \triangleright_{X}\colon X\times X\to X is a binary operation such that, for all x\in X , the function y\mapsto y\triangleright_{X}x is a permutation of X . We will omit the subscript from \triangleright_{X} when it is clear from the context. 1 1 1 This paper borrows the notation s_{x}(y) and \triangleright from quandle theory to hint at the analogies between quandles and risandles; cf. [ 6 ] . In particular, neither quandle operations nor risandle operations \triangleright are associative in general. The equivalence of this definition with Definition 2.1 is given by the formula s_{x}(y)=y\triangleright x. Each of these two definitions has advantages over the other; this paper uses them interchangeably. Definition 2.2 ( [ 1 ] [ 16 ] ) . The right multiplication group of a right quasigroup (X,s) , denoted by \RMult(X) , is the subgroup of S_{X} generated by the set s(X) of right multiplication maps: \RMult(X)\coloneq\langle s_{x}\mid x\in X\rangle\leq S_{X}. Definition 2.3 ( [ 1 ] [ 16 ] ) . A homomorphism of right quasigroups, say from (X,\triangleright_{X}) to (Y,\triangleright_{Y}) , is a function \varphi\colon X\to Y that preserves the binary operations of X and Y ; that is, \varphi(w\triangleright_{X}x)=\varphi(w)\triangleright_{Y}\varphi(x) for all w,x\in X . Let \mathsf{RQuas} denote the category of right quasigroups and their homomorphisms. Then an isomorphism in \mathsf{RQuas} is simply a bijective homomorphism. Example 2.4 . The (right) regular action of a group G on itself, given by h\triangleright g\coloneq hg , defines a right quasigroup (G,\triangleright) . Denote the category of groups by \mathsf{Grp} . Under this view, it is easy to see that \mathsf{Grp} embeds faithfully but not fully into \mathsf{RQuas} . Example 2.5 ( [ 3 ] [ 9 ] [ 11 ] [ 16 ] ) . A rack is a right quasigroup such that all right multiplication maps s_{x} are endomorphisms. A quandle is a rack (X,\triangleright) such that x\triangleright x=x for all x\in X . The right multiplication group of a rack is often called its inner automorphism group or operator group . 3. Risandles In this section, we study the algebraic properties of risandles , which Ishii, Nakamura, and Saito introduced in [ 6 ] with inspiration from quandle theory. 3.1. Risacks and risandles Analogizing the relationship between racks and quandles (see [ 3 ] ), we temporarily introduce risacks , which have one fewer axiom than risandles. Like