Interferometric inference of black hole spin from photon ring size and brightness
Joseph R. Farah, Alexandru Lupsasca, Eliot Quataert, Michael D. Johnson · 2025
Read Interferometric inference of black hole spin from photon ring size and brightness by Joseph R. Farah, Alexandru Lupsasca, Eliot Quataert, Michael D. Johnson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-23628.txt.
Introduction
Light that loops once around a black hole forms a photon ring whose size can betray the hole's spin. Joseph R. Farah and 3 co-authors define a new interferometric observable for that ring ahead of the proposed Black Hole Explorer. The observable ties directly to the ring's brightness profile around its circle. In their survey of emission models, the brightness pattern shifts with the source's physics, while the ring's width stays nearly fixed.
That steadiness makes width a probe of the space-time itself, like the ring's shape. Diameter plus width could pin spin and tilt to within about twenty percent for a hole with known mass and distance. Large simulations back the claim.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Joseph R. Farah, Alexandru Lupsasca, Eliot Quataert, Michael D. Johnson |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-23628
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Interferometric inference of black hole spin from photon ring size and brightness Joseph R. Farah, Alexandru Lupsasca, Eliot Quataert, Michael D. Johnson Abstract The n = 1 n=1 photon ring is a full image of the astrophysical source around a black hole, produced by photons that execute n ≈ 1 n\approx 1 half-orbit around the event horizon on their way to an observer. The Black Hole Explorer (BHEX) is a proposed extension of the Event Horizon Telescope to space that will target the n = 1 n=1 photon rings of the supermassive black holes M87 ∗ and Sgr A ∗ . In this paper, we introduce a new interferometric observable that will be directly measurable on BHEX baselines and which admits a clear image-domain interpretation in terms of the photon ring brightness profile. Across a wide range of semi-analytic equatorial emission models, we find that the azimuthal intensity profile of the ring can change depending on the astrophysics of the source, but its width w b w_{b} is weakly sensitive to these details—much like the ring shape, which has previously been identified as a probe of the spacetime geometry. Our survey suggests that interferometric measurements of the photon ring diameter and w b w_{b} can place constraints (to ≲ 20 % \lesssim\!20\% ) on the spin and inclination of a black hole with a known mass-to-distance ratio, such as Sgr A ∗ . State-of-the-art numerical simulations support this finding, paving the way to a precise photon-ring-based spin measurement for Sgr A ∗ with BHEX. I Introduction The Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) has used an array of ground radio stations to observe the black holes M87 ∗ and Sgr A ∗ via very-long-baseline interferometry (VLBI) ( Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration 2019 ; Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration 2022 ) . The Black Hole Explorer (BHEX) is a mission under development to extend terrestrial (sub)millimeter VLBI to space by launching a satellite into Earth orbit at \gtrsim 20,000\, km altitude Johnson et al. 2024 ; Marrone et al. 2024 . With an effective aperture three times larger than the Earth, BHEX will take the sharpest images in the history of astronomy, enabling it to measure the first ( n=1 ) photon rings around the supermassive black hole targets M87 ∗ and Sgr A ∗ Lupsasca et al. 2024 , which so far remain unresolved ( Lockhart and Gralla 2022 ; Tiede et al. 2022 ) . The n=1 photon ring is a full image of the astrophysical source around a black hole, produced by photons that execute n\approx 1 half-orbit around the horizon on their way to their observer Luminet 1979 ; Gralla et al. 2019 ; Johnson et al. 2020 ; Gralla and Lupsasca 2020 . Since these photons probe the strong gravity of the spacetime just outside the horizon, the ring image that they produce carries information about the geometry of the black hole, including its mass, inclination and spin. In particular, inferring the spins of the black holes M87 ∗ and Sgr A ∗ from measurements of their n=1 photon rings is a primary goal for BHEX Lupsasca et al. 2024 . The interferometric response to M87 ∗ or Sgr A ∗ on the baselines sampled by an Earth-orbiting satellite is dominated by the n=1 ring. This nearly circular ring has a typical diameter of d\approx 10M and a narrow width w\lesssim M\ll d , and its interferometric signature on baselines 1/d\ll u\ll 1/w sampled by BHEX is essentially universal : that is, the visibility is almost completely fixed by the ring size, shape, and brightness asymmetry, with scant dependence on its (unresolved) radial profile. The ring produces a characteristic ringing signature whose periodicity and amplitude encode its angle-dependent diameter and brightness asymmetry, respectively. The brightness asymmetry visibly varies with the rotation of the black hole and is clearly worth investigating as a tool for spin inference. Here, we consider two visibility-domain observables that are directly measurable on the BHEX baselines where the n=1 subring dominates ( u\!\sim\!20 - 40\,\mathrm{G}\lambda ) and that together encode the geometry of the ring as well as its azimuthal brightness profile. While this profile can rotate and change in ways that do depend on the astrophysics of the source, we find that its width (illustrated in Fig. 1 ) is weakly sensitive to these details—much like the diameter itself, which has previously been identified as a probe of the spacetime geometry Cárdenas-Avendaño and Lupsasca 2023 . A naïve measure of the brightness asymmetry of the photon ring based on its visibility-amplitude envelope—e.g., (V_{\max}+V_{\min})/(V_{\max}-V_{\min}) as a function of baseline angle \varphi —is attractive but proves sensitive to astrophysical details and is difficult to estimate with low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). Instead, we integrate the squared visibilities over the n=1 -dominated annulus in the (u,v) plane to obtain an angular profile b_{\varphi}\!\equiv\!\int_{u_{-}}^{u_{+}}\!\!|V(u,\varphi)|^{2}\,\mathop{}\!\mathrm{d}u , whose full width at half maximum we denote by w_{b} (see Fig. 1 ). Physically, b_{\varphi} tracks the azimuthal distribution of subring brightness, and w_{b} provides a robust, directly interferometric proxy for the width of that distribution. We pair w_{b} with a geometric observable d_{+} , the maximum of the angle-dependent diameter d_{\varphi} of the n=1 subring, inferred from the periodicity of the Bessel-like ringing in the visibility amplitude—see Eq. ( 1 ). Across semi-analytic equatorial emission models, we find that w_{b} is primarily controlled by inclination and is only weakly affected by nuisance emission parameters, whereas d_{+} varies strongly with spin at low inclinations and exhibits different (and largely orthogonal) degeneracies. A joint measurement of (d_{+},w_{b}) therefore constrains spin and inclination simultaneously. This spin-inference method is typically subject to uncertainties at the \lesssim\!20\% level for sources with known mass-to-distance ratio such as Sgr A ∗ , consistent with our survey and with tests against state-of-the-art simulations using general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamics (GRMHD; Gammie et al. 2003 ). A major advantage of this technique is that it can be carried out entirely within the visibility domain (without requiring reconstruction of an image from its sparsely sampled Fourier transform) while still relying on data with a clear geometric interpretation. Our approach complements and extends prior image-domain and geometric strategies. Image-fitting and “photogrammetry” frameworks can recover spin in controlled settings Chang et al. 2024 , and equatorial semi-analytic models such as KerrBAM reproduce many MAD features (though not SANE) and constrain inclination but find spin difficult to pin down Palumbo et al. 2022 . Measuring multiple subring diameters can in principle break shape degeneracies and yield \sim 10% spin constraints, albeit with strong mass degeneracy Broderick et al. 2022 . Machine-learning analyses of photon-ring images also indicate \lesssim 10% spin precision in favorable cases Farah et al. 2024 . Additional channels—e.g., linear polarization of the ring to break mass-spin degeneracies at low inclination Palumbo and Wong 2022 and tests based on detailed ring-shape systematics Paugnat et al. 2022 —provide valuable cross-checks. Most closely related to our goals, recent geometric attempts using n=1 diameter and asymmetry alone reported limited constraining power in the BHEX regime, especially at moderate spins Keeble et al. 2025 ; by contrast, our visibility–integrated w_{b} is both easier to measure at low SNR and more robust to astrophysical variations, particularly for \theta_{\rm o}\lesssim 50^{\circ} .