Experimental study of diffusiophoresis in a cellular flow

Florence Raynal 1, Menghua Zhao 1 2, Romain Volk 2 · 2025

Read Experimental study of diffusiophoresis in a cellular flow by Florence Raynal 1, Menghua Zhao 1 2, Romain Volk 2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-23914.txt.

Introduction

Colloids drifting in a cellular flow do not quite follow the fluid when salt gradients push them sideways. Florence Raynal and 2 co-authors study that diffusiophoresis experimentally in a two-dimensional Rayleigh-Bénard cell. The colloids gain a small extra velocity along the log gradient of salt concentration. Theory from Volk and co-workers in 2022 predicted either enhanced transport or blockage, depending on a blockage coefficient.

Using high-dynamic-range light-induced fluorescence, the team tracks the colloid concentration field at large Peclet number. Agreement with theory is good even though the experiment is spatially uneven and transient. Injecting salt and colloids at both ends sped transport; injecting them together blocked it when the phoretic push was strong.

Catalog record

CREATORFlorence Raynal 1, Menghua Zhao 1 2, Romain Volk 2
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE71 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-23914

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Experimental study of diffusiophoresis in a cellular flow Florence Raynal 1, Menghua Zhao 1 2, Romain Volk 2 Abstract In this article, we study experimentally the dispersion of colloids in a two-dimensional, time independent, Rayleigh-Bénard flow in the presence of salt gradients. Due to the additional scalar, the colloids do not follow exactly the Eulerian flow-field, but have a (small) extra-velocity 𝐯 dp = D dp ∇ log C s \mathbf{v}_{\mathrm{dp}}=D_{\mathrm{dp}}\nabla\log C_{s} , where D dp D_{\mathrm{dp}} is the phoretic constant and C s C_{s} the salt concentration. Such a configuration is motivated by the theoretical work by Volk et al. 2022 , which predicted enhanced transport or blockage in a stationary cellular flow depending on the value of a blockage coefficient. By means of High Dynamical Range Light Induced Fluorescence, we study the evolution of the colloids concentration field at large Péclet number. We find a good agreement with the theoretical work although a number of hypotheses are not satisfied, as the experiment is non homogeneous in space and intrinsically transient. In particular we observe enhanced transport when salt and colloids are injected at both ends of the Rayleigh-Bénard chamber, and blockage when colloids and salt are injected together and phoretic effects are strong enough. † † affiliation: 1 Laboratoire de Mécanique des Fluides et d’Acoustique, CNRS UMR 5509, École centrale de Lyon, INSA Lyon, Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1, 69134 Écully Cédex, France 2 Laboratoire de Physique, ENS de Lyon, CNRS, F-69342 Lyon, France 1 Introduction The transport of particles or macro-molecules in a flow can be affected by concentration gradients of a scalar field present in the flow such as temperature, solute concentration, or nutrient in the case of living organisms. Such phoretic particles do not follow exactly the Eulerian flow-field but have a small drift velocity, the precise expression of which depends on the physical phenomenon involved. In the case of charged colloids in water, this extra-displacement is related to electrokinetic effects, and the phenomenon is called diffusiophoresis: due to salt gradients, the drift velocity takes the form \mathbf{v}_{\mathrm{dp}}=D_{\mathrm{dp}}\nabla\log C_{s} , where D_{\mathrm{dp}} is the diffusiophoretic mobility and C_{s} is the salt concentration ( Derjaguin et al. 1961 ; Prieve et al. 1984 ; Anderson 1989 ; Ault & Shin 2024 ) . Although the drift velocity is usually very small as compared to any macroscopic fluid velocity, it has a strong influence on how the phoretic particles spread inside the flow, even at the macro-scale ( Mauger et al. 2016 ) . In particular, it was found that mixing could be delayed or enhanced depending on if the colloids are introduced together with the salt or introduced in salted water: for instance, Abécassis et al. 2009 showed in a \Psi- channel that the diffusiophoretic effect could be modelled by a diffusive behaviour, with a positive or negative effective diffusion coefficient much greater than that of the large colloidal particle; in chaotic advection, mixing of colloids was measured using an effective Péclet number ( Deseigne et al. 2014 ; Mauger et al. 2016 ; Raynal & Volk 2019 ) . However, the complex behavior of colloidal particles cannot be summed up by a simple diffusive effect; indeed, its origin lies in the compressibility of the drift velocity \nabla\cdot\mathbf{v}_{\mathrm{dp}} , which can be set to be positive or negative depending on the configuration ( Volk et al. 2014 ; Raynal et al. 2018 ; Renaud & Vanneste 2020 ; Chu et al. 2020 ; Chu et al. 2021 ; Chu et al. 2022 ) . Another important situation, often encountered in practical applications and distinct from the previous open flows above, is the case of flows with closed streamlines. Indeed most flows have recirculation loops from which a perfect tracer cannot escape if the flow remains steady. In particular, the transport of a passive scalar in an array of vortices with closed streamlines was the focus of several theoretical and experimental studies ( Shraiman 1987 ; Soward 1987 ; Young et al. 1989 ; Solomon & Gollub 1988b ) . In such a configuration, it has been shown that advection-diffusion of Brownian particles leads to diffusive dynamics at long times with a ratio of their effective diffusivity to the molecular diffusivity growing as the square root of the Péclet number, \mathit{Pe}=UL/D , where U is the velocity scale, L the size of the recirculation cell, and D the molecular diffusivity of the particles. More recently, this study has been extended to the theoretical case of joint transport of salt and phoretic particles ( Volk et al. 2022 ) . In this work, salt inhomogeneities are forced by a constant salt gradient \mathbf{G} , leading to strong salt variations in between vortices; phoretic particles have a linear drift velocity of the form \mathbf{v}_{\mathrm{drift}}=\alpha\nabla C_{s} and are initially homogeneously released. By means of numerical simulations performed in both Eulerian and Lagrangian framework, in the limit of realistic large Péclet numbers for both salt and colloids, the authors could address how colloids move or regroup in the flow under the action of advection, diffusion and phoresis. The study showed the existence of two regimes, both very different from the diffusive-like behaviour observed in previous studies, depending on the value of a parameter \displaystyle R=\frac{\alpha GL}{2\sqrt{D_{c}D_{s}}} , where D_{s} and D_{c} are the diffusion coefficients of salt and colloids respectively: (i) For R\ll 1 , the transport of colloids was strongly enhanced, leading to a mean velocity v_{m}\sim\alpha G\sqrt{\mathit{Pe}_{s}} , where \mathit{Pe}_{s}=UL/D_{s} is the salt Péclet number; this velocity is the much larger than the phoretic velocity \alpha G that the particles would have in the absence of flow. This regime is called “enhanced transport” in the following; (ii) For R\gg 1 , when phoretic effects are very strong compared to diffusion, instead of moving even more rapidly in the direction of the mean salt gradient, the colloids are trapped in their cells. This regime is referred to as “blockage” in the following, and R is called “blockage coefficient”. However, these theoretical findings were obtained in the stationary regime with periodic boundary conditions and a mean salt gradient constant in space, so that phoretic effects could build up in time without any constraint. One may then wonder if these two regimes can be observed experimentally after injection of salt and colloids in some bounded convective flow, a problem of dispersion that is intrinsically transient and non homogeneous in space. In this article, we propose to prove experimentally the existence of the two regimes of enhanced transport and blockage. To this end, we use the same phoretic particles as in Mauger et al. 2016 , i.e. charged colloids which are attracted toward regions of high salt concentration. This makes it impossible to create the cellular flow by electro-convection ( Bergougnoux et al. 2014 ) as it would require already salted water, which could screen the diffusiophoretic effects. Rather, we use the experimental configuration of Solomon & Gollub 1988b , which takes place in a long horizontal Rayleigh-Bénard cell, where the flow is time-independent and composed of an alignment of steady convection rolls in the closed chamber, see figure 1 . In order to study how the injected colloids or salt spread inside

Read the complete text