Combustion Behaviour of Single Silicon Particles in Different Oxidizing Environments Journal: Combustion and Flame
Herman Heng, Hugo Keck, Christian Chauveau, Samuel Goroshin, Jeffrey Bergthorson, Fabien Halter · 2025
Read Combustion Behaviour of Single Silicon Particles in Different Oxidizing Environments Journal: Combustion and Flame by Herman Heng, Hugo Keck, Christian Chauveau, Samuel Goroshin, Jeffrey Bergthorson, Fabien Halter (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-24070.txt.
Introduction
Silicon is cheap, common, and packs a lot of energy, yet its use as a clean fuel is little studied. Herman Heng and 5 co-authors burned single silicon grains held in place by an electric trap and lit by a laser. They tried five gas mixes, from plain air to pure oxygen, with helium or argon added in some runs.
Hotter gas mixes raised the peak heat of the burning drop by a wide margin. A helium mix burned cooler than an argon mix at the same oxygen share, against what basic theory predicted. The team links that gap to how heat and gas move in the mix. Film in normal and ultraviolet light showed a gas form of silicon oxide leaving the drop as it shrank.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Herman Heng, Hugo Keck, Christian Chauveau, Samuel Goroshin, Jeffrey Bergthorson, Fabien Halter |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 48 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-24070
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Combustion Behaviour of Single Silicon Particles in Different Oxidizing Environments Journal: Combustion and Flame Herman Heng, Hugo Keck, Christian Chauveau, Samuel Goroshin, Jeffrey Bergthorson, Fabien Halter Abstract Silicon, despite its abundance and high energy density, remains underexplored as a carbon-free fuel, with limited data available on its combustion characteristics. In this work, the combustion behaviour of silicon particles is examined using an electrostatic levitator with laser ignition. Five oxidizing environments at atmospheric pressure are investigated: air, pure oxygen, and mixtures containing 40% oxygen (by mole) diluted with nitrogen, helium, or argon. The burning droplet peak temperature, measured by three-colour pyrometry, increases by 337 K from air to pure oxygen. The measured peak temperature of the silicon droplet in the 40%O 2 –60%He mixture is noticeably lower than that in the 40%O 2 –60%Ar mixture, in contradiction with thermodynamic predictions, due to a higher Lewis number of the helium-diluted mixture. Although oxygen diffusivity is higher in the helium-diluted mixture, a lower burning rate is observed, attributed to the lower combustion temperature. High-speed colour camera observations (with a resolution of about 1.25 µm/px) reveal that the square of the particle diameter, d 2 d^{2} , decreases with time, t t , in each individual combustion run, following a strong linear relationship ( R 2 > 0.99 R^{2}>0.99 ) across all oxidizing environments. However, the combustion lifetime, τ c \tau_{\mathrm{c}} , and initial particle diameter, d i d_{\mathrm{i}} , follow a trend of τ c ∝ d i n \tau_{\mathrm{c}}\propto d_{\mathrm{i}}^{n} , with n n ranging from 1.69 to 1.82. This deviation from the expected n = 2 n=2 appears to result from unavoidable measurement uncertainties and the limited particle size range, rather than differences in combustion physics. The decrease in silicon droplet size during combustion is attributed to the formation of gaseous SiO as an intermediate combustion product. The SiO species is observed using a UV camera, showing a UV intensity decay from the particle surface. High-speed imaging and LED absorption signals indicate that the final condensed product, SiO 2 nanoparticles, are not optically visible, suggesting they possess very low emissivity. Novelty and significance statement We present the first experimental demonstration of ignition and complete combustion of single silicon particles, providing the first evidence that their combustion follows the classical d^{2} law, unlike many previous studies on metal particles that reported deviations. The identified influence of Lewis number and particle size on combustion time, as well as the observed radiative properties of silicon combustion products, offers insights of scientific and engineering significance for developing combustion technologies using silicon as a carbon-free energy carrier. 1 Introduction Metal fuels have gained increasing attention over the past few decades as carbon-free energy carriers. Silicon is a promising candidate in this role due to its abundance in Earth’s crust and high specific energy density. Its widespread availability makes it attractive, potentially eliminating the need to recycle its combustion product (silicon dioxide) for reduction. Instead, the SiO 2 nano-particle product generated during combustion can be repurposed for material synthesis in industries such as cement, ceramics, and reflective coatings [ 1 , 2 ] – integrating clean energy production with local manufacturing. These key attributes may position silicon as a potentially more favourable candidate than aluminum and iron, the most extensively studied metal fuels in the literature to date. Despite these advantages, silicon has not yet been widely considered as fuel within the combustion community. Most prior applications of silicon combustion have focused on pyrotechnics [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] rather than investigating its potential and properties in the context of sustainable fuels for energy systems. While silicon has been investigated as a component in composite propellants [ 7 ] , combustion data on pure silicon metal remains limited. This is due to the challenge of igniting silicon particles, caused by a protective silicon dioxide layer [ 8 ] , and its relatively slow combustion rate compared to more volatile metals, such as aluminum and magnesium. Nevertheless, recent work at McGill University [ 9 ] has successfully demonstrated the first laminar silicon dust flame stabilized on a Bunsen burner. This breakthrough not only confirms that pure silicon can sustain self-propagating combustion for energy applications but also enables detailed investigation into its combustion characteristics, including laminar burning velocity, flame temperature, combustion products, and the combustion mode of silicon. Nevertheless, dust flame experiments still present limitations, particularly in observing the behaviour of individual particles, such as their size and temperature evolution during combustion. These insights are essential for deepening our understanding of the combustion process and for validating the applicability of existing available theoretical combustion models to silicon particle combustion. The classical d^{2} law of combustion [ 10 ] has long been used to describe the temporal evolution of a burning droplet’s size for diffusion-controlled combustion, as expressed in Equation 1 : d^{2}=d_{\mathrm{i}}^{2}-Kt (1) where d is the instantaneous particle diameter, d_{\mathrm{i}} is the initial diameter, t is time, and K is a proportionality constant. When the particle is fully consumed ( d = 0), Equation 1 reduces to \tau_{\mathrm{c}}=d_{\mathrm{i}}^{2}/K , where \tau_{\mathrm{c}} is the complete combustion time. This relationship implies that the combustion time is directly proportional to the square of the initial particle diameter, with the proportionality constant K characterizing the burning rate. The d^{2} law has been observed in experiments for conventional fuels, such as liquid hydrocarbons [ 11 , 12 ] and char [ 13 ] , for most of the droplet particle combustion lifetime. In the case of metal fuels, some studies have shown that aluminum combustion somewhat fits the trend of the d^{2} law [ 14 , 15 , 16 ] ; however, it is also recognized that the formation of an aluminum oxide cap on the droplet surface significantly alters the symmetry of aluminum droplet combustion, which affects the accuracy of the classical model. Several models have been proposed to account for the effects of aluminum oxide cap formation [ 17 , 18 , 19 ] in the estimation of burning time. Iron particle combustion presents a different heterogeneous combustion mode. Because the boiling points of iron and its (sub-)oxides are typically lower than the flame temperature, the particle size does not necessarily decrease as predicted by the classical d^{2} law. Ning et al. [ 20 ] reported a d^{n} -law with n=1.46-1.72 for single iron particles, indicating a deviation from the classical d^{2} law. Several studies have attempted to develop a new model to account for particle growth and changes in particle density after oxidation [ 21 , 22 ] in iron particle combustion. There have been numerous numerical and experimental investigations on the combustion of single iron and aluminum particles within the combustion community. However, for silicon, combustion data remain scarce. As a result, the combustion behaviour of individual silicon particles is still not well understood. It should be noted that metal fuels are more chemically diverse than hydrocarbon fuels [ 23 ] , where insights gained from the combustion of one metal fuel cannot be directly applied to another. Each metal fuel requires its own comprehensive investigation and understanding, as their reaction chemistry, thermodynamics, and phase transformations are fundamentally distinct without a unified framework. In the